EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Driving it home: Hybrid cars overtake fuel cells in short-term comparison

Published 11 March 2003 - Updated 29 January 2010
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

A recent study carried out by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) has shown that hybrid cars will outpace the environmental benefits of hydrogen fuel cell cars until at least 2020.

Even with aggressive research, the university study concludes, the hydrogen fuel cell vehicle will not surpass the diesel hybrid in terms of total energy use and greenhouse gas emissions by 2020. This is because the conversion of hydrocarbon fuel into hydrogen uses substantial energy and emits greenhouse gases.

Therefore, if greenhouse gas emissions are to be curbed within the next 20 years, improving mainstream gasoline and diesel engines and expanding the use of hybrids is most progressive path to pursue, the study recommends. Continuing to work on today's gasoline engine and its fuel can cut energy use and emissions by a third compared to today's vehicles by 2020, the study says.

However, work on the hydrogen fuel cell should not be stopped. Hydrogen fuel-cells are still "the only major fuel option identified to date", says John B. Heywood, Director of MIT's Laboratory for 21st-Century Energy and co-author of the study. But the hydrogen will have to be produced without making greenhouse gas emissions, which at this moment is still too expensive.

In November last year, a similar report was issued by the British Institute for European Environmental Policy. It will take at "least 30 years" before mass-market use of hydrogen fuel cells produces a carbon benefit, the experts estimated. Based on economic considerations, McKinsey's latest report on fuel cell technology, too, concludes that the internal-combustion engine "will still be installed in 90 percent of all new vehicles sold in developed economies in 2015 and remain dominant in new vehicles for at least another decade after that, both as a stand-alone technology and as an integral part of hybrids."

 

Next steps: 
The "vision report" from the High Level Group on Hydrogen and Fuel Cells is expected in May 2003 and will be presented at a conference to be held in Brussels in June 2003. The Commission will respond to the report with recommendations and guidelines for further initiatives.

Within the framework of its Sixth Research Framework Programme (FP6 2003-2006), the Commission intends to spend about 100-300,000 euros on fuel cell research.

 

Background: 
Hydrogen fuel cell cars are widely seen as the solution to environmental problems and could ease Western dependence on foreign oil imports.

The USA and Japan are world leaders in fuel cell research. The US government has just announced it would pour 1.2 billion dollar into a new initiative to develop hydrogen fuel cells for cars.

Total European public funding for fuel cell research is estimated at some €50-60 million per year, which amounts to only one third of US funding, and one quarter of Japanese research investment. To pave the way for more focused EU action in this field, the Commission has set up a High Level Group on Hydrogen and Fuel Cells.

With respect to hybrid cars, i.e. cars which combine conventional petroleum engines with an electric motor, Japan's Honda Motor Co. Ltd. and Toyota Motor Corp. are the leading manufacturers.

 

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Advertising

Théâtre National - Brussels

30 May 2012:
Théâtre National - Brussels

Maastricht

04 June 2012 - 05 June 2012:
Maastricht
06 June 2012 - 07 June 2012:

Lyon

Advertising