EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Vassiliou: Immigrants must learn the language of their host country

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 27 September 2012, updated 28 September 2012

Speaking in tribute to the European day of languages on Wednesday (26 September), Commissioner Androulla Vassiliou said it was a time to “celebrate” multilingualism in all its forms, but that immigrants must learn the language of their “host” country.

“We celebrate all the languages that are spoken within the European Union on this day, whether they are national, regional languages or minority languages or languages spoken by immigrants,” said Vassiliou, the EU Commissioner for Education, Culture, Multilingualism and Youth.

However, she also insisted that immigrants should respect the language obligations of the countries in which they reside.

In response to a question from EurActiv on whether EU citizens with a foreign background should be targeted in their native language in election campaigns, she said: "If we want the integration of various communities in the host country, they have to learn [its] official languages.”

“Let us differentiate between facilitating and encouraging and learning of the languages of the immigrants."

Complementarity

Multilingualism is a hot topic in Belgium, where Vassiliou was speaking, both because its capital, Brussels, is the seat of the institutions of the European Union, which has 23 official working languages, and because of the linguistic differences that divide the country. The official languages of Belgium are French, spoken in the Walloon south and widely in Brussels, Dutch in the Flemish north, and German, spoken by a minority close to the border with Germany.

The tensions caused when a French-speaker, or Walloon, does not know Dutch - and vice-versa - are well publicised.

But a different facet of Belgium’s multilingualism made waves in the press this week, when five young candidates from the Humanist Democratic Centre (CDH) presented descriptions of themselves for local elections only in Turkish.

Despite the publicity appearing in a Belgian edition of a Turkish-language newspaper, Yeni Vatan, its monolingualism was against party rules. CDH, an affiliate of the European People's Party, says that "a small sentence" in Turkish may appear in their campaign messages, but its main content should be in French or in Dutch.

“The use of another language is only allowed if it is a complementary translation of all or a part of the communication made in French or Dutch”, says the CDH.

Other candidates have undertaken publicity campaigns in Polish.

“In this particular case of the elections, I think Belgium has more than one official language, so it is very important for the immigrants to learn the official languages of the country”, Vassiliou told reporters.

‘Fact of life’

The commissioner said it was a “fact of life” that English was the dominant foreign language in Europe and that in most countries the youth choose to learn it.

“But this is not enough”, she said. “English is the lingua franca, but I think the benefit of learning and speaking other foreign languages is immense. It provides better opportunities to get to know each other”, she added.

Despite the admirable goal of being pro-integration, many employees of the EU institutions do not speak at least one of the official languages of Belgium, and fewer still participate in local elections.

EurActiv.com

COMMENTS

  • Does this apply also to English people who when go to live abroad generally do not bother to learn the local language?
    Most UK emigrants go to English speaking countries certainly they do not bother to learn foreign languages as a general rule.

    By :
    Walter
    - Posted on :
    27/09/2012
  • très bon article, il faut que l'Europe apprenne à gérer sa diversité et les langues en font partie. Nous n'échapperons pas à la question dans la stratosphère mais grâce à une vraie politique de la citoyenneté et des langues. L'EUrope doit absolument aider à trouver les paramètres d'une telle politique.

    By :
    catherine
    - Posted on :
    27/09/2012
  • Some people may be unwilling or unable to learn languages to an acceptable level of proficiency. That is either their choice or their problem. What governments should NOT be doing is spending money and bending over backwards for large voting blocks and translating things into that language at public expense. Nor should they be providing sustance to anyone who cannot find a job because they have not learned a language. Many expats who do not learn languages do not expect local government support, but far too many do. If you do not learn the language it is your problem to sort out. On the other hand I envy and admire those who are multilingual. My wife always says "you live as many times as languages you speak".

    By :
    Ken
    - Posted on :
    27/09/2012
  • Sustanance, not sustance. My apologies.

    By :
    Ken
    - Posted on :
    27/09/2012
  • Cathrine et Ken,
    Je suis d'accord avec votre avis.

    By :
    Walter
    - Posted on :
    27/09/2012
  • Does Commissioner Androulla Vassiliou speak both French and Dutch? If not, she should start learning as she is over 5 years an immigrant in Belgium....

    By :
    DavidG
    - Posted on :
    27/09/2012
  • Personally, I don't mind learning and using the national language(s) of a host country: foreign languages have always been one of my biggest hobbies! But what I dó mind is learning it in the 'Belgian' way, in bed, by having sex with local native speakers… Sorry, but sex-for-language lessons are not for me!

    By :
    Murat Saralapov
    - Posted on :
    27/09/2012
  • Commissioner Vassiliou is right, of course. Still, to put this into practice is another matter, clearly shown by the Belgian example. Most expats don't adapt to the local (linguistic)culture, even those who consider themselves 'good EU citizens'.

    By :
    tom
    - Posted on :
    28/09/2012
  • Commissioner Androulla Vassiliou is right by saying"We celebrate all the languages that are spoken within the EU on this day whether they are national,regional languages or minority languages or languages spoken by immigrants".The EU Commissioner for Education,Culture,Multilingualism and Youth has not looked in her own backyard-Greece.There are over 1.5 million indigenouse Macedonians who are being denied to learn or speak their own mother language in Greece.
    There was an incident where the bishop of Salonica was threatening to organise 60 buses for the purpose of going to the town of Ovcharani(Melitis)to break down the new Macedonian broadcasting Radio Station in Macedonian language.The Bishop is forgetting one very importent thing,these Macedonians are paying his wages through taxasion,as all Greek clergy are paid by the state.
    She furthere states"English is the lingua fraca,but I think the benefit of learning and speaking other foreign languages is immense.It provides better opportunities to get to know each other".
    Greece is a member of the EU,but what the Commissioner is talking about does sound like a pure fabrication of the truth in her own country.
    Miss Ashton appointed a Greek to represent the EU on Human Rights.This appointee stated"I will not be preocupied with the Human Rights in the member states of EU".What is the EU role on the Human Rights issue?
    Is EU going after an easy target of China as usual,Human Rights in Macedonia,Russia and others?.
    EU must clean-up its own backyard before they will critisize others.I suggest to the Commissioner,fix your own backyard before you can advise others what it should do,or what is best for them.

    By :
    Peter
    - Posted on :
    29/09/2012
  • As I said, I've always been good at learning foreign languages, but I'll NEVER accept those tricks Belgians use to IMPOSE their culture on foreigners! And this attitude is more popular in Flanders than in the rest of the country. Once again, learning and using their national language(s) is one thing, but being FORCED to adopt and practice their culture is another. Integration is fine as long as it is not confused with assimilation!

    By :
    Murat Saralapov
    - Posted on :
    29/09/2012
  • I'm sometimes amazed how little some EurActiv readers know about the country they live and work in. I agree with Ken, Walter and Catherine though. Although Belgium is a tiny country, it's a pretty good example of how enormous challenges are at an EU level. Wherever you immigrate to out of your own will to find a better life for you and your family, as a minimum one should respect the local culture.

    By :
    tom
    - Posted on :
    29/09/2012
  • we expect Comiss. Vassilious force all publications/web/
    video/tv of UE and relatives be edited on all languages. If You want all citizens acess and participate information don´t forget all people don´t speak well/at all other than their own. UE should not be for a minority.

    By :
    antonio cristovao
    - Posted on :
    29/09/2012
  • Learn English! Other languages are useless as English is the main language of everything.

    By :
    Ken
    - Posted on :
    29/09/2012
  • I have lived in Belgium for at least 9 years and I have a véry good idea about the local culture. However, the problem is that knowing and respecting this culture is NOT enough to many local people. They also want you to adopt and practice it as much as they themselves do. But I wasn't born a bastard or raised as an orphan, and I also want my own culture to be respected…

    By :
    Murat Saralapov
    - Posted on :
    29/09/2012
  • As for me, I agree with Peter and Ken!!! :D

    By :
    Murat Saralapov
    - Posted on :
    29/09/2012

Advertising

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Video General Promoted 2

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising