EurActiv Logo
EU-Nachrichten & Politikdebatten
- durch Sprachenvielfalt -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Réseau

ALLE SEKTIONEN BROWSEN

Sehr geehrte Leserinnen und Leser!

Auf Grund des großen Erfolgs von EurActiv Deutschland findet die komplette deutschsprachige EU-Berichterstattung des EurActiv-Netzwerkes nun über Euractiv.de statt.

Die deutschsprachige Fassung von EurActiv.com wird nicht mehr aktualisiert, alle bisherigen übersetzten Texte bleiben aber im Archiv für Sie verfügbar.

Wir freuen uns, Sie künftig auf EurActiv.de begrüßen zu dürfen!

EU concern over Romanian power struggle

Druckversion
Send by email
Veröffentlicht 06. Juli 2012, aktualisiert 09. Juli 2012

Attempts by Romania’s new prime minister, Victor Ponta, to impeach the country’s president Traian Băsescu – under way at an extraordinary meeting in the Bucharest parliament this afternoon – are rattling the Commission amidst concerns over democracy.

The EU executive is especially worried about the “sequence of events and the quick way in which they were adopted”, jeopardising progress in Romanian rule of law over the past four years, Commission spokesman Olivier Bailly told EurActiv.

European Commission president José Manuel Barroso today called premier Victor Ponta to Brussels next Thursday (12 July) to discuss “concerns” such as “actions that appear to reduce the effective powers of independent institutions like the Constitutional Court”.

Ponta neglected a decision of the Constitutional Court which ruled that he could not represent Romania at the last European Summit (28-29 June). He has also issued an urgent decree, approved by the government last Wednesday (4 July), stating that opinions of the Constitutional Court are no longer mandatory for parliamentary decisions. 

This means that the Constitutional Court will no longer have a binding ruling on the president's impeachment.

The new Romanian premier also changed, in one day, chiefs of the chambers of deputies and the senate, together with the ombudsman and Constitutional Court judges.

EU Commissioner for Justice Viviane Reding tweeted that she was seriously concerned about the recent attacks on the independence of the Romanian Constitutional Court.

Leader of the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats for Europe, Guy Verhofstadt, today sent a letter to Reding following her statement.

“I would be grateful of you could provide us with your assessment of the situation in Romania. Especially since the Romanian government informs us and reassures us that they are acting in accordance with the existing legislation and its European commitments,” Verhofstadt said.

President of the social-democrat group of the European Parliament, Hannes Swoboda, who has so far been supporting the Romanian government led by Ponta, said: “We must carefully monitor the developments in Romania. As S&D Group we have a very clear stance: There is only one question for us and that is whether EU laws and values are being violated.”

Swoboda added, however, that they have not yet seen a violation of EU laws and “do not see the need for action”.

President on brink of impeachment

Tonight (6 July) the parliament is expected to vote on a move to impeach current president Trian Băsescu instigated by Ponta's Union of Social Liberals (USL) coalition. The USL was still consolidating its position in the parliament trying to muster a majority of votes this evening. 

The USL alleges, amongst other things, that Băsescu has acted unconstitutionally, tried to undermine the role of the prime minister, usurped the economic competencies of the government, and disrespected judicial independence.

Băsescu accuses Ponta of attempting to impeach him in order to increase USL control over all the state institutions. 

Were the parliament to suspend Băsescu, he would be replaced for an interim period by the liberal leader and senate president Crin Antonescu, a fellow USL ally of Ponta. 

Antonescu would not have the power to dissolve parliament or to organise a referendum on the presidency issu, and would be required to wait for official Constitutional Court confirmation that the presidency is vacant before ousting Băsescu from Bucharest's Cotroceni Palace. 

If impeached, Băsescu would face a referendum on his presidency within 30 days, making 22 July the likely date for such a poll. 

Backpedaling on justice reforms

Ponta's undermining of the role of Romania's highest court may also affect a report the European Commission will publish this summer on the country's judicial reforms and anti-corruption measures. 

The report has been annually drawn for the past five years as part of the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism – the condition under which Romania joined the EU in 2007 – and by the end of July the Commission is expected to summarise five years of work.  

“Recent developments may be putting at risk the progress made over the years,” the Commission said in a statement issued just hours before the impeachment vote in the Romanian parliament. 

Meanwhile, protesters against Ponta have been gathering in the capital Bucharest over the past week. The prime minister is also suspected of plagiarism, having reportedly “copy-pasted” almost a third of his doctoral thesis.

Stellungnahmen: 

In a commentary published on 6 July, during the impeachment vote in the Romanian parliament, policy analysist Corina Stratulat and researcher Paul Ivan, both of the European Policy Centre said:

"The developments in Romania show that democratic achievements are not irreversible and that the principles of liberty, democracy, respect for human rights, fundamental freedoms, and the rule of law on which the Union is founded are not immune to assaults".

“What is happening these days in Romania is nothing but a fight led by Antonescu and Ponta against the rule of law and democracy,” liberal-democrat MP Vasile Blaga – dismissed from his function as head of Senate on 3 July by premier Victor Ponta - said during the extraordinary meeting of the European Parliament.  He warned the coalition led by premier Ponta and liberal chief Crin Antonescu  - now president of the Senate – have begun a siege of all the state institutions, president Traian Basescu being “the only obstacle left in their way”. 

“You forgot that there is one institutions which you cannot siege  and that is represented by the people,” Blaga added, making a reference to the national poll which will be organised to decide whether president Basescu will keep his seat in case he is impeached on Friday (6 July).

"The president abandoned his role of mediator between the state and the society," social-democrat MP Dan Şova said during the extraordinary parliamentary meeting. Citing articles from the Constitution, Şova said the move to impeach the president, along with putting him through a referendum is legal. 

Ana-Maria Tolbaru

COMMENTS

  • I think it is obvious why the Cooperation and Verification Mechanism was put in place. Romania is not yet ready to take it's place with the Free World countries. The politicians and leaders of Romania should be shown what democracy is and why it is supported. Then after careful examination, the Constitution and laws of Romania should be examined and where necessary, changed to make a more democratic society. Until this happens, the country should be suspended from all funding and be under sanctions, where EU priviliges such as voting, attending meetings, the Euro, Schengen, ESA, etcetera should be revoked until the rule of law is secured.

    By :
    Julien J. Houle
    - Posted on :
    06/07/2012
  • Who ever heard of liberals making alliance with the socialists ONLY for the single purpose to grab power and nothing beyond this..no agenda on the economy, it's a country in full crisis, no agenda on social policies, or medicare or justice..Finally, when some incredibly corrupt people are sacked and jailed, there come these people reversing all the progress we did in the past 22 years....How is it possible that a handful of people can by their own intentions make such tremendous changes..
    What we are witnessing now is the very reason why communism worked like a charm in Romania. Left and right is working together to remove all other political opponents and then splitting the spoils..No political ethics, no working together with other parties for the common wellbeing of the people whom they forget they represent there.

    They talk about who should represent the country to the EU summit...read about it everywhere...but not one word about HOW he represented the country, what was his contribution to the summit, what is the impact of what was discussed on Romania..etc etc etc..

    NO content, only a bunch of NOBODIES with plagiated PhDs struggling for power for their own benefit.
    THESE PEOPLE MUST GO. And the Romanian folk is responsible to see to that in the next elections this fall!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Fixing this wrong must come from within.

    By :
    anca
    - Posted on :
    07/07/2012
  • "European Commission president José Manuel Barroso today called premier Victor Ponta to Brussels next Thursday (12 July) to discuss “concerns” such as “actions that appear to reduce the effective powers of independent institutions like the Constitutional Court”.
    What the fuck has Romania's internal issues got to do with Barroso?!! Romania, tell him to piss off!!

    By :
    Don Latuske
    - Posted on :
    07/07/2012
  • For Romanian people from USA.

    Poanta Pontei
    .
    Ne-am intors la teatrul de papusi
    Ca pe vremea cand eram sub rusi
    Caci sforarii din culise joaca
    Cum sa puna tara iar pe craca.
    Ia priviti-l pe interimar putin
    Ce stapan pe sine-i ca Putin
    Care-avind acum un mic lacheu
    Simte ca a devenit chiar zmeu.
    Le dottore poarta permanent
    Un cuceritor suras inconstient
    De cretino-tamp usor senil
    C-o aliura infantila de pupil.
    Deocamdata gangsterii au reusit
    Si-ar putea sa-l gratieze in sfarsit
    Chiar pe cleptomanul Bombonel
    Ce si-a ispasit pedeapsa putintel.
    Dupa care Crinul adormin
    Care dintr-o data s-a trezit
    C-ar putea sa fie Furer eunuc
    De-ar avea o pata sub nasuc.
    Asta-i tot ce ne lipsea un pic
    S-aparem in lume ca la circ
    Eram sifonati si-usor botiti
    Dar acum ne prezentam mototoliti.
    Sa ne vada toti ce stim si ce putem
    Ca am devenit si noi europeni
    Dar c-avem in suflet nostalgia
    Sa reinviem din nou tovarasia.

    By :
    Maur Nelson
    - Posted on :
    09/07/2012
  • Ponta est invité à la commission européenne afin de défendre becs et ongles tous les mensonges, toutes les affirmations tronquées et fausses afin de justifier sa politique de crapule désastreuse pour la Roumanie. Basescu a été écarté du pouvoir pour avoir eu le courage de s'attaquer à la terrible mafia existant dans ce pays depuis sa création par le Président Iliescu et son premier ministre Nastase actuellement jeté en prison. C'est aussi pour sortir Nastase de détention que toutes ces manoeuvres frauduleuses ont été mise au point par Ponta et Antonescu. Ces derniers tentent désespéremment de protéger les complices de toute cette mafia. Un seul exemple est donné par un ami de Ponta et Antonescu, un chef puissant de la mafia qui fut président du sénat et qui vient d'accaparer des sommes immenses (dizaine millions d'Euros) venant de l'UE à son seul profit. Par ailleurs, ce même individu rachète toute l'énergie hydroélectrique de la Roumanie afin de la revendre 40 %plus cher à l'Etat roumain et autres usagers pauvres à qui on coupe abusivement l’électricité pour incapacité de paiement, entraînant le désespoir dans des milliers de familles pauvres et des suicides journaliers. Personnellement j'ai vécu 15 ans dans ce pays et je connais parfaitement toutes les injustices flagrantes dans ce pays. Cette dernière est catastrophique pour le peuple roumain et c'est la raison pour laquelle je la dénonce avec force et courage. Etant par ailleurs scientifique, je ne peux admettre qu'un premier ministre se soit montré coupable d'avoir fraudé sa thèse de doctorat et de donner aux jeunes roumains le sentiment de l'argent facile, ce qui se traduit à ce jour par la plus grande catastrophe dans les résultats des roumains au Bacalauréat où plus de 60 % des élèves sont recalé à l'épreuve du Bac. Après ils viendront chez nous avec de faux diplômes truqués ou achetés et entrant en compétition pour des jobs avec les candidats de nos pays civilisés et rigoureux... Il est grand temps d'ouvrir les yeux sur le phénomène grave survenu de manière explosive dans ce pays...ou alors leur renoncer aux droits dans l'Europe, s'ils ne respectent pas leurs devoirs...

    By :
    Fernand LENOIR
    - Posted on :
    09/07/2012
  • The Washington Post and other international commentators, among them The Economist, have been quick to blame Romania's new Prime Minister Victor Ponta for the country’s current political crisis, which led to the impeachment of Romanian President Traian Basescu. Yet claims that Prime Minister Ponta has undermined democracy and threatened the nation’s economic stability are not simply mistaken, they are also willfully misleading. A closer analysis of the impeached president’s past record and recent actions, as well as recent Constitutional Court rulings on the affair, suggest that the prime minister is defending democracy, not subverting it.
    Just more than a month ago, the Romanian parliament impeached the sitting president, Traian Basescu, a former sea captain who worked with the Romanian Securitate (secret police) before the revolution in 1989, which ended the 22-year reign of communist strongman Nicolae Ceauşescu. Basescu has faced continual allegations of corruption, voter fraud, and impropriety since becoming president in 2004 and was first impeached five years ago following allegations that his then-Justice Minister Monica Macovei was pursuing politically motivated criminal prosecutions.
    Meanwhile, the hugely unpopular President Basescu, desperate to resurrect his political fortunes, has continuously sought to shuffle the political deck in his favor. Having been hit by a series of harsh austerity measures, the Romanian people had lost faith in President Basescu, whose popularity was already on the wane thanks to a series of controversial constitutional breaches, including changing the voting majority required to impeach him.
    Ponta,the new prime minister, who is not yet 40 years old, made his name as a general prosecutor and reformer within the Social Democratic Party, which recently formed a coalition government with Liberal Party under the banner of the Social Liberal Union. When he became prime minister in April this year, he was the third person in less than six months to be appointed to the post.
    Once in office, Prime Minister Ponta quickly sought to focus on policy rather than politics. His priority was to implement a series of social and economic reforms designed to shift the government’s focus to jobs and growth. While pledging to maintain commitments made to the International Monetary Fund and World Bank by the previous government, he sought to promote growth by improving the country’s capacity to absorb European funding.
    In parallel, the new prime minister pledged to improve pay for public servants such as teachers and nurses and to return illegally confiscated money to Romania's pensioners. The hope was to bolster investment and domestic demand and to help those who had been hardest hit by President Basescu's austerity politics.
    The new government’s policies proved popular with the Romanian electorate, delivering a landslide victory for the Social Liberal Union in the regional elections in early June. In response, President Basescu started what can best be described as a vicious personal and political attack on Prime Minister Ponta. He sought to halt the government’s reform agenda, appealing beyond his powers to the constitutional court to block reforms. He also initiated a series of vicious personal attacks on the prime minister he'd appointed just four months earlier.
    As tensions worsened, the Social Liberal Union moved to replace the leadership of the lower house of parliament and the senate and to impeach the president. In the days following the parliament’s decision to impeach President Basescu, the Constitutional Court upheld the decision, as well as the governing coalition’s right to change the leadership of the house and senate. Despite the majority of the court's judges having been previously appointed by President Basescu himself, the Court ruled that the president had sought to diminish and usurp the role and powers of the parliament and prime minister, and that the president had also failed in his duty to mediate between the powers of the state.
    And now,about the referendum:

    About 87% of those who voted approved Basescu's impeachment, but the president's supporters followed his call to boycott the plebiscite. The Magyar electorate seems to have tipped the balance; the two counties where the Hungarians ethnics form a majority registered the lowest turnout.One day before the referendum, Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orban urged the Magyar community "not to take any decision" concerning the impeachment referendum, a call which drew the ire of the central authorities in Bucharest, which accused Orban of interfering in Romania's internal affairs.Basescu is impeached from a political point of view, he ceased to exist. There is a total fracture between him and the Romanians.

    By :
    Max
    - Posted on :
    08/08/2012
The Romanian fight for power raised democracy concerns in Brussels
Hintergrund : 

Leftist Social Democrats and rightist Liberals and Conservatives have joined forces with a view to ousting Romania's centre-right government in the next general election, set for later this year.

The three parties on 5 February 2011 signed a protocol forming an alliance called the Union of Social Liberals, USL.

The USL are to present single candidates at local elections to be held in the spring of 2012 and they are also hopeful of forming the next government.

The first goal of the coalition is to spark early parliamentary elections. Both liberal leader Crin Antonescu and the social-democratic leader Victor Ponta  - now prime minister - have said they would like to see Basescu step down.

The presidential election is due in 2014.

More in this section

Advertising

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Video General Promoted 3

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising