EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Russia-Ukraine: War is 'the only option'

Published 19 August 2009
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

A war between Russia and Ukraine “could happen in the very near future, and certainly no later than 2017, when the Russian Black Sea Fleet is set to leave Sebastopol, as the lease agreement with Ukraine to use this ‘city of Russian military glory’ expires,” writes George Bovt, a Moscow-based political commentator, in an August paper published by the EU-Russia Centre think-tank.

“What exactly is going on in Russian – Ukrainian politics?,” asks Bovt. “Nobody can give a precise answer nor can they explain what really provoked the strongly-worded statement of Russian president Dmitry Medvedev on August 11th.”

In this statement, Medvedev denounced Viktor Yuschenko, the Ukrainian president, for his anti-Russian policy and announced that “the new Russian envoy to Ukraine would remain in Moscow for the time being.”

Bovt explains that Ukraine and Russia still have diplomatic relations but these are in their worst state since collapse of the USSR: “The two countries are much closer to the war today than they have ever been during the post-Soviet period.”

The political commentator underlines that “surprisingly” Medvedev’s statement gave political assistance to Yuschenko - whose popularity is very low - because of Russian president’s “aggressive tone”.

“Russia’s overall understanding of relations with Ukraine is […] potentially dangerous,” Bovt warns. “For the Russian ruling elite Ukraine is, in many ways, ‘the last bastion’, which Moscow just can not allow itself to surrender”.

“This means that Moscow would probably do ‘whatever it takes’ to prevent its neighbour from falling into the sphere of Western influence,” Bovt insists. “Even though Russian politicians recognise the territorial integrity of Ukraine and its integration of the Crimea peninsula, deep in their hearts they have not accepted the idea. Neither has the vast majority of the Russian population."

“I do not believe that any of the current Ukrainian politicians, if they became the next president of this country, would resolve this existential problem for Moscow,” he writes. “None of them would voluntarily give up Ukrainian sovereignty.”

According to Bovt, “there is no solution to this serious problem (for Russia) in the context of bilateral Russian-Ukrainian relations, or even multilateral Russia-Ukrainian-European relations.”

War between the two countries is the only “option for resolution,” he concludes. 

Advertising