EurActiv Logo
EU-Nachrichten & Politikdebatten
- durch Sprachenvielfalt -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Réseau

ALLE SEKTIONEN BROWSEN

Sehr geehrte Leserinnen und Leser!

Auf Grund des großen Erfolgs von EurActiv Deutschland findet die komplette deutschsprachige EU-Berichterstattung des EurActiv-Netzwerkes nun über Euractiv.de statt.

Die deutschsprachige Fassung von EurActiv.com wird nicht mehr aktualisiert, alle bisherigen übersetzten Texte bleiben aber im Archiv für Sie verfügbar.

Wir freuen uns, Sie künftig auf EurActiv.de begrüßen zu dürfen!

E.coli-Mysterium: Spanien und die Niederlande fordern Entschädigungen

Druckversion
Send by email
Veröffentlicht 03. Juni 2011, aktualisiert 15. April 2013

Spanien hat am Mittwoch (1. Juni) Schadenersatz verlangt, nachdem deutsche Wissenschaftler bestätigt hatten, dass spanische Gurken den tödlichen E.coli-Stamm nicht beinhalteten. Der Stamm hat 15 Deutsche und eine Schwedin getötet und entwickelt sich weiter - Wissenschaftler stehen vor einem Rätsel.

In deutscher Übersetzung können Sie diesen Artikel auf EurActiv Deutschland lesen.

Alfredo Perez Rubalcaba, Spain's deputy prime minister, told popular Spanish radio station Cadena Ser: "We do not rule out taking action against authorities which have cast doubt on the quality of our produce, so action may be taken against the authorities, in this case Hamburg."

Juan Corbalán García, the Brussels delegate of Spain's Agri-Food Co-operatives, echoed the request, claiming that €200 million each week was being lost by the fruit and vegetable sector, which accounts for 40% of Spanish agriculture.

European Commission officials confirmed that at an informal EU meeting of agricultural ministers held in Debrecen, Hungary, on Tuesday (31 May) ministers from the Netherlands, Greece and Ireland had also indicated that their farmers had been suffering lost vegetable sales since the outbreak surfaced.

Dutch Minister Henk Bleker told the meeting that the country had seen its trade in salad vegetables to Germany – worth €10 million each week – plummet. He also requested financial assistance for farmers from the EU executive.

Commission mulls special measures

European Commission officials said they were examining how special measures might be taken to compensate farmers.

Existing options include activating rules applicable to farmers belonging to producer organisations, which allow for equal compensation payments to be paid by the Commission and the groups.

Other options include countries offering the sector state aid: either within legal limits, or – subject to Commission clearance – greater sums.

Such clearance may take weeks to obtain, however, and sources within the EU executive confirmed that the quickest solution would be for member states to agree for extraordinary state aid to be granted by unanimity by member states in the Council. This would, however, be subject to the ability of member states to make payments.

Outbreak continues, source unknown

Meanwhile, the number of people in Germany affected by the outbreak of the E-coli bacteria is growing, officials have said, with 365 new cases reported on Wednesday, a quarter of whom are suffering from the more serious hemolytic-uremic syndrome (HUS), which affects the blood and kidneys (see 'Background').

In Sweden, 41 people have the E.coli infection, of whom 15 have developed HUS. Denmark has six HUS cases, the Netherlands three and the UK two. A few infections have also been recorded in Austria, Spain, Switzerland and the US.

Scientists continue to test samples of vegetables in an attempt to identify the source.

Stellungnahmen: 

"Until we know exactly what the cause of the contamination is, it would be useless to give way to panic in the face of such a serious situation, especially when it is under such close scrutiny by European and national bodies," said MEP Françoise Grossetête (France; European People's Party).

"These cases force us to strengthen labelling in Europe in order to make the mention of the origin of some commodities compulsory, to improve traceability and better to inform the public," added Grossetête, who is a member of the European Parliament's committee on the environment agriculture and health.

"I have thrown myself into the fight at the European Parliament in order to make compulsory the mention of the origin of the ingredients which represent 50% or more of a foodstuff to protect our fellow-citizens against these threats," she added.

"The fundamental problem is the bacterium, but there is clearly an economic problem arising at the same time. We have seen all sorts of anecdotal evidence of losses. The Spanish minister mentioned something about €200 million each week, the Dutch minister mentioned varying figures between €10 and €20 million and the Greeks and Irish have problems with sales," explained a spokesman at the European Commission.

He said: "Our priority is finding a solution to the problem and protecting consumers, but we are moving on to a second issue, here which is the economic impact of the crisis because it is a crisis of consumption."

Confirming that the problem was discussed at the informal Agriculture Council in Hungary yesterday, he explained: "Where farmers are members of producer organisations there are a number of options within those organisations allowing for compensation which is co-funded by the EU. These can allow for the withdrawal of stock from the market and compensation – limited to 5% of production per year – for farmers, with the EU paying half and the producer organisation making up the other half."

He added: "There are one or two other clauses that the Commission is looking into with the legal service to see if further relief can be given. Apart from that there are state aids: a de minimis allows member states to pay up to €7,500 per farm per year over three years."

The spokesman explained that any further payments would require clearance from the EU executive, a process which "may take a number of weeks".

Other sources in the Commission said that there was a third option: "Member states could go to the next Council and explain that they have a real problem here and need to pay state aids a matter of urgency; if this was agreed unanimously by the member states then it would be the quickest option, but would only be possible if Spain – one of the member states worst affected by the financial crisis – had enough money to pay its own producers."

"We are calling on the German authorities and the Commission for compensation and to reject the declaration of the German authorities last week when the Hamburg authorities said Spanish cucumbers were responsible," said Juan Corbalán García, the Brussels delegate of Spain's Agri-Food Co-operatives.

He added: "She made the declaration without knowing the reason for the contamination and without letting the Commission and the federal government in Germany know, and this means that the protocol was not respected. From that day the market for fruit and vegetables in Spain has been losing €200 million per week and this is from a market which represents 40% of our agricultural economy."

"This market is also one of the few sectors giving succour to the weak employment market in Spain and we are afraid that one in four may lose work over this."

Corbalán García said that complaints could be brought under CAP [Common Agricultural Policy] rules – which he claimed required that the Commission be informed before a warning of the sort given by the Hamburg authorities could be issued – and called for extraordinary measures to be taken by the Commission to compensate the sector.

EU Health and Consumer Policy Commissioner John Dalli said: "All authorities must ensure continuous surveillance, which is crucial at this stage, as we are still working to pin down the possible source of contamination and eliminate risks for public health."

Nächste Schritte: 
  • Next week: Commission officials will explain what special compensation measures might be available.
  • Coming days: Scientists to continue to test samples in attempt to identify source of outbreak.
Hintergrund : 

E.coli bacteria are common and normally harmless, but a few strains can cause severe illness. In many of the reported cases, the Shiga Toxin-Producing Escherichia coli (STEC) gastrointestinal infection has led to Hemolytic-uremic Syndrome (HUS), which usually occurs when digestive system infection produces toxic substances which destroy red blood cells and can cause kidney failure.

Severe cases can cause failure of the nervous system.

The

[+]

Sweden-based European Centre for Disease Prevention and Control has called the outbreak "one of the largest described of HUS worldwide and the largest ever reported in Germany". The sickness is not directly contagious but it can be transferred between people if an infected person prepares food for others.

It is the second food scare for German consumers this year. In January highly toxic dioxin was found in egg, poultry and pork products.

The outbreak has confused scientists because whereas HUS normally affects children under the age of five, in this instance nearly 90% are adults and two thirds are women.

Mehr über dieses Thema

More in this section

Advertising