EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Offshore drilling spat sours EU-Turkey relations

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 16 September 2011, updated 25 June 2012

Ankara threatened to send its navy yesterday (15 September) to intervene in a dispute involving oil and gas exploration around Cyprus, an EU member state whose northern territory is occupied by the Turkish military. EurActiv Turkey reports.

Ankara's warning came after Cyprus President Demetris Christofias announced that a US firm, Noble Energy, would begin exploratory drilling to confirm deposits beneath the sea bed off Cyprus' southern coast.

The Cypriot press reported that the drilling rig took place in the Republic of Cyprus' Exclusive Economic Zone, under the watchful eye of Turkey's navy and air force. 

Ankara's warning came after Cyprus President Demetris Christofias announced that a US firm, Noble Energy, would begin exploratory drilling to confirm deposits beneath the sea bed off Cyprus' southern coast.

The Cypriot press reported that the drilling rig took place in the Republic of Cyprus' Exclusive Economic Zone, under the watchful eye of Turkey's navy and air force. 

According to a Cyprus Defence Ministry source, Turkish navy ships and planes watched from a distance as the rig was moved from Israeli offshore field Noa to Cyprus' Aphrodite field. 

The source clarified that the Turkish ships and planes did not violate Cyprus' territorial waters or air space.  

The Turkish Foreign Ministry released a statement yesterday saying it would defend the rights of the island's northern part should Cyprus go ahead with the drilling, in what it described as "disputed waters".

"It has been agreed that Turkey and the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus will conclude a continental shelf delimitation agreement should the Greek Cypriot administration proceed with offshore drilling activities in the south of the island," said Turkey's Foreign Ministry.

Speaking yesterday, Turkey's EU Minister Egemen Bağış said that 70% of the energy sources Europe needs are either in the north, south, or east of Turkey.

"If [Europe] thinks that it can reach these sources bypassing Turkey, it is mistaken. If they think they can take steps about energy in disputed waters of the Mediterranean as they please, they are mistaken," Bağış is quoted by Cihan News Agency as saying.

Sabre-rattling

Bağış had issued a similar warning earlier this month, saying that Turkey's navy stood ready following Cyprus' refusal to step back from exploration.

Turkey's Mediterranean warships have played an increasingly visible role in Turkish diplomacy in recent days. On a visit to Tunis on 15 September, Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdoğan warned Israel about its activities in the eastern Mediterranean, saying Turkish warships could be on the spot at any moment.

His warning came as Israel withdrew its ambassador to Jordan over fears of violent demonstrations against its embassy in Amman.

A few days ago, Ankara said it was prepared to provide military naval escort to any future Gaza-bound aid mission, following an Israeli attack on a humanitarian aid flotilla to Palestine in which nine Turkish activists were killed in May 2010.

International relations expert Dr. Harry-Zachary George Tzimitras from İstanbul's Bilgi University suggested that Turkey's stance towards Cyprus' exploration for oil and gas did not only result from economic concerns, but also from Turkey's changed self-image and ambition to become the leading country in the region.

Speaking to EurActiv Turkey, Tzimitras argued that the Turkish government felt much stronger now, both at home and abroad, and argued that opposition to Israel in Europe was growing stronger. Against this background, he said that the timing of efforts by the Republic of Cyprus and Israel to strengthen cooperation in the Eastern Mediterranean coincided with Ankara's gravest warnings yet to the Jewish state.

Athens praised for being cautious

Tzimitras, meanwhile, welcomed Greece's soothing attitude in the dispute. "Keeping in mind Greece's special relationship with Cyprus, the Greek government had a mature attitude which did not endanger improvements in relations with Turkey," he said.

"The current government respects the relations between Turkey and Greece more than the previous ones did. Greece also avoided putting its potential interests in the Aegean at stake," he said.

Moreover, the government in the Republic of Cyprus is also "a crumbling one," Tzimitras added. On 5 August, Christofias appointed a new government, led by economist Kikis Kazamias, charged with leading the island's drive to avoid bankruptcy.

"Papandreou avoided bonding with such an unpopular government. Given the financial troubles present, Papandreou also does not want to have more on his plate," Tzimitras explained.

Greek Cypriot daily Simerini reported that during a Greek cabinet meeting on the dispute, the government agreed not to intervene in the region unless "Cypriot territory were in danger".

Positions: 

A written statement issued by EU Enlargement and Neighbourhood Policy Commissioner Stefan Füle's office last week read that "the Commission regrets any statements that are not conducive to the objective of peaceful settlement of border disputes" and recalled that "the Council of Ministers has repeatedly underlined the importance of progress in the normalisation of relations between Turkey and all EU member states, including the Republic of Cyprus".

The Commission said that "it will continue to monitor Turkey's commitments to good neighbourly relations in the light of the principle of peaceful settlement of disputes".

Greek Cypriot government spokesman Stefanos Stefanou warned on Wednesday (14 September) that Nicosia will block EU-Turkey energy talks unless Turkey makes a commitment that it will not obstruct Republic of Cyprus' efforts in the field of energy.

Commenting on Turkey's intention to conclude an "agreement" on the delimitation of the Turkey-occupied Cyprus continental shelf, Greek Foreign Ministry spokesman Gregory Delavekouras said: "Turkey's announced intention to conclude an 'agreement' on the delimitation of the continental shelf with occupied Cyprus contravenes international law. Any such 'agreement' will be null and void. It can in no way be linked to the Republic of Cyprus' exercising of its self-evident sovereign right to proceed to the exploitation of its natural wealth."

The Turkish Cypriot side is ready to suspend plans to sign a continental shelf delimitation agreement with Turkey if the Greek Cypriots agree to postpone drilling for natural gas, Turkish Cypriot leader Dervish Eroglu's special representative Kudret Ozersay told the Cyprus Mail on 15 September.

COMMENTS

  • I quote: "The Commission said that "it will continue to monitor Turkey's commitments to good neighbourly relations in the light of the principle of peaceful settlement of disputes"."

    That is scandalous. The Turkish side has always supported the reunification of Cyprus.

    As for the Greek side, let's remind that it rejected the Annan peace plan in 2004 (and betrayed Günter Verheugen - the EU commissioner for enlargement)and then, as it was going to be an EU member anyway, it decided not to find a solution with the Turkish side. On the contrary, the Greek side decided to isolate more the Turkish Cypriots by preventing the EU (for 7 years) from lifting the embargoes against the Turkish Cypriots. Though the EU promised that lifting in April 2004.

    The Greek Cypriots have sabotaged the negotiations about the reunification of Cyprus with the support of Sarkozy and Merkel. Several EU observers of the Cypriot dossier, several French socialists of the EU parliament, Jack Straw as well as Marco Perduca confirmed that.

    By sabotaging the reunfication of Cyprus, sarkozy, Merkel and their Greek friends are sabotaging at the same time the EU-Turkey negotiations.

    That is crystal clear. That is the objective of Sarkozy and Merkel.

    To conclude, the EU commission doesn't need to monitor Turkey's commitments, which are concrete and support the reunifcation of Cyprus. The best example is the referendum of 2004 (which was an EU/UN plan). The EU commission ought to start monitoring the commitments of the Greek Cypriots. The EU commission ought to force or at least motivate the Greek Cypriots to show some willingness to find a solution with the Turkish side. But as the EU of Sarkozy and Merkel asked the Greek side not to find a solution with the Turkish side, it will be difficult for the EU commission to unblock that unhealthy and disgraceful situation. By the way, what is the opinion of the EU commission about the direct trade between the EU and the Turkish Cyrpiots that the EU promised the Turkish side in 2004?

    Best regards,

    Cem

    PS. It is very revealing that the Greek Cypriots decided to search for oil and gas since the Turkish and Greek sides are negotiating about a solution at Cyprus. Such a decision can only increase the tensions and destroy the current negotiations. Yes, the timing is very revealing.

    PPS. If the EU of Sarkozy and Merkel wanted it, the Greek side would support a solution with the Turkish side. If it wanted it, it would monitor the commitments of the Greek side.

    By :
    Cem77
    - Posted on :
    17/09/2011
Background: 

The division of Cyprus represents one of the most difficult issues affecting EU-Turkey relations, with the future of Ankara's EU membership talks hinging on the successful resolution of the problem.

The Turkish army has occupied the northern part of the island since 1974 when it intervened to defend the Turkish Cypriot community there against a Greek-led military coup.

Despite repeated efforts under the auspices of the UN to bring the leaders of the Greek and Turkish Cypriot communities to the negotiating table, the island has remained divided since then.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Energy Supply News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Energy Supply Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising