EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

EU tar sands vote set for 23 February

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 16 February 2012, updated 22 February 2012

EU officials are expected to vote on 23 February on a draft law that would label fuel produced from tar sands – also known as oil sands – as more polluting than that from other forms of oil.

The EU’s proposal to assign oil from tar sands a ranking reflecting greater carbon intensity has stirred intense lobbying by Canada.

Home to the world's third-largest oil reserves, almost all of which are in the form of tar sands, Canada argues that the EU is unfairly discriminating against it.

Previous EU meetings have failed to get as far as a vote, but the agenda for a fifth sitting of the fuel quality committee later this month schedules a vote on an amendment to the Fuel Quality Directive proposed by the European Commission.

EU sources close to the talks said a stalemate is likely, with no majority either way.

If that happened, the debate would transfer from the level of EU technical experts to open discussion among EU ministers, and the Commission could decide to amend its proposal.

"It's very unlikely to get a qualified majority, which means that this will go the Council," one source said, speaking on condition of anonymity.

EU ministerial talks are also expected to be difficult as objections to the high polluting default value given to tar sands have provoked opposition in European nations where oil majors active in Canada such as Royal Dutch Shell, BP and Total are based.

Environmentalists say there is a body of scientific evidence supporting the EU view that oil sands crude is more carbon-intensive than oil from other sources and that a shift to greener forms of energy should avert the need to extract every last drop of oil.

The oil industry has countered that the proposed law could create an unreasonable administrative burden.

With Canada, it also argues that tar sands are a crucial energy source from a politically stable nation, able to fuel a world will that will remain oil dependent for decades.

Under the draft EU proposal, tar sands are assigned a default greenhouse gas value of 107 grams of carbon per megajoule, compared to conventional crude’s 87.5 grams.

If finalized, the ranking would complete legislation introduced in 2008, when the EU agreed to reduce the carbon intensity of its transport fuels by 6% by 2020 as part of wider goals to cut carbon emissions by 20% by 2020.

Positions: 

Alain Mathuren, a spokesman for Europia, an oil refinery association, sent EurActiv a statement explaining why the group believes the Commission's proposal will have "many detrimental consequences for the EU." The proposed Fuel Quality Directive would "not contribute to reducing global GHG [greenhouse gas emissions] as the crudes labelled with higher GHG content will be reallocated to other markets," Mathuren said.

He added that the proposals would "impair security of supply with a negligible benefit... increase the price of feedstocks imported to Europe... impact further the already gloomy economic situation of the EU refining industry by increasing the cost of feedstocks... further damage the competitiveness of EU refining... create a disproportionate administrative burden for the member states and all other actors in the supply chain... create the potential for a charge of trade discrimination in front of the WTO, and generate tensions in the relationships with important trading partners for Europe."

Next steps: 
  • 23 Feb.: EU fuel quality committee to vote on Fuel Quality Directive proposal
EurActiv.com with Reuters
Background: 

The Fuel Quality Directive was adopted to complement the climate and energy package of December 2008. It requires suppliers of petrol, diesel and gas oil used in road transport to reduce the lifecycle greenhouse gas emissions of fuel by 10% by 2020.

Since then, the EU has grappled with devising a methodology for calculating greenhouse gas emissions from different types of fuel.

Alberta contains almost 85% of the world's bitumen oil sand reserves, which are heavy pollutants. They are also known as 'tar sands' because of their sticky, tar-like appearance.

Because the extraction and processing of these heavy oils, involves huge amounts of energy and water, it has been estimated that they could emit between three and five times more CO2 than conventional oils across their production lifecycle.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Energy Supply News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Energy Supply Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising