EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Fishing dispute sparks new friction between Spain, Gibraltar

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 05 August 2013

Spain is studying retaliatory measures against the British territory of Gibraltar in an escalating dispute over fishing grounds, Spanish Foreign Minister Jose Manuel Garcia-Margallo has said.

"The party is over," Garcia-Margallo told the ABC newspaper on Sunday (4 August), referring to years of softer policy on Gibraltar under the previous Socialist government.

The minister said Spain was mulling a €50 border-crossing fee and tax investigations of thousands of Gibraltarians who own property in Spain. A border fee would affect tourists and Gibraltarians who cross the border for work.

Gibraltar has complained to the European Commission over what it says are unreasonable controls at the border, saying they violate European Union rules on free circulation.

Spain was also considering closing airspace to planes heading for the airport in Gibraltar and changing rules to wring taxes from on-line gaming companies based in Gibraltar, he said.

Spain disputes Britain's 300 years of sovereignty over Gibraltar, which is home to close to 30,000 people with an economy dominated by off-shore banking, internet gambling operations and tourism.

Gibraltar Chief Minister Fabian Picardo issued a statement attacking Garcia-Margallo's reported comments. The British Foreign Office said it would seek explanations from Spain regarding the measures it might impose.

"The statements ... are the most backward-looking and threatening since before the frontier closed and are clearly reminiscent of the politics and tactics on Gibraltar deployed by the fascist regime led by Franco in the '50s and '60s," Picardo said in a statement. He called the Spanish foreign minister's words "belligerent rantings."

The 1.2-km frontier between Spain and Gibraltar was closed for most of the 1970s and the first part of the 1980s due to the dispute over the status of the territory.

Under the previous Socialist government Spain softened its stance, discussing other issues without bringing up sovereignty while agreeing to give Gibraltar a voice in any talks with Britain over its status.

But the centre-right government of Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy has taken a harder line regarding its claim on the territory.

Fishing dispute

The latest tensions between Spain and the British territory began 10 days ago after Gibraltar boats began dumping blocks of concrete into the sea near the territory. Gibraltar said it was creating an artificial reef that would foster fish populations.

Spain said the reef would block its fishing boats and ramped up border checks, creating long lines at the border between Spain and the territory.

Picardo called for proportionate customs and immigration controls at the frontier, saying they had been excessive in recent days.

Positions: 

British Prime Minister David Cameron is "seriously concerned" by reports that Spain is considering introducing fees at the border with Gibraltar and closing its airspace to planes using the British overseas territory's airport, his spokesman said on Monday (5 August). "We remain seriously concerned by events at the Spain/Gibraltar border," the spokesman told reporters in London. "We are seeking an explanation from them [the Spanish government] regarding the reports that they might target Gibraltar with further measures."

EurActiv.com with Reuters

COMMENTS

  • The only solution in the present conflict is to remove the artificial reef.The land border and the air space to and from Gibraltar should be left open,as it was in the past 30 years. The above complies with the rules of
    Shengen articles implemented in EU.

    By :
    Lech Kowalski
    - Posted on :
    05/08/2013
  • Kowalski, Gibraltar is not part of the Schengen cooperation since the United Kingdom has opted out from this part of the Union law. So, Schengen is not applicable, but only those parts of the freedom of movement for persons that are not part of the Schengen acquis. This means that any Union citizen has the right to pass the internal EU border (with passport or national id card). It is regulated by the free movement directive (2004/38/EC) and has nothing to do with Schengen.

    By :
    Fred
    - Posted on :
    05/08/2013
  • As usual the EU are saying nothing.
    They are quick to send envoys around the worlds hot spots but they seem to be avoiding a dispute between two EU countries.
    They should have been straight in to stop Spain disregarding previous treaties/agreements.
    It isn't in Spanish interests to treat the Gibraltarians this way.
    Is it any wonder that most UK citizens want out of the EU??

    By :
    gilburton
    - Posted on :
    05/08/2013
  • Both sides are wrong - Gib serves little in the way of Uk interests - a way should be found to give it back to Spain - it's like Spain having the Isle of Wight - or Portland bill.

    Spanish fisherman - the great rapists of the ocean - and successive Spanish governments (& French for that matter) opponents of meaningful reform of EU fishing policy. I rather doubt a small reef will make much different to "the hoovers of the sea". A bunch of rocks might give the fish somewhere to hide - dfficult to see (sea?) what there is to object to.

    By :
    Mike Parr
    - Posted on :
    05/08/2013
  • Or the Channel Islands or Spain having territory in Morocco???
    You have to remember that over hundreds of years all parts of Europe have been fought over and eventually borders have been set up through agreements and these have been internationally recognised.
    I'm not talking about the "Disputed" Treaty of Utrecht" 300 yrs ago.
    I'm talking about the agreements made by Spain over the last few years.
    The current Spanish govt. are seeking to divert attention away from their internal problems.
    If Spain wants to peacefully absorb Gibraltar they should do away with the border and co-operate.
    France doesn't invade Monaco or Luxembourg etc.
    It won't happen overnight but in the future as the 2 cultures come together Gibraltar actually "might" have no objections but at the moment there is no chance of that.
    re the Spanish fishermen.
    They have illegally been fishing inside the 3 mile limit.This limit could have been 12 mls but 3 mls were chosen under international agreement and maritime rules.
    It's only a very small area and they "rake" the sea bed trawler style so the reef stops them doing that.
    The reef has been installed to encourage fish stocks because of the depletion due to illegal fishing.
    It's the same type of reef that the Spanish have installed in their own waters so what's the problem??

    By :
    gilburton
    - Posted on :
    05/08/2013
  • The UN Fourth Committee met on 17th October 2008 to determine whether the right to self-determination could have conditions imposed where there was a sovereignty dispute. After a debate and protests from Spain and Argentina, a vote was taken and it was decided that the right to self-determination was too fundamental a human right to have conditions imposed.

    The future of Gibraltar rests firmly in the hands of the Gibraltarians.

    Artificial reefs have been laid by the Spanish to protect marine environments. Their fishermen need to respect Gibraltar's wishes and fish elsewhere. But as we know, this is all distraction politics being used by the government of Spain.

    By :
    BritBob
    - Posted on :
    05/08/2013
  • Honestly, I don't understand this problem.

    Gibraltar has not respected the sovereignty of Spain and has thrown concrete blocks into waters which don't belong to the Gibs. This is in action which must never be tolerated. I am sure that UK would not allow this to happen if they were in the same situation as Spain living with a foreign colony which don’t respect its territory.

    This is just a small action in a list of problems that Gib has been causing during the last years.

    UK has been silent and always supporting its colony regardless of it being right or wrong.

    Spain has finally said "this is enough" and has started taking measures that unfortunately the international press don't see as positive, but that are legitimate and according to the International/EU law.

    Spain has been also very clear; if the concrete blocks are removed, things will come back to normality. Where is then the problem? Why UK and Gib don't recognise their mistake and solve the issue, instead of continuing with an unnecessary political dispute?

    By the way, Euractive should be more neutral and objective with this kind of news. The article looks quite biased and doesn't tell the whole story.

    By :
    David123
    - Posted on :
    06/08/2013
  • http://www.gibnet.com/fish/waters.htm

    By :
    gilburton
    - Posted on :
    06/08/2013
  • David123 are you Spainish by chance, you do not live in gibraltar try being stuck in a que for 7 hours in 40 degree heat, going into premature labour or having a heart attack let alone not able to get your supply of insulin so suffering a hypoglacimic attack, this is not human behaviour,Spain has a entire Ocean to fish in why does it want British waters of 3 miles, if we even enter Spainish waters we are shot at, infact we get shot at by the Guardia in our own waters, please do not comment unless you experiance these issues on a daily basis, this is totally political and as always the normal people suffer Spainish and Gibraltarian alike.

    By :
    loulou
    - Posted on :
    06/08/2013
  • When I go to North West Scotland I often see Spanish fishing boats pillaging the seas at the expense of the local fishing fleet, who mostly operate small boats with a small eco foot print. So when the Spanish Govt. bleat on about their poor fishermen its only because the have fished their own waters out of existence.

    By :
    Charles_M
    - Posted on :
    07/08/2013
  • Again we have ques to enter Gibraltar minimum 3 hours, the Guardia are checking every vehicle, the Policia National are protesting outside the frontier, The EU have told them to stop but as usual Spain does what Spain wants
    Spanish Fishing vessel detained in Gibraltar for smuggling cigarettes - vessel is currently in port

    By :
    loulou
    - Posted on :
    07/08/2013
  • Excellent from Andrew Rosindell MP

    “And so, the time has come for Spain and it government to act like a twenty-first Century democracy and move on from this stupidity, end the nonsense and put this whole sorry episode behind them. If they refuse to do so, the Spanish Ambassador in London should be ordered to return home, the Royal Navy must be dispatched to the waters around Gibraltar to protect British interests and in every international forum and organisation, Britain must use its influence to challenge Spain. We must demonstrate by words and actions that Spain have lost Britain as a friend and if they want to change things, they have to change their own attitude towards Gibraltar.

    And finally, the Prime Minister should make a decision to send the most powerful signal that can possibly be made and show the world that Britain will always stand shoulder to shoulder with Gibraltar. David Cameron should advise the Queen that after sixty years, now would be an appropriate time for her to visit the people who are unquestionably her most loyal subjects on the planet. The message from Britain will then be clear: Britain will defend Gibraltar now and forever!”

    By :
    loulou
    - Posted on :
    07/08/2013
  • Spain has it's own Gibraltar, Monte Hacho, in the city of Ceuta, and the city of Melilla both in Morocco in fact just sail south from Gibraltar and you will very soon be in Ceuta, I say don't throw stones Spain cos you live in a glass house.........now get back to sorting your economy out instead of trying to distract from your situation.

    By :
    monty
    - Posted on :
    08/08/2013
  • UK is wrong... It is pure greed that has never ended in British mentality and foreign policy. Pure exploitation to serve mere and selfish interest of Britain even in current age( albeit being the lap dog of USA) UK is suffering from post=colonial trauma both at national and institutional level. Hidden chronic sense of possibility of losing interest and control in any part of the world triggers UK( and USA) to resort empty promise of restoring democracy, justice and being loyal to EU law and international treaties where all other nations are seen as traitors and undemocratic. I am sorry but if you had this colony and if there is any problem with respect to this piece of land hold by UK for its own selfish national interest it has to bear the consequences as such.

    By :
    Enver Ethemer
    - Posted on :
    12/08/2013
  • The treaty has been maintained for 300 years. The people of the rock want to remain under British sovereignty and have democratically voted to do so. The concrete blocks were dropped in Gibraltan waters. It seems Spain is using its size a bullying Gibraltar as its fisherman can't fish in Gibraltan waters.

    This is Spain diverting attention. But what is worse is the hypocrisy of claiming colonialism by wanting to force their sovereignty on people who don't want it.

    By :
    Nate
    - Posted on :
    12/08/2013
  • The treaty has been maintained for 300 years. The people of the rock want to remain under British sovereignty and have democratically voted to do so. The concrete blocks were dropped in Gibraltan waters. It seems Spain is using its size a bullying Gibraltar as its fisherman can't fish in Gibraltan waters.

    This is Spain diverting attention. But what is worse is the hypocrisy of claiming colonialism by wanting to force their sovereignty on people who don't want it.

    By :
    Nate
    - Posted on :
    12/08/2013
  • The People of Gibraltar do not want to be a part of Spain, they are independent of it and every time Spain tries to carry out a land grab they oppose it. In the 70's it was clearly shown by the Spanish gates being locked and the Gibraltan gates rusted open Gibraltar has never stopped spanish people going there it has always been the opposite, Gibraltar has a right to defend its own waters. The eussr is showing what a failure it is by not telling Spain to back off.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    13/08/2013
  • Gibraltar is Spains territory despite treaty as Catalunya's belongs to Spain !
    Who take the right to forbbid the fisheries ON THEIR OWN WATER ???
    The water doesn't belong not only to fucking arrogant Britts!
    IT's merely spanish water!!

    Now teaching people about "independenciieess" when it comes the liberty of fishing is illogic in arroganti manner!

    Sems In their proudness they even ignore their lack of RESPECT ! Do they have ? Of course No !!!
    As even they killed a lot of Scotts and Americans !!
    They are proud Bandits!
    All for them but nothing for others !! I call this SELFISH!

    So i suggest impose not only 50€ fees to this rock entry but 150 Euro fees ;-)

    FUCK the United Kingdoom and the ARROGANT British people as even their marine!

    Hey Barry Davies !You are an arrogant ignorant motherfucker who even don't know what cheese is made about!

    I would suggest European Union makes the treaty for an United Federal Europe which GB out of it and have no say so these arrogant britts can sting the rock on their own fucking arshole but let the spanish people fishing in peace ! ... and burn all damn arrogant British flag !

    By :
    United Alliance !
    - Posted on :
    23/08/2013
  • While UK doesn't make real part of the European Union and don't want an United Europe ,
    while UK is acting in arrogantly manner blocking the fisheries for spanish people on international water and this in a selfish manner ...
    then it is totally legal that the spanish governement can impose fees as they want ! The more fees the better ....! Seems 50€ is not expensiv enough !119€ would be adequate for the indemnisation to spanish fishers
    I would call this a " Rock visit " fee or "fisherie indemnisation" !
    The bill for an arrogancy is always expensiv in Europe !!
    Now why are they complainin' AGAIN about this ??
    More fees please!

    By :
    an european
    - Posted on :
    23/08/2013
  • Gibraltar does not belong to Spain, just because it is attached to it, as is Portugal and France or are you claiming them as well Gibralter has a right to say who fishes in its waters which are not Spains. Only Arrogant Spanish people who have been told time after time by the Gibraltans that they want to be independent not just a part of Spain think they have the right to overule what the independant nation wants, this sort of behaviour belongs in the middle ages not the 21st century.

    While the Spanish arrogantly steal fish from other nations waters they demand that theirs are left alone, it seems that being broke and having to be bailed out by our money has made the Spanish think they can do what they like. Keep to your own country and forget about invading others.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    24/08/2013
  • Gibraltar does not belong to Spain, just because it is attached to it, as is Portugal and France or are you claiming them as well Gibralter has a right to say who fishes in its waters which are not Spains. Only Arrogant Spanish people who have been told time after time by the Gibraltans that they want to be independent not just a part of Spain think they have the right to overule what the independant nation wants, this sort of behaviour belongs in the middle ages not the 21st century.

    While the Spanish arrogantly steal fish from other nations waters they demand that theirs are left alone, it seems that being broke and having to be bailed out by our money has made the Spanish think they can do what they like. Keep to your own country and forget about invading others.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    24/08/2013
  • What does ENgland have to do with Gibraltar? Can someone answer this? I mean why is UK there in Falklands?

    COme on? then spain has the right to take Galler and say ok galler does not necessarily belong to UK just cos it is attached

    By :
    e
    - Posted on :
    24/08/2013
  • The United Kingdom, not England, has had a link with both the Falklands which are not argentinian, and Gibraltar which is not Spanish for centuries. Go and learn some history for yourself. I don't know of anywhere in the world Called Galler.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    24/08/2013
  • Well what does UK have to with Gibraltar then? Why is UK there? It is sole arrogance and chronic vicious insatiable need for exploitation and manipulation. It has nothing to do with free will of people in Gibraltar deciding for its future.. UK has always been and will always be a problem nation for worl history. Brining demise, chaos and detriment but nothing else.It has even done so in Northern Ireland. Main British interest lies with brining disaster but nothing else to anywhere they have been to. So this is another incident and example of how UK should just get the hell out of all those places and just try to focus on its business. It has ripped and thieved all those nations in all over the world for centuries. do you think British people are wise enough to create today's England? So naturally they will not give up on anything they have a grasp off

    By :
    e
    - Posted on :
    24/08/2013
  • to hell with the british arrogance of Gibros ! Nuke them and the rock ....

    By :
    United Alliance
    - Posted on :
    25/08/2013
  • Well e the people of Gibralter have been asked and they cateorically don't want to be a part of Spain, or does democracy only work when the answer is the right one for you just like the unelected political failures who make up the eussr commission didn't accept the democratic rejection of the constitution. Spain wanting to fish in Gibralters waters and take over the country has nothing to do with the free will of the people it is just a means of taking the Spanish peoples vision away from all the things their government and the eussr have done to make their lives bad. You clearly know nothing about Northern Ireland, and You clearly don't understand that the British people are made up out of 4 nations not England but then your whole argument is fiction so that is not surprising.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    26/08/2013
  • i am not suprised why such violent conflict erupted in N. Ireland and why Scotish wants to detach. I hope they do and UK demises into ashes and loses its last hope to become the detriment to the world and loses its hope to become a vicious insatiable colonial mice.

    By :
    e
    - Posted on :
    26/08/2013
  • e - planty of violent conflicts elsewhere, regular riots in Paris, neo nazi murders in Germany, gay & Roma persecution in Eastern Europe, etc. Talk sense or don't bother. Where are these mice you have been spotting?

    By :
    Charles_M
    - Posted on :
    27/08/2013
  • and they all go back to colonialism and unyielding desire of westerner nations to exploit. All these that you have been mentioning has been the post-colonial vile of former colonial nations. Post-colonial exploitation has occurred on a different par right after the WWII where mostly Indian and Carribean former colonies had to provide cheap labor to colonial masters. The exodus and mass migration has occurred which is the case in the UK. Lethargic white race had to use and manipulate manpower to survive economically. Well worst is that all these nations,like Germany has no such world presence and still vicious hunger to rule and cause distraction and damage like vulgar and crude British. Whether you argue the contrary or not this is the world=wide sentiment towards Britain. I would not feel that strong if Britain had the power but if it was not the US then Britain would account to nothing. I think I am talking absolute sense. You need to take off your visors and see things from a multi-perspective standpoint. Sorry but UK is a big problem for the world. Hippocratic and swindler charlatan ever

    By :
    Enver Ethemer
    - Posted on :
    27/08/2013
  • Good boy
    British overseas territory Gibraltar could open its waters to Spanish fishermen again by October, its chief minister was cited as saying on Friday (23 August), offering a chance that the dispute with Spain – which lays claim to the rocky outpost – might be nearing resolution.

    By :
    Enver Ethemer
    - Posted on :
    27/08/2013
  • I feel more than happy, the dispute soon will come to
    an End, and nearly - according my earlier suggestions.
    Some of the Readers I can inform, I have visited Gibraltar few years ago to renew the memories of 1943 air crash, in which general W. Sikorski prime minister of Poland, was killed.
    I am from Poland and have the experience on crossing the border, between La Linea and Gibraltar.
    I avail this opportunity to appreciate all your
    comments on this subject.

    By :
    Lech Kowalski
    - Posted on :
    27/08/2013
  • e you have no clue of why the conflict started in Northern Ireland, unless you look at the basques, and Catalans and why they want to be independant of Spain, although they are forced to stay in spain against their will, now Spain wants to annexe another free nation to be part of Spain their colonialism belongs in another era.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    27/08/2013
  • What ?? Do you say i've no clue about the basque or catalans ??!!!
    Catalunya is spanish region and belong to Spain ! Sorry!
    Quieres una respesta en castellano , desgraciado ?

    I'm a mixed Pro-European

    You see, i go every year in Spain and know well what mostly people thinks about Spains Catalunya as even that undemocratic Utrecht Treaty in which the King ceded Gibraltar to your arrogant Westminster this piece of Rock 300 Years ago without even telling spanish people!!
    There is a discussion about "IF legitimacy!!

    But the main problem is that British arrogance in not letting Spanish fishing on their own water or simply international water! It doesn't mention on the treaty that the water was ceeding too !

    So it's only democratic when it comes to british interests!!

    Believe me! The Spanish Gov will not make that mistake again for Catalunya ! And If some catalans becomes noisy the Guardia Civil or army is there for law and order !

    UK made a treaty as well in the European Union!!
    Hmm... Cameron allowed a referendum on 2017 !

    !Well let's then give a referendum to spanish people too ..about Gibraltar !!

    You're an undemocratic SELFISH MASTER Mr.Davies as well the british pluribus anus flag....

    El Plurbus Unum
    ;-)

    By :
    United Alliance
    - Posted on :
    28/08/2013
  • loulou Posted on : 07/08/2013
    In an recently reporting there was a british woman who wanted to smuggled british Cocaine from Gibraltar to the Spain entry Border as well !

    What's Your uneducated Point! Hi.o .e P.ta ?

    By :
    United Alliance
    - Posted on :
    28/08/2013
  • So the arrogant Spanish think they have a right to march into an independant nation and demand its land and fishing grounds, this type of colonialism ended a long time ago, and these days is not acceptable to any nation. Istated clearly that you had no idea of what the troubles in Northern Ireland was about, Ulster like Gibralter wanted to be part of The UK. Catalunya and the Basque country have many people who would like to be independant of Spain, but the democratic process seems to be ignored by Spain when it comes to them enslaving people.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    28/08/2013
  • the deal is over sadly and GIbraltar is letting Spanish fishermen soon. Sorry Brits US was not there to help you

    Cry in the gardens of White House not in rocks of Gibraltar. Maybe they could give you guys a little lollipop(Obama)

    By :
    Enver Ethemer
    - Posted on :
    28/08/2013
  • What a crass and stupid statement Enver, it is people like you who support the eussr.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    28/08/2013
  • do not be sorry barry davies

    By :
    Enver Ethemer
    - Posted on :
    28/08/2013
  • Clearly you do not understand the English language Enver, you make idiotic statements nothing else because of your failure to understand. Gibralter made the decision to allow some fishing in their waters by the Spanish it had nothing to do with the UK or the US, but as you are undoubtedly one of the eussr lefties you blame all the shortcomings of the eussr stupidity on the US. The Spanish colonialism has nothing to do with the US it is just a failing nation trying to cover up its own shortcomings by attacking a smaller nation.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    28/08/2013
  • Whatever. It makes me happy that you are making enough contribution with your perfect English. Anyway deal is on its way and Gibraltar is making concessions apparently. In general, all European economics are failing I guess and UK is no exception to this. My comments run on a different point. Of course Spain was a colonial power like UK. Germany was a colonial nation although not as big but both Spain and Germany seem not to be interfering as much as Britain does into every single thing. I think this is clearly a post-colonial chronic trauma. In link to this, I said is there any need to be in every corner of the world? has this been a role crafted for UK or is it something that is self-assumed in shadow of USA? If it was not USA would UK be as much present in world affairs? And if it is omnipresent then what is its interest?
    Above all, I guess Gibraltar issue is coming to a resolution which both works for Spain and UK and EU in general. I am happy that residents of Gibraltar have came to common sense regardless of bullying from Britain.

    By :
    Enver Ethemer
    - Posted on :
    28/08/2013
  • Of course when you look at the Spanish colonies they are what is refered to as third world nations mainly whereas those that were part of the defunct British Empire and adopted British law are mainly doing well as independant nations, now why should Gibralter want to be part of Spain? It seems that the bullying of Spain and the utter failure once again of the eussr to do anything of value to anyone, has forced a tiny nation to accept a compromise. The USA has had nothing whatsoever to do with the bullying of this tiny nation by a fiscally insecure nation, so why do you even mention them, Germany on the other hand by keeping the euro at a stupidly high value for everyone but itself has taken on colonial powers over Spain and the other parasite nations within the eussr. It is a shame that such a despicable nation isn't being taken to the UN where its reprehensible behaviour could be properly addressed.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    28/08/2013
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
A 19th-century siege gun is one of the Gibraltar's landmarks. Photo: Gibraltar.gi Tourism
Background: 

The European Union agreed on 30 May to put an end to decades of over-fishing and rebuild dwindling stocks by 2020, as part of a deal to overhaul of fisheries policy.

The agreement will put an end to annual haggling over catch quotas by EU ministers in Brussels, widely blamed for putting short-term economic interests above the long-term health of Europe's fish stocks.

The reform will also see a massive reduction in the wasteful practice known as discarding, which sees European fishermen throw almost 2 million tonnes of unwanted fish back into the sea each year - often dead or dying - as they seek to fill strict quotas with the most valuable species.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising