EurActiv Logo
EU-Nachrichten & Politikdebatten
- durch Sprachenvielfalt -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Réseau

ALLE SEKTIONEN BROWSEN

Sehr geehrte Leserinnen und Leser!

Auf Grund des großen Erfolgs von EurActiv Deutschland findet die komplette deutschsprachige EU-Berichterstattung des EurActiv-Netzwerkes nun über Euractiv.de statt.

Die deutschsprachige Fassung von EurActiv.com wird nicht mehr aktualisiert, alle bisherigen übersetzten Texte bleiben aber im Archiv für Sie verfügbar.

Wir freuen uns, Sie künftig auf EurActiv.de begrüßen zu dürfen!

Euro-Rettungsplan verhindert Desaster, Ängste bleiben

Druckversion
Send by email
Veröffentlicht 11. Juni 2010, aktualisiert 14. Juni 2010

Einen Monat, nachdem die Europäische Union Pläne für die größte internationale Rettung der Geschichte bekannt gegeben hat, verhindert das Schema zwar ein finanzielles Desaster, doch verfehlt es, bestehende Ängste in den Märkten zu beruhigen.

Indebted eurozone countries other than Greece are retaining their ability to raise money in the bond market, avoiding the worst-case scenario that appeared possible before the scheme was announced: a string of debt restructurings or defaults.

But part of Europe's interbank money market remains frozen as nervous banks refrain from lending to each other. Bond yields have been rebounding after a dip in mid-May, and the cost of insuring banks and governments against default is sky-high.

European policymakers are clearly worried and frustrated by the failure of their unprecedented scheme to calm the markets.

European Central Bank Governing Council member Axel Weber said on Wednesday (9 June) that the way in which the markets were taking a sceptical view of the scheme was "incomprehensible".

But analysts say fears over Europe's debt problems and slow growth may have become too serious to be resolved by any bailout plan, however large.

Markets may only start returning to normalcy if Europe demonstrates that it can achieve steady economic growth while cutting its government budget deficits - a process that could take many months, even years.

"The underlying, fundamental problem is not being addressed," said Daniel Gros, director of the Centre for European Policy Studies in Brussels.

"It's a problem of insolvency that is actually in marginal parts of Europe, but it's like a bag of apples - a few rotten ones infect all the others."

A Reuters poll of 52 economists, published on Thursday (10 June), found exactly half of them thought the worst of the euro zone's debt crisis had passed. Others saw the possibility of worse instability, despite the EU's bailout plan.

Energy loans

On 10 May, European governments announced that along with the International Monetary Fund, they would provide as much as 750 billion euros ($915 billion) of emergency loans if that became necessary to help eurozone states finance themselves.

The European Central Bank backed that up by launching an unprecedented programme of buying government bonds of the most indebted countries from the secondary market.

Strong demand at Spanish and Portuguese government bond auctions this week showed the EU had succeeded in preventing those countries from losing access to the debt market. Spain looks likely to meet a 16.2 billion euro bond redemption on 30 July, its last big redemption this year.

But both countries had to pay massive spreads on their bond issues, which they cannot do indefinitely without worsening their debt problems.

Other areas of the markets have continued to deteriorate in the past month. The euro has lost about 10 cents against the dollar, while benchmark interbank lending rates hit a five-month high this week. The costs of insuring against debt defaults by European governments and banks through credit default swaps are back near early May highs.

Policymakers themselves appear partly to blame. Weber himself has criticised the ECB's bond-buying strategy as inflationary, making investors wonder whether the central bank would be willing to step up its buying aggressively enough to offset any fresh wave of panic in the market.

EU finance ministers have so far resisted publishing the results of "stress tests" of the health of individual banks. Many investors think more transparency could reassure the markets by revealing the full extent of problems.

Gros said the rot would spread if governments refused to come clean on specific bank exposure to the debt of various governments and sectors.

"Nobody knows exactly what the magnitude of the problem is, and when you don't know you assume the worst."

And though governments are moving to tighten rules on fiscal discipline in the zone, they are showing few signs of correcting big imbalances in policies that cause economic tensions. For example, Germany is determined to tighten fiscal policy rather than keeping it loose to help European trading partners.

No bailout is big enough

There are also more fundamental grounds to doubt whether any bailout could be large enough to rescue the weakest countries in the euro zone.

In order to reassure the debt market, the most indebted countries are being pressured into draconian austerity programmes that are expected to slow economic growth, putting fresh pressure on their tax revenues and banking systems.

The Reuters poll of economists published on Thursday found them estimating a 30% chance of the euro zone slipping back into recession, a bigger chance than for Britain or the United States.

Given the poor outlook for growth, many investors think the debts of one or more eurozone countries may simply be too large to manage over the long term. A bailout would buy them time, but they would eventually prove unable to repay the bailout loans, and Europe's rich countries would not support them indefinitely.

World Bank President Robert Zoellick raised this possibility in a speech in Berlin on Wednesday (9 June) when he said that in some situations, debt restructurings might be the best course of action - though he did not specify whether he thought any European countries had reached that point.

"If it becomes clear that a particular debtor cannot pay back its borrowings, a managed restructuring, combined with financial support, can create confidence that growth can be restored," he said.

Lena Komileva, economist at brokerage Tullett Prebon, said the combination of slow growth and austerity in the euro zone was deterring many private investors from buying government bonds in response to the ECB's reluctant purchases.

"The euro bloc remains burdened by the toxic arithmetic of a debt crisis that will keep investors away - spreading government default risk and loss of confidence in the currency, government spending cuts, rising taxes, job losses, credit shortages, undercapitalised banks and indebted households."

(EurActiv with Reuters.)

Hintergrund : 

EU finance ministers agreed on 9 May to establish a rescue mechanism worth around €750 billion to protect the euro from collapsing under the weight of debt accumulated in countries such as Greece, Spain or Portugal (EurActiv 10/05/10).

Crisis-hit EU countries have adopted highly unpopular austerity measures, which in the case of Greece sparked violent street protests (EurActiv 05/05/10).

Greece's austerity measures include a two-percentage-point increase in its top value-added tax rate to 23% effective as of 1 July. In addition, excise taxes for fuel, tobacco and alcohol will be raised immediately. Public-sector wages will be cut, as will both private- and public-sector pensions. Labour laws will be liberalised to make it easier for companies to fire workers.

In Portugal, Prime Minister José Sócrates and opposition leader Pedro Passos Coelho drew up steps on 13 May to slash Portugal's budget deficit, including 5% pay cuts for senior public sector staff and politicians, and increases of VAT sales tax, income tax and profits tax ranging from one to 2.5%.

UK Finance Minister George Osborne detailed on 24 May 6.2 billion pounds (seven billion euros) of spending cuts. The next day, Italy's cabinet approved austerity measures expected to reduce the budget deficit by 24 billion euros over two years (EurActiv 25/05/10).

Mehr über dieses Thema

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Euro & Finance News videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Euro & Finance Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising