EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Macedonian opposition: EU ignores democratic backslide

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 04 January 2013

Macedonia's leading opposition party has accused the European Union of overlooking threats to democracy in the country, as anti-government protests continued yesterday (3 January) for the 11th day. 

Protests broke out in the capital Skopje on December 24, when opposition MPs tried to block the parliamentary debate on the 2013 budget and were expelled from the chamber.

After the incident, Branko Crvenkovski - leader of the largest opposition party, the Social Democratic Union of Macedonia (SDSM) - announced that his party would participate in local elections scheduled for March only if electoral rolls were revised. He also said the elections must be held according to the standards of the Organisation for Security and Cooperation in Europe.

The opposition would also likely boycott the local elections unless they are carried out by an interim government, Serbia's B92 news site reported.

SDSM claims that on 24 December, “democracy was suspended” in Macedonia, accusing the police of forcefully removing opposition MPs and some journalists from Parliament.

SDSM, an associate member of the Party of European Socialists, also claims that the budget was adopted in an “unlawful and illegal procedure”.

Opposition leaders also denounced what they call the authoritarian drift of Prime Minister Nikola Gruevski, the arrest of some political opponents and crackdowns on independent news outlets. They say the ruling VMRO-DPMNE party has also influenced civil society groups - charges the government denies.

In his New Year address, Gruevski called on the opposition to return to Parliament and take part in the local elections.

Belarus in the Balkans?

Meanwhile, SDSM accused the international community of overlooking what it sees as a democratic reversal in recent months.

This year will be a “year to make or break democracy in Macedonia”, says an opposition statement, obtained by EurActiv. “Democracy, constitutionality and rule of law will be restored, or the country will look more like Belarus than an EU candidate country,” the statement reads.

SDSM blames the government for spending public money in a non-transparent manner for populist projects, such as media campaigns and building of monuments for the Skopje 2014 urban renewal project. The construction of a huge statue of a ‘Warrior on horseback’ resembling Alexander the Great has recently infuriated Greece.

Representatives of several print and electronic media outlets expressed their outrage on 27 December by loudly booing Parliament President Trakjo Veljanovski as he attempted to open a parliamentary session. The heckling protest is believed to be the first of its kind by the media in the 20-year history of the state, the website Southeast European Times reported.

Positions: 

Asked by EurActiv to comment the political situation in Macedonia, Commission spokesperson Sebastien Brabant said:

 '”We have observed with concern  the politically driven clashes in and around the Parliament building, and call on all sides to immediately halt any and all aggressive and provocative actions.  

“While the peaceful expression of different opinions is the foundation of a strong and democratic nation, the use of violence by any parties involved undermines that system and damages its ability to govern responsibly.  

“The EU urges the leaders of all political parties and their supporters to put an end to these confrontations without delay.  We call upon them to behave in a manner that is in accordance with the law, the constitution, and agreed upon Parliamentary procedures, and that takes into account the best interests of the citizens they have been chosen to represent.”

EurActiv.com

COMMENTS

  • Interesting that SDSM draws comparison to Belarus when it is their leader Crvenkovski who is the longest tenured party leader in Europe next to Lukashenko.

    By :
    Djole
    - Posted on :
    04/01/2013
  • It was not the Prime Minister and or the speaker of the Parliament who suspended democracy in Macedonia.It was the behavior of the opposition who interfered with the democracy.The opposition members in parliament were the ones who attacked a 60 year old commission member at the budged discussion,they removed the microphones from the tables.The opposition with its leader Crvenkovski know,that the budged was good for the country,giving them no chance of returning to power.Furthere,Crvenkovski owes Samaras for the money he received from Greece for the purpose of destabilizing the Republic of Macedonia(130 million dollars in 1995).Crvenkovski dislikes any progress in Macedonia that the Prime Minister Gruevski is bringing to the country.Crvenkovski is fighting for his own skin,because once out of government he is facing treason,breaking the oil embargo to Serbia and profiting from it.He knows,his days are numbered before faces the music!One and half year ago,he dared the PM Gruevski to call parliamentary elections.The PM called his bluff.The majority of the people rejected Crvenkovski,and brought N.Gruevski back to power.Crvenkovskis demands are a resemblance with a baby who cries for the bottle of milk when hungry,and Crvenkovski for power.

    By :
    Peter
    - Posted on :
    04/01/2013
  • The eussr despises democracy, the constitution was democratically rejected, and we got it anyway renamed the lisbon treaty, and the only body with any power is entirely made up of unelected failed politicians, for this bunch to talk about democracy is a poor joke.

    By :
    Barry Davies
    - Posted on :
    04/01/2013
  • Branko Crvenkovski is a Hardline Communist who hides behind the SDSM he is the longest serving member of politics on Par with Fidel Castro, yes his days are numbered and only brings chaos and fear to stay in power he is on a path of self destruction and cannot understand the ways of the west, because he enjoys the democratic values Macedonia prides itself on he has eluded being tried for HIGH TREASON.

    By :
    Aron
    - Posted on :
    04/01/2013
  • Honorary Consul of Macedonia to Armenia: Syrian War: Israel or Lebanon will be next? Consul of Macedonia to Armenia, academician Arayik Sargsyan: http://www.yerkramas.org/2013/01/03/arabskaya-vesna-avantyura-ne-imeyushhaya-ni-malejshego-otnosheniya-k-podlinnym-interesam-narodov-blizhnego-vostoka/

    By :
    ARAYIK SARGSYAN, academician, President of the Academy of ge
    - Posted on :
    05/01/2013
  • @Robert Palmer;You are right,you don't know enough about Macedonia,nor Crvenkovski.Let me make you understand the real problem.The opposition leader Crvenkovski and his cronies the likes of Frckovski who was the interior minister during Gligorovs presidency,both were working to destabilize the newly independent Nation.Frckovski was given one million dollars and a Rolex watch to make an offer to Gligorov to change Macedonias constitutional name,Gligorov refused,and right after that,the attempt on his life was made,coincidence or what?. Former Foreign Minister,and present PM of Greece was the donor of 130 million dollars stashed in black garbage bags secretly to destabilize Macedonia.Crvenkovski did not succeed to satisfy his donors then,so he continues to earn the money he received unlawfully from a foreign country,and for that he will soon face the music once his own party will reject him in this coming May,2013.The Macedonian Law forbids to bring charges while serving in parliament,but once you are out,the matter will be brought to court for his and others involvement in corruption,treason etc.He made a promise to the Greeks that he cannot keep,the Macedonian people know what it means being occupied by foreigners.Macedonias will preserve at least one quarter of its rightful land free.In the last 6 years,this government of N.Gruevski has done more than what the SDSM has done in 16 years.The statues in Skopje are Macedonias treasure.They were budgeted,and approved by the parliament.Worth noting,this government created jobs while the EU are loosing jobs.The micro-economic policy of the government has kept the currency stable,keeps the economy growing,and adds more foreign investment,that is called a responsible governance.

    By :
    Peter
    - Posted on :
    05/01/2013
  • @Peter,
    Obviously you have an axe to grind with the skopjian government of FYROM!

    But please that these ugly looking statues and disneyland like monuments are a national treasure is screaming out to us in the rest of the world who visit FYROM the incredible depth of insecurity surrounding the skopjian capital's identity.

    As tourists we would probably not visit again, as the grey depressive atmosphere of the skopjia capital is in stark contrast to the other beautiful Yugoslav countrys like Croatia, Montenegro, etc. Maybe your skopjian government should have spent less in kitschic statues and concrete but more in trees, gardens and wide, green boulevards to beautify the city instead of draping it inorganic decadence.

    In the end the real treasure of FYROM is the capitals skopjian people not these communist styled stalinistic patriotic statues that do little else but make tourists vomit at their utter ugliness!

    Concerned tourist!

    By :
    Robert Palmer
    - Posted on :
    06/01/2013
  • Crvenkovski is a corrupt village idiot who I'll sell out the Macedonian name.

    As for Robert Palmer, he is an ignorant Greek who froths at the name Macedonia

    By :
    Four eyes
    - Posted on :
    06/01/2013
  • Robert Palmer aka Kurios malaka

    Like Athens is any better . You just have a famous pile of rubble about to topple over on a cliff overlooking the Bronx.

    By :
    Four Eyes
    - Posted on :
    06/01/2013
  • All comments are wrote by institutional and party members of VMRO-DPMNE by order of Center for Communication and lies .

    By :
    Ronin
    - Posted on :
    06/01/2013
  • @Robert,these statues are representing our past,present and future,they are beautiful.Finally,we have one part of Macedonia free,and the people of Macedonia can express themselves without foreign restrictions as in Greece and Bulgaria.As you are well aware,the Human Rights in Macedonia has been restored for every citizen since independence,and no other Balkan country can claim same.
    By the way,Macedonia is Macedonia,not "Alvanoturkia or Tatar".We decide on our name,not you!The people of Macedonia did not invite you to re-baptize our name.Macedonia is the oldest country in Europe that retained its name,therefore,its existence is much older than our neighbors.The day will come,when our neighbors will have to re-write their fabricated history that does not belong to them.

    By :
    Peter
    - Posted on :
    06/01/2013
  • As I said before, don't know enough about the politics of the skopjian government in FYROM.

    As for the statues and concrete monuments, historical or not, they are just plain ugly and ultra kitsch. Maybe 4 eyes needs a couple of extra eyes to see through his/her plastic goggles or just a plane trip to disneyland?

    By :
    Robert Palmer
    - Posted on :
    09/01/2013
  • Robert,is the statue of Alexander the Great in Scotland ugly you say,or the statues in Praga Chech Republic,Italy, or even in your country,and the World all over,or it is because they are Macedonian in Macedonia?.
    I find it very ironic,or better,you smell to me like a Greek.There is no Skopja or FYROM,it is the Republic of Macedonia that over 135 countries recognized the constitutional name.We are not Greece to buy our recognition like the Greeks who gave 400 old tanks to the CDR just to reverse their recognition of Macedonia.No wonder they are in a mess that they are.Of course,the EU has to support the spoiled child,as the German news paper wrote"they are like the fly in the ointment".-
    Here is something for you to think;if Macedonia and Macedonians as per the Greek claim are "Greek"why in the world they signed the partition of Macedonia in 1913 if Macedonia belonged to them,and the same goes for Bulgaria and Serbia with same claims?.Show me your intelligence by answering this question historically,not politically.God knows,we know the politics behind it.

    By :
    Peter
    - Posted on :
    09/01/2013
  • Once again as I mentioned before I don't know enough about skopjian poitics in FYROM to be able to make any historical judgement.

    As for the statues, yes they are ulgy everywhere. Statues are the symbols of nationalistic ideologies regardless in which country. The statues and concrete monuments of skopjia are some of the ugliest I've seen.

    This does not mean that the skopjian people of FYROM are any less because their politicians choose to elevate nationalisic agendas showcasing their insecurity to the world, instead of helping the poor, disadvantaged people we seen in the streets during our holiday there.

    After asking many local skopjians in the capital of FYROM unemployment we were dismayed to find out that FYROM has nearly 39% unemployed skopjians in the capital. This is a disgrace but obviously this doesn't seem to worry the skopjian politicians.

    Nevermind at least FYROM has its own disneyland now, and hopefully this will attract enough likeminded statue loving enthusiasts to keep the capitals skopjian population fed!

    By :
    Robert Palmer
    - Posted on :
    12/01/2013
  • @Robert,it is not what you don't like,it is what the Macedonians do like.The revamping of Skopje has increased
    tourism by more than 5.9%,and that is good for the country.Tourists are taking pictures in front of these statues,they must love them as I do and many Macedonians.Before the independence,the Macedonian communists,all they cared was their own position within Belgrade.They brought no industry to the Republic,and the off shut of them the(SDSM)has done just that.Twenty years ago,these same opposition demonstrating on the streets of Skopje sold off what little industry Macedonia had to their friends for next to nothing.The result was,massive unemployment.The last six years,PM Gruevski has brought the country back to life, by improving the conditions of doing business,stable currency,stable banking,and improving the employment by more than 9%.There is long ways to go,but it is better now than a EU member state as Greece.Macedonia has no suicides,and if you compare that with Greece where there are reports of 3,100 people that have taken their lives due to lack of work,Macedonia is doing fine.Foreign investment is coming due to conditions this government introduced,unemployment is coming down. Tourism industry is greatly improved, and the last survey done in Macedonia,57% say they are happy with their lives.Compare this with our neighbors.

    By :
    Peter
    - Posted on :
    12/01/2013
  • This does not explain, Peter, why FYROM still has 39% unemployement. Perhaps the skopjian government should have introduced voccational orientated programs to help the country's workforce and especially the poor unemployed skojpian people in the capital of FYROM.

    It is quite amusing that you would equate tourist photos in front of imbecillic, ugly looking statues to the plight of the skopjian people in the capital. It seems to me you are also probably only a patriotic tourist from elsewhere who goes back to the skopjian capital for pleasure.

    And indeed, you go there for pleasure while the skopjian people are left to struggle with next to nothing,with no or very little social security and with pitiful handouts from their cousins overseas.

    If the skopjian government were as good as you say unemployment would be down around the 10%. But this is sadly not the case. The skopjian people are not well off, only their hypocritical politicians and cronies. For gods sake even, debt ridden Greece (which you understandebly mock) has 25% unemployment, 14% less than FYROM who according to you are living the high life.

    Meaning Gruevski has his figures and fingers in many awkward looking pies, pretty much like those ugly statues that many skopjians complain about.

    Concerned tourist!

    By :
    Robert Palmer
    - Posted on :
    13/01/2013
  • Robert,looks like you don't understand the difference between young and old democracies.It is not easy to build a nation that its people were under foreign influence,and above all,a communist dictatorial regime.Following the independence,Macedonia was still in the same mode till Gruevski was elected.The SDSM created over 280,000 unemployed by selling off industry to their friends and foreign friends.To get the unemployment down to the 1991 level in a short time is not easy.Compare Greece with Macedonia as you have.Macedonia started with next to nothing,the unemployment at 39.5%,and in the last 6 years came down to 30%.What does that mean,present government has performed better than the previous.Don't also forget,the economic and financial situation in the world has melted down,but Macedonias economy has been growing,unemployment gone down 9.5%.Now compare Greece.After receiving over 600 Billion dollars,that is with a big"B"their economy is down the tube,unemployment at 28% and going up to 38.5% to end of this year as predicted by the economists.Even though the problems Macedonia has with Greece,I don't wish Greece bad.I hope Greece will come out from this mess for the good of its citizens,also for Macedonias economy.Macedonias economy was growing over 6% on yearly basis before the economic bubble burst.That trend would have continued,which it means,the unemployment would have been as you suggest or better.
    Robert,tomorrow is our New Year,even dough we are on opposite sides, I wish you a Happy New Year my friend.

    By :
    Peter
    - Posted on :
    13/01/2013
  • Wish you also a Happy New Year! Good Luck with everything!

    By :
    Robert Palmer
    - Posted on :
    14/01/2013
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Protest in Skopje
Background: 

Macedonia first appeared as a country at international level in 1991 after declaring independence from the dissolving Socialist Federal Republic of Yugoslavia.

In official EU documents, Macedonia is referred to as "the former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia" due to a dispute over the country's name, which is identical to that of a Greek province.

Macedonia is an ethnic mosaic. Slavic Macedonians represent the largest group (64% of the population). Ethnic Albanians are the second biggest minority (25%), with Turks (3%) and Roma (1.9%) also present.

Ever since the country's independence, integrating the ethnic Albanians has proved a cumbersome process, and the country has come close to civil war.

The August 2001 Ohrid Framework Agreement, brokered by Western powers, halted the brinkmanship between the Kosovar-Albanian communities in northern Macedonia (organised militarily in the National Liberation Army) and Macedonian forces.

Nikola Gruevski, born in 1970, has been prime minister of Macedonia since 27 August 2006 and was re-elected in June 2011. Since 2003, he has been leader of VMRO-DPMNE, historically a nationalist party, now an associated member to the centre-right European People's Party.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Video General Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising