EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Filmmaker says movies can help solve EU's 'image problem'

Published 28 October 2010
Tags
cinema
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

By supporting European filmmaking the EU can banish its image as a bureaucratic economic body and get in touch with its emotional side, film director Wim Wenders told a European Parliament hearing yesterday (27 October). 

"Movies practically invented the American Dream and can do the same for Europe," the German director of such movies as 'Paris, Texas' and 'Wings of Desire' told participants.

"There are deficits in Europe’s image. The EU is seen as an indistinct economic conglomerate that is technical and technocratic, which explains Euroscepticism. Administration has become its image," Wenders said.

"To know who you are, you have to know what you look like," the director said, arguing that the EU could improve its image by concentrating more on the emotional side of Europe.

Europe 'shy' about its cultural assets

"We filmmakers see cinema as a key way of improving and addressing the emotional deficit in people's perceptions of Europe," he declared, lamenting that Europe is "so shy about its greatest asset: culture".

"People are in awe of our economic power, but they respect our cultural power. If only we Europeans could harness this asset properly, but we don't," the director said.

Highlighting the power of film as a means of communication, Wenders said movies not only reflect the picture of society and project values, but also shape them. "There is no more popular or more efficient way of transmitting messages. Images are the weapons of the future," he said.

"This traffic will come to a grinding halt if we don't act now. Otherwise we won't create the Europe we're dreaming of. There'll only be the administration left, and people will soon get sick and tired of that," Wenders warned.

Scepticism widespread

Other participants were less optimistic that a 'European Dream' could still be created.

"People who don't know their history are condemned to repeat their history. We're seeing nationalist forces rise again in Europe, showing that we have failed to create a sense of common belonging," argued French centre-right MEP Jean-Marie Cavada (European People's Party), chair of the European Parliament's media intergroup.

"Perhaps it's too late for us bureaucrats to address this," Cavada cautioned. "We haven’t done our job well enough at EU level. We need a fund for the creation of quality content. Look at the garbage that dominates our TV screens," he lamented.

Calling for young people to be educated about the richness of European cinema, Wenders complained that "film is not explored enough in schools".

"We're living in the audiovisual era. We all have TVs and computers, but the audiovisual world plays a very minor role in schools. Why?" Wenders asked.

Bridging the digital divide

Meanwhile, a representative of the Belgian EU Presidency said cinema heritage and the challenges posed by digitisation would be discussed at a November meeting of EU culture ministers.

"We want national cinema strategies to focus on heritage," the presidency official said, adding: "It is essential that member states support the transition to digital, or you’re going to end up with a divide where many screens aren’t up to scratch."

Wenders warned that "the digital revolution is much bigger than we thought. It isn’t just changing distribution, it’s changing the content of what we distribute, and the question is whether Europe can survive this".

"We need to make sure that we’re not limiting the access of European films to our own cinemas," the director cautioned. "Many arthouse cinemas are struggling to digitise and making digital films is expensive for small filmmakers."

The key to a successful future for the European film industry lies in education, Wenders believes. "The gigantic US film industry communicates primarily to kids and adolescents. Our film industry doesn’t do this, and it’s a huge shame," he said.

EU culture ministers are next due to meet on 18-19 November.

Positions: 

"Imagine the outcry and uproar if Europe’s bookstores were filled with 70% or 80% American books. Why is it not the same for cinema? In some European cinemas, half the screens are dedicated to one American film," said German film director Wim Wenders.

"Young audiences don’t consider the option of European cinema any more. For them, blockbusters are the only choice. European cinema is slow food, not fast food. It’s good food, it’s soulful food, but it’s losing young audiences. It doesn’t have to be like this," Wenders said. 

"Kids need to be given a serious chance to learn [the] vocabulary [of the audiovisual], especially now that books are losing popularity among the young. We want film to be a part of school curricula - and not just American blockbusters," he added.

Polish film distributor Roman Gutek, founder of the Warsaw Film Festival, urged cinemas to screen more European films, and for a longer period of time. "We have the goods but not the shops. 1,200 films are being produced each year in Europe, but half of them don’t even make the cinema. If they do, they’re there for barely a week".

"We need to refurbish existing cinemas that show European films. Build more screens. And we need to help distributors to convince cinemas to show exceptional European films for longer. They do not generate instant returns like US films, but they can attract huge audiences over time," Gutek insisted.

"Analogue distribution is in crisis but we don’t have a stable solution suitable for everyone yet," he said. Meanwhile, "state television is trying to compete with commercial TV stations and it is not buying European films," he added.

"The Internet should have more libraries of movies. Of course, we’re already doing this illegally, so we need to be able to do it legally more easily," Gutek said.

Unattached Austrian MEP Hans-Peter Martin said "we need a more pro-European image of the EU. But don’t fall into the trap of Leni Riefenstahl. Anyway, at the end of the day the EU is about waste and bureaucracy. We will need money if we’re going to do this properly".  

German centre-right MEP Doris Pack (European People’s Party), chair of the European Parliament’s committee on culture and education, said "cinema can really attract people to Europe who are not interested in EU affairs. It’s about capturing the soul of Europe".

"We’re happy that we have the MEDIA programme, but we could do with lots more money for it," she added.

A member of the European Commission’s media unit said "cinema is unique as it is both an art and an industry. It is linked to emotions and identity, but it is also a key industry sector which employs many people".

"We’re pleased that cinema is being discussed more widely at political level and we’ll try to incorporate it more into our own media programme," she said, warning of "a long hard struggle" ahead to ensure that cinema "receives the support it deserves".

Anne Jäckel, a prominent author on co-productions a research fellow at the University of the West of England in Bristol, said "there is an urgent need for the institutional to become more political and less defensive in the face of rising nationalism in Europe".

"The role of the European institutions remains crucial in helping to produce films that reflect Europeans’ lives, hopes, fears and quests for identity," she added, explaining that some European movies are "the direct product of EU and governmental intervention in cultural affairs".

An Irish member of the audience at yesterday's hearing questioned comparisons between the role of cinema in creating the American Dream and Europe. "There’s a key difference between America and Europe: in the US it was supported by one government for one country in one language."

Giorgio Gosetti, general delegate of 'Venice Days' at the Venice International Film Festival, stressed the importance of film festivals as an arena for intellectual debate.

"We should be interested in quality cinema. It's mostly European, and it's not boring," Gosetti said.

Italian MEP Silvia Costa (Socialists & Democrats) noted the challenge of cinema digitisation and stressed the need to protect copyright and ensure remuneration for creative works.

Belgian MEP Ivo Belet (EPP), German MEP Petra Kammerevert (S&D) and Spanish MEP Maria Badia i Cutchet (S&D) supported the idea of including film literacy in school curricula.  

Next steps: 
  • 18-19 Nov.: EU Culture Council.
  • 24 Nov.: Buzek to present winner with 2010 LUX Prize in Strasbourg ceremony. 
Background: 

Three films are in contention for the European Parliament's 2010 LUX Prize for European cinema. On the shortlist are Feo Aladag’s Die Fremde, Olivier Masset-Depasse’s Illégal and Filippos Tsitos’ Akadimia Platonos.

European Parliament President Jerzy Buzek will award the prize to the winning film in Strasbourg on 24 November.

The EU's Media Mundus programme helps to fund the European film industry. The current Media 2007 phase provides EU filmmakers with €755m for the period 2007-2013, and has helped fund award-winning films like Slumdog Millionaire (UK), Gomorra (Italy) and La Vie en Rose (France). 

In summer 2008, the European Commission announced it was exploring ways of increasing the share of European films in extra-EU markets to counter the dominance of Hollywood (EurActiv 11/06/08), primarily through the 'Media International' initiative (EurActiv 27/06/08) approved by MEPs in December that year. 

More in this section

Advertising