EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Bulgaria News
Turkey News
Germany News
Spain News
France News
United Kingdom News
Poland News
Czech Republic News
Slovakia News
Hungary News
Romania News
Serbia News
Greece News
Italy News
Bulgaria Turkey Germany Spain France United Kingdom Poland Czech Republic Slovakia Hungary Romania Serbia Greece Italy
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Russia makes emissions pledge, but WTO confusion remains

Published 19 November 2009
Printer-friendly versionSend to friend

Russia set a new target for reducing its greenhouse gas emissions at a summit with the European Union yesterday (18 November), but failed to clear up confusion over its plans to join the World Trade Organisation.

The EU said the promise to make further reductions to those planned was a boost for climate talks in Copenhagen next month, and the good atmosphere at the meeting was a sharp contrast to previous EU-Russia summits that have been marred by disputes. 

The EU also welcomed Russian President Dmitry Medvedev's commitment to join the WTO quickly but he failed to answer their questions about whether Moscow would join as a separate state or as part of a customs union with Belarus and Kazakhstan. 

One sour note at the talks in Stockholm was a disagreement over human rights, with the EU expressing concern over the situation in Russia. But the sides said they hoped soon to agree a new framework agreement for economic and political ties and avoided any conflict over Russian energy supplies to Europe. 

"With the Copenhagen conference starting in just over two weeks, I very much welcome the signal from President Medvedev today of their proposed emissions reduction target of 25 percent. This is indeed very encouraging," European Commission President José Manuel Barroso said. 

Asked to confirm the figure, Russian officials later said Medvedev had set a target of reducing harmful emissions by 22-25% by 2020 compared with 1990 levels. The previous target was 10-15%. 

The EU is at the forefront of efforts to combat climate change and has urged other countries, including the United States and Russia, to make deeper emissions reductions and to help secure a new deal to fight climate change in Copenhagen. 

A legally binding agreement is now thought out of reach in Copenhagen but Barroso said: "We have made very important progress in our talks with Russia on this very important issue." 

No clarity on WTO entry 

Russia, a country with vast natural resources and a population of about 142 million, hopes to win more foreign investment from the EU following the global economic crisis. No direct mention was made of this after talks. 

Relations are improving only slowly after the Georgia war in August 2008, which prompted Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt at the time to compare Russia's military intervention to Nazi leader Adolf Hitler's invasion of parts of central Europe. 

Swedish Prime Minister Fredrik Reinfeldt, whose country holds the EU presidency, said the 27-country bloc representing nearly 500 million people had urged Moscow to carry out all the commitments it made at the end of the fighting in Georgia. 

"We exchanged views on developments on human rights, the rule of law and democracy in Russia, especially on the situation for human rights defenders in Russia. It's an increasing cause for concern," he added. 

There was harmony, however, on energy issues. Both sides welcomed the signing on Monday of a memorandum requiring them to notify each other of any likely disruption to energy supplies and to work together to resolve the problem. 

Russian gas supplies to Europe via Ukraine, a route that supplies a fifth of Europe's gas, were halted for more than two weeks in January because of a quarrel between Moscow and Kiev, and fears are growing of a new dispute this winter. 

Medvedev said Russia would seek quick entry to the 153-nation WTO but said no decision had been taken on whether to join alone or with Kazakhstan and Belarus, the two former Soviet republics which are part of a customs union with Russia. 

"In my opinion both ways are possible," he said. "For us the main thing is speed. Whatever way is faster, we will take it." 

Russia's powerful prime minister, Vladimir Putin, said in June Moscow would join the WTO only as part of the customs union, causing concern in the WTO over Russia's commitment to joining the body which would open up Russian markets. 

(EurActiv with Reuters.) 

Positions: 

Russian President Dmitry Medvedev said he is satisfied with the results of the Russia-EU summit, the Russian agency Itar-Tass reported. 

On the visa problem, Medvedev said: "We agreed that in an unbiased manner, the existing system of issuing visas prevents normal exchanges between businessmen and between ordinary people. It simply creates problems for visits to our countries. I believe that we should continue working on this both related to ordinary visas and long-term visas." 

The Russian president added that he had discussed the future Russia-EU basic agreement: "All is not bad in this aspect. Since the summit in Khanty-Mansiisk where we gave a start to this activity we have held six sessions. The document is being coordinated on points and on chapters. I hope that we will coordinate the final text of the agreement very soon. Of course, it is necessary to reach certain compromises. The current summit proved that all sides involving in the process are ready to reach such compromises," he is quoted as saying. 

Focusing on discussions on key economic projects, Medvedev said: "We also riveted attention to energy cooperation, the development of energy security and ensuring energy security in Europe […] On this aspect we also reached an understanding because without accord on these issues it is impossible to make life in Europe normal. But of course, energy security will be linked to what normative instruments will be used," the Russian president said. 

Tomas Valasek, head of foreign and defence policy at the Centre for European Reform  in London, believes that although ties have improved since the 2008 Russia-Georgia war, Europe and Russia remain far apart on many substantive issues, the Voice of America reported. 

"They are moving away from the August 2008 situation [the Russia-Georgia war], when the EU, as a whole, condemned Russia for its behaviour and ties were really frozen and tense. But they're not moving back to what they were before - to the status quo ante," he said. "We're not moving back to any hope of a gradual rapprochement or a gradual alignment or strategic partnership." 

Valasek says that before 2008, there was hope that Russia and the EU would grow into strategic partners and form a relationship that might balance American influence in the world. He says today, the two sides are at odds about basic issues like democracy, human rights and transparency. 

Still, they do share economic and energy interests. Europe depends on Russia's natural gas for heating and the EU is Russia's biggest trading partner. Germany, for one, is eyeing closer business ties with Russia. 

"The economic relationship will continue to be the bond. Europe's relationship with Russia's energy exports will increase, in the short run. Europe will certainly depend [more] on Russia in the coming years than it does currently," said Valasek. 

Background: 

EU-Russia relations are marked by the aftermath of the five-day war which Russia and Georgia fought in August 2008. The conflict saw Russian troops repel an assault on the breakaway pro-Russian region of South Ossetia, which broke free from Tbilisi's rule in the early 1990s. 

Russia later recognised South Ossetia and Georgia's second breakaway region of Abkhazia as independent states. Russia has thousands of troops stationed in both regions. The EU sent an observer mission to the conflict zone. 

Another important aspect of relations between Brussels and Moscow is energy security. Last winter, millions of EU citizens were left in the cold because of a gas dispute between Russia and Ukraine (see EurActiv LinksDossier). 

Brussels is also seeking Russia's full involvement in coordinated international efforts to address the climate change threat. The EU also encourages Russia to join the 153-member World Trade Organisation (WTO). Russia is the largest country outside the WTO. 

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising