EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Why Somaliland does not attend ‘New Deal for Somalia’ conference

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 16 September 2013

While supporting the New Deal process and welcoming of the donors’ engagement, Somaliland has  chosen not to participate in the Conference as the country’s national needs and priorities are very different to Somalia’s, writes Mohamed Behi Yonis.

Mohamed Behi Yonis is Minister of Foreign Affairs & International Cooperation, Republic of Somaliland.

Despite facing many pressing problems, both in Europe and elsewhere, it is encouraging to see that EU leaders are going to focus on my region today, in a Conference – the New Deal for Somalia, that will sanction a clear and improved framework for international donors’ engagement with the Somali people.

The Horn of Africa has for a long time been seen as one of the world’s most troubled regions. It has been defined on the front pages of Europe’s newspapers by conflict, repression, famine, terrorism and piracy. Thanks to international support, Somalia has made important progress since 2012 but it remains very fragile and in need of further assistance to achieve stability, security and good governance.

To that end, Catherine Ashton, High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs, and Herman Van Rompuy, President of the European Council, will gather in Brussels with a number of donors and beneficiaries.

Somaliland whole-heartedly welcomes the New Deal for Fragile States process, inaugurated in Busan in 2011 by a group of donors and post-conflict countries, as it offers a more effective mechanism to deliver development assistance to our country.

However, while supporting the New Deal process and welcoming of the donors’ engagement, we have chosen not to participate in the Conference. Somaliland and Somalia find themselves at two very different stages of development, and we therefore feel that our presence at this particular Conference, co-hosted by Somalia, would not be appropriate. We Somalilanders have governed ourselves in conditions of peace and stability for the last 22 years, and our country is at the “transformative” stage of development, whereas Somalia has yet to recover from more than two decades of civil war and much of its territory remains outside government control. Somaliland’s national needs and priorities are very different to Somalia’s.

This does not mean that we do not wish to engage with the EU —Somaliland is extremely grateful to the EU for its strong support and friendship across a whole range of important issues.

And it does not mean that we are not willing to speak and cooperate with Somalia. In 2012 the international community agreed to support a Dialogue between Somaliland and Somalia and we held three rounds of talks so far.  The objective is to clarity our future relationship and in the short-term we hope to cooperate on issues like security and trade.

Somaliland declared its independence from Somalia in 1991, after a civil war in which 50,000 Somalilanders were killed, and our capital, Hargeisa, was reduced to rubble by bombs.

That independence was strongly endorsed by a referendum in 2001, and by the results of 5 democratic nation-wide elections held since that time. 

We have built a separate state, which meets in full the criteria of customary international law for statehood, and which our peaceful and hard-working citizens are proud of. 

We will not cooperate in attempts to rebuild the former unified state of Somalia, if it purports to include Somaliland. Nor can we cooperate in any effort to use aid as a lever to force Somaliland to become part of Somalia.

In line with our support for the New Deal process, the Somaliland Government and civil society have together adopted a document based on New Deal principles, the Somaliland Special Arrangement (SSA).  This is fully compatible with our National Development Plan, and therefore reflects our own priorities. 

Our intention is that the SSA will form a distinct and separate component of the broader Somali New Deal Compact, facilitating coordination between the donor community and Somaliland at the level of both government and civil society.  The Federal Government of Somalia has had no input into this document.

We wish to settle our differences with Somalia peacefully and without outside pressure. It is in our interests to see Somalia recover its former stability, provided that it does not compromise our own stability, nor our people’s desire for Somaliland to be recognised as an independent state.

We support the New Deal, and hope to be able to work with the EU in the future to build not only a strong, stable and democratic Somalia, but a strong, stable, democratic and independent Somaliland too.

COMMENTS

  • A clear expounding of Somaliland's view on how to go forward with both the international community and the nascent beginnings of a Somali state based in Mog.

    By :
    Mohammed Ismail
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • Boasting? Not sure what you are reading here. As for dying lonely, folks in Hargeisa are doing rather well and people from other regions have voted with their feet. Regardless of what your issues with Sland are, you cannot deny they have achieved peace and stability in a region sorely lacking in both.

    By :
    Mohammed Ismail
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • History tells us that the Somalia we know today came into existence after British Somaliland and Italian Somaliland united in 1960, British Somaliland withdrew from the union in 1991 after a bloody war to become Somaliland, however the Italian Somaliland which is today's Federal Somali Government refuses to accept that and regards ex-British Somaliland to be part of SFG. The SFG does everything to destabilize Somaliland by giving government posts to anyone from Somaliland they can persuade and supporting armed groups against Somaliland however it has little effect as Somaliland has the majority of its people behind its quest for international recognition. The world can not deny Somaliland for the right to self determination and the Somali Federal Government which controls little with the help of foreign troops risks making enemy at its doorstep. The New Deal conference will not be different from the many conferences before it. The solution of the Somali problem lies in the hands of Somalis not the EU or any other world body.

    By :
    Ali Nasir
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • Somaliland has nothing to do with Somalia and its people will together achieve where they want to be and will have its own seat at the United Nations sometime very soon,its nothing less then Somalilanders deserve.

    By :
    Abdinasir Hangagaar
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • Thank you Mr Minister. You have said enough and at the right time. Hope your wise words will NOT fall into deaf ears.

    As a pure Somalilander, I totally agree with you on your stand about the New Deal.

    Somaliland's destiny cannot be decided in Brussels, it is within Somaliland's reach; the capital and its boundaries. Any outside attempt to topple our system will face harsh and unthinkable consequences.

    Bravo ...

    By :
    Ahmed Shawky
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • That is the fact of good leadership Sympathy. Apart From talking about the failed state of Somalia, Somaliland Foreign ministry put the role of his leadership with a fascinating point of telling that Somaliland is no more a part of Somalia, but as a separate country.
    We, as Somalilanders, argue that the international community biases between failed state and a real functioning country with a democratically elected government.
    Somalia New Deal by EU, will not be decided Somaliland's destiny nor will it do anything else other than boasting Somaliand's support in the international community.

    By :
    Kadar Kaariye
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • The Minister has hit the nail on the head. Well done, Mr Minster.

    Somaliland and Somalia went into union to form the now defunct Somali Republic. The current so-called Federal Republic of Somalia only represents (in name) the Somalia part of the union that ceased to exist.

    Thus Mr M. B. Yonis is correct to argue that this conference is for Somalia, and Somalia alone.

    By :
    Omer Osman Egeh
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • Mr. Yonis said it right at the right time. Thank you

    By :
    Hassan Aden
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • The world should accept the reality on the ground! Somaliland is an independt country and not a part and parcel of Somalia. The sooner that the EU and the rest of the world realise the better. Somaliland needs a deserved recognition. And bear this in your mind, Somaliland will never reunite with Somalia-italia. Period

    By :
    Alamti Aale
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • thank you very much our minister Mr Bihi
    you are speaking our voice as Somaliland people.
    yes we are ready to cooperate with international community every thing except what we can not accept is to unite again with Somalia. now everybdy news what Somaliland added th e region and the whole is the peace and democracy those are not expected to implemented many recognized countries.

    By :
    shuraym
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • Thank you very much for the very informative,excellent article.As Somalia citizen I believe we should let Somaliland become independent. they have shown the world
    22 years of stability.

    By :
    adam
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • Very eloquently said by the Foreign Minister, the only solution for Horn of Africa is to accept the voices on the ground, it is futile to suggest otherwise. Somaliland has no interest whatsoever in returning to Mogadishu quagmire, African Union must stop dictating to us, we will never surrender our independence to anyone, they should ask themselves why Africa is always in civil wars, their stubborn dictatorial policies are fracturing Africa within, Ogadenia, Somaliland, NFD, Eritrea, S. Sudan have all rejected false Union, it is about time International community stop supporting African Union position which unsustainable in bringing peace to Africa.

    By :
    Bashe Ali
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • The International community must respect the democratic choices made by the citizens of Somaliland. Somaliland had nothing to do with Somalia before July 1960 and again since 1991.

    The Somaliland-Somalia union was initiated by the Somaliland people, but unfortunately' it did not work for the benefit of Somaliland - it had fallen a victim to Somalia's oppression, corruption, mass rape and genocide for horrific thirty-years. In short, the Somaliland-Somalia union did not work and Somalilanders will never risk going back to the failed union with Somalia.

    The International community must not waste its energy and resources to accomplish the impossible mission of trying to convince Somalilanders to reunite with Somalia.

    By :
    Dhugtame
    - Posted on :
    16/09/2013
  • Well written diplomatic article that is sufficient to all audience from the word to fully absorb the reason why Somaliland decided not to participate the new deal conference.

    By :
    Abdirisaaq
    - Posted on :
    17/09/2013
  • simply we can say somaliland is not same priority somalia

    By :
    Mohamed Deeq
    - Posted on :
    17/09/2013
  • well done mr minister we r congaralation

    By :
    abdikadar
    - Posted on :
    17/09/2013
  • Mohamed Bihi Yonis for President

    By :
    Mohamud Tani
    - Posted on :
    17/09/2013
  • If you don't want to be part of Somalia, then why bother and put your nose into a deal intended for Somalia. This is like saying "bakhtiga ma cunee, fuudkiisaan cabaa." If Somali Nacayb Movement ("SNM") can dust off old colonial clan enclave and call it a government, then why not any clan.

    "Xoolo kaa cararayaa la soo ceshadaaye, dad kaa cararaye lama soo ceshado." The Issaq clan can take its territories and call it whatever it want, but don't bother Somalia with it.

    It is amazing that the hapless SFG will allow this type of arrangements to be made with clan enclave.

    By :
    Abdi Dhunkal
    - Posted on :
    17/09/2013
  • Well Done Mr Minister Mahamed Bihi

    By :
    Warda
    - Posted on :
    17/09/2013
  • Since last year after Somaliland attended the London Conference, many Somalilanders felt that the West and the Gulf countries are easying Somlaliland into the folds of the proposed Somali federation. Their suspicions were further highlighted by the now infamous "carrot and stick" statement publishedby Chattam House just before the conference; where the report reccommnded to use developmental aid as a leverage to hoodwink Somaliland into the federation by 2017.

    But now, with such a definitive statement by our foreign minister, it seems the lid is being slowly tighhened on the Coffin of Somali Federalism. Keep on Minister, and as my friend Tani said, BIHI FOR PRESIDENT.

    By :
    Mohamed Dualeh
    - Posted on :
    17/09/2013
  • The important thing that Somalia is missing is "SOMALILAND WAS SOMALILAND BEFORE SOMALIA WAS BORN"! Please say it load. Let them hear it again and again. I don't believe that Somaliland history can be ignored so easily.

    Another vital point is, who can change the hearts of our people, our citizens who will die for the independence of their country Somaliland? Nobody!

    Well done Your Excellency Mr. Bihi! We are so proud to have you and Somaliland will move forward because it has intellectuals and leaders like you!

    By :
    Somaliland Big Time
    - Posted on :
    18/09/2013
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.

Advertising