EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Brussels takes baby steps towards new smart grid regulations

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 12 April 2011, updated 13 April 2011

The European Commission has inched towards a new regulatory framework to promote smart grids in a strategy paper to be published today (12 April) that sets out carrots and sticks to get the fledgling industry on its feet.

Consumers with smart meters could slash their energy consumption by more than 10%, the communication obtained by EurActiv reads.

Smart meters, which are conceptually and technologically linked to grids, allow customers to consume energy away from peak energy times by, for example, programming washing machine cycles to run in the middle of the night.

But only around 10% of EU households currently have a smart meter, despite an updated electricity directive in 2009's third energy package which intended to deliver them to 80% of European homes by 2020.

John Harris, vice-president of Landis and Gyr, a market leader on smart meters, told EurActiv that there had been "enough wiggle room in the third energy package that the member states could do what they wanted – and very little was done on the ground".

This paper was "praiseworthy" by comparison, he said.

The communication warns of "stricter regulation for the implementation of smart grids" by 2012, if member states are still making "insufficient progress" to implement the roll-out of smart metering systems - because of the close relationship between smart grids and meters.

Incentives in the making

The paper also signals forthcoming regulatory incentives for smart grids, a possible revision of the Energy Services Directive, and even a possible intervention to define a network code if progress in implementing the existing work programme is not made this year.

To monitor progress, EU member states will be requested to provide action plans with targets for the implementation of smart grid systems. 

Policymakers see smart grids as a tool to reduce network losses, increase the reliability of the grid and allow large amounts of intermittent renewable power to be connected to the grid. Moreover, they allow consumers to sell energy back to the grid.

Jessica Stromback, executive director of the Smart Energy Demand Coalition, welcomed the Commission's new tone.

"I think it is an excellent start," she told EurActiv, "and as they move forward they will see the areas they need to address for the further development of regulatory frameworks".

Today's communication was flagged last year in a policy paper which estimated that smart grids could save the EU €52 billion annually.

Bridge the investment gap

The communication says that a "considerable gap" in investment will need to be bridged to achieve that because while "grid operators and suppliers are expected to carry the main investment burden" of grids, they are unlikely to do so without "a fair cost-sharing model". 

But according to Stromback, the problem facing smart grids is primarily one of legislative and regulatory frameworks. 

"The investment is there," she told EurActiv. "Siemens, EDF and Schneiders are ready to roll if they only could. They're only being stopped because the capacity markets and wholesale markets which are necessary to sell energy savings are still non-existent at the moment."

Eurelectric, the association representing the EU electricity industry, also welcomed the communication.

But the group's chairman, Peter Birkner, added that "missing incentives – both in national regulation and in the overall European energy policy – are slowing down the necessary smart grid investments".

Positions: 

Jessica Stromback, executive director of the Smart Energy Demand Coalition, was particularly heartened by the Commission's language. She told EurActiv: "We are very pleased with the Commission's commitment to smart energy consumption - they even used those words - and their use of 'demand response' in particular." 

According to Stromback, the development of the wholesale energy markets in Europe will be central to reach stated goals because a functioning, vibrant demand side requires that the sale of energy savings (or megawatts) is profitable for all concerned. 

John Harris, vice-president of Landis and Gyr, told EurActiv that "the fact that the Commission is devoting so much time, effort and thought to this subject is praiseworthy".

One of the problems, said Harris, has been that everybody is talking about smart metering and smart grids but doing very little. "I don’t think this is the panacea that will get everything going but at least there is a recognition of the problem: that there was no real requirement for member states to do anything about smart grids in the third energy package," he said.

"The requirements for smart metering are more concrete than the references to smart grids, but the timelines for implementation are too long. All the 2020 targets depend on the grid. The development of a smart grid is the key to achieving those 20-20-20 targets, and smart metering is the essential first step to its development. The Commission now has to translate its words into investments in infrastructure, and action on the ground," Harris added.

Eurelectric, the association representing the EU electricity industry, also hailed the Commission's turn towards a tougher line on smart grid regulation.

"Eurelectric welcomes the release of the European Commission's Communication 'Smart Grids: from innovation to deployment'," a statement sent to EurActiv read, stressing that the paper addresses the main regulatory elements currently hampering the implementation of smart grids in Europe.

Overall, Eurelectric believes that the Commission's communication strikes a good balance between the various needs of stakeholders involved in the implementation of smart grids.

Monique Goyens, Director-General of BEUC, the European Consumer's Organisation, welcomed the prospect of smart metering but voiced concerns regarding data privacy and cost. She said that "Smart meters will also supply energy suppliers with a truckload of personal data. It is therefore essential that consumers’ data is protected and that privacy and security measures are in place."

"One thing is clear, the smart meter roll-out across Europe will cost plenty of money and these costs must be borne by those who benefit from it, not just consumers," she added.

Next steps: 
  • 3 Sept. 2012: Stricter regulation promised if plans and timetables for roll-out of smart metering systems are not sufficiently well-advanced, as specified in Annex 1.2 of Electricity Directive.
Background: 

Smart grids are digitised electricity grids that enable two-way communication between suppliers and consumers and feature an intelligent monitoring system to track electricity flows in all directions. 

Despite the lack of EU legislation on the deployment of smart grids, the third energy package adopted in 2009 encouraged the long-term modernisation of European grids.

Smart meters, which are conceptually and technologically linked to grids, allow customers to consume energy away from peak energy times by, for example, programming washing machines cycles to run in the middle of the night.

A subsequent electricity directive paved the way for the roll-out of smart meters by requiring smart metering systems to be fitted in 80% of homes where deemed cost-effective by 2020 (EurActiv 25/03/09).

In October 2009, the Commission published its long-awaited funding map for the Strategic Energy Technology (SET) Plan (EurActiv 07/10/09). It earmarked €2bn of public and private investment to the 'European electricity grid initiative' in order to enable 50% of Europe's networks to operate as smart grids.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Videos

Climate & Environment News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Climate & Environment Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising