EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Outcry forces EU reversal on olive oil bottles

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 23 May 2013, updated 27 May 2013

Battered by criticism and widespread ridicule, the European Commission on Thursday (23 May) reversed its decision to ban refillable bottles of olive oil from restaurants. Europe's leading farm groups, however, swiftly denounced the change as a defeat for consumers.

 

Last week, the Commission said restaurants would be banned from serving oil to diners in refillable glass jugs or dipping bowls from next year. Instead, to protect consumers from fraud, restaurants would have to use sealed, non-refillable bottles that must be disposed of when empty.

The rules were criticised by the leaders of France and the Netherlands at an EU summit on Wednesday. British Prime Minister David Cameron, who wants to claw back powers from Brussels ahead of a potential referendum on the country's EU membership in 2017, accused the Commission of unnecessary interference.

"This is exactly the sort of area that the European Union needs to get right out of, in my view," Cameron said. "It shouldn't even be on the table, to make a false pun."

Agricultural Commissioner Dacian Cioloş said he had taken the decision once it became clear that consumers did not support the plans.

"This is crucial in my view, so I've decided to withdraw this proposal and not submit it for adoption," the commissioner said as he attempted to deflect a barrage of pointed questions.

"I wanted to come here today to demonstrate that I've been very alive to the current debate in the press."

Cioloş said he would propose revised rules to protect olive oil producers and consumers after further consultations with manufacturers, consumer groups and the restaurant industry, and promised to avoid any unnecessary red tape.

Europe's leading farm and agricultural cooperatives organisation, Copa-Cogeca, said in a statement the decision was a bad move for consumers and accused the Commission of bowing to political pressure.

“It is totally ludicrous that the Commission just withdraws this measure due to political pressure - it has been discussed for over a year and was supported by 15 member states and passed through all the correct legal procedures," said Pekka Pesonen, Copa-Coegca's secretary-general.

"It was really a very simple measure that was positive for everyone. It represented a positive first step in the implementation of the EU Commission's Action Plan to improve the viability, quality and competitiveness of the EU olive oil sector – a product which has many nutritional and health benefits.”

Positions: 

"A stunning decision that unfortunately is part of a dangerous groove that goes against the meaning of Europe," said European Parliament Agriculture committee chair, Paolo de Castro.

"Once again we see that Europe has chosen to reject a rule supported by as many as 15 countries, including major producers such as Italy and Spain," and favour the opposition of some countries of the North Europe, said the Italian Farmers Confederation (CIA).

EurActiv.com with Reuters

COMMENTS

  • A cynic might suggest that the suppliers are more interested in increasing sales by requiring restaurants etc. to have to buy large numbers of single use bottles, a goodly proportion of which will have to be thrown away half used rather than simply refilling the glass jugs. Of course this would unfortunately result in higher costs for consumers but so what, the correct legal procedures have been followed and that is all that matters.

    By :
    Iwantout
    - Posted on :
    23/05/2013
  • "It represented a positive first step in the implementation of the EU Commission's Action Plan to improve the viability, quality and competitiveness of the EU olive oil sector – a product which has many nutritional and health benefits.”

    The EU has No Business to be interfering in such trivial matters as this . They will be telling us next how many sheets of toilet paper we may use to wipe our bottoms , in the interest of conserving natural resources .

    This proposed ban on olive oil in jugs was madness !!!
    How were they proposing to serve olive oil ? Think of the cost of bottled olive oil , customers wouldn't buy it , too expensive . What happens to the rest of the oil not finished , the customer takes it home ? Perhaps the customer should bring their own olive oil ?
    I will not buy olive oil named product of the European Union . Most restaurants that serve olive oil to anoint bread or toast , buy from a local farm or frantoio . Customers who like eating toast with oil know what the oil should be , first pressed virgin , or old cooking oil . There are big differences in oil from Greece , Spain , Puglia and northern Italy , Tuscany , Valdarno .

    Quality of oil served in restaurants is a matter for local food inspectors in each individual country , to consider or not as they choose , Not the EU !!!
    The EU would have all restaurants standardised the same , like Howard Johnson's motel eatries in America .
    It is proposed laws like this that make ordinary people like me HATE THE EU !!!

    By :
    David Barneby
    - Posted on :
    24/05/2013
  • Another example of European Commissioners waking up in the morning and thinking "what shall I do today?" having read Alice in Wonderland the night before.

    By :
    Charles_M
    - Posted on :
    24/05/2013
  • how would this measure if implemented " improve the viability, quality and competitiveness of the EU olive oil sector"

    By :
    Andrew
    - Posted on :
    24/05/2013
  • All true and well... but when one hears that over 20% of the olive oil circulating in the US labelled as Pure Virgin Cold Pressed only contains flavoured "vegetable" oil which has never had anything to do with olives...
    The fraud is rife in the US and apparently in the EU too... This MUST be addressed, strictly regulated and enforced: we do not want to continue to pay through the nose for dangerous, or at least unhealthy, ersatz, mislabelled bad quality substitutes.
    Whether it comes in carafes, tins, bottles or God knows what... just do it!

    By :
    Jean de Ryckman de Betz
    - Posted on :
    30/05/2013
  • Jean de Rychman de Betz

    I am sorry if you and others in America find that you are being offered poor grade olive oil or even a fraudulent substitute .
    I can recommend " Amici Olive Oil " from Pian di Scio , Valdarno Tuscany , I have helped to pick the Olives , driven them to be pressed and have tasted the first oil on toast at the Frantoio , delicious , this is as good oil as you can get .
    You can buy this oil via the internet ,
    http://www.amiciitalianimports.com
    Click on this site and can read all the details and where to buy direct via the internet , you will not be disappointed .

    By :
    David Barneby
    - Posted on :
    31/05/2013
  • .For those in Europe who would like to find the same quality oil , this is the Frantoio where the olives are pressed to make such excellent oil . They also sell in big Gallon cans that are safe to transport or even send by air .

    soc.coop.frantoio sociale 7 ponti molitura olive - vendita olio toscano

    Localita' Grania - 52020 Castelfranco Di Sopra (AR) | mappa

    tel: 055 9147065

    Categoria: Oli alimentari e frantoi oleari • frantoi

    By :
    David Barneby
    - Posted on :
    31/05/2013
Photo: International Olive Council
Background: 

The European Commission has proposed new rules saying restaurants would be banned from serving oil to diners in refillable glass jugs or dipping bowls from next year.

Instead, to protect consumers from fraud, restaurants would have to use sealed, non-refillable bottles that must be disposed of when empty.

The move prompted an outcry in the press, with French and British leaders raising the issue at an EU summit on 22 May.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising