Dijsselbloem counters Wilders’ EU exit claim

  

Dutch Finance Minister Jeroen Dijsselbloem, who also heads the Eurogroup, has hit back at far-right politician Geert Wilders’ claim that leaving the European Union would be good for the Dutch economy.

Wilders said on Thursday (6 January) that the the Dutch economy, just emerging from recession, would see substantially higher growth if the Netherlands quit the European Union.

"We must become boss of our own money, our own budget, our own borders, and our own future again," Wilders told a news conference in The Hague, pointing to non-EU member Switzerland as an example.

Citing a report commissioned by his party, he said the Dutch economy would be 10 percent bigger in 10 years' time if the Netherlands were to leave the EU next year than if it stayed.

The average annual benefit would be nearly €10,000 per household over the next two decades, he said.

The report by the research consultancy Capital Economics, called "Nexit: Assessing the economic impact of the Netherlands leaving the European Union", said quitting would lead to higher growth by bringing control of monetary policy back to the Dutch central bank and allowing individual trade deals.

"This report proves not just that Nexit, a Dutch exit from the EU, is more positive than stumbling on in the EU, but it also offers the Netherlands an exit from the crisis," Wilders said.

Wilders, whose party is topping opinion polls in the run-up to European elections in May - often used as a protest vote against sitting governments - has long called for the Netherlands to quit the euro and claw back power from Brussels.

Dijsselbloem was quick to shoot down Wilders' proposals.

"The Netherlands is an economic powerhouse in Europe. We earn the bulk of our money in trade with EU countries so the Netherlands has a lot of interest in a single market with easy trade," Dijsselbloem told local media, adding that quitting the EU would be "very unwise".

While the Netherlands was a founding member of the European Union, signing up to its earliest predecessor in 1951, the last decade has seen a eurosceptic mood take hold, exacerbated by persistent sluggish economic performance.

While the government is pro-Europe, Prime Minister Mark Rutte last June called for a "more modest, more sober but more effective" European Union, with the emphasis on national sovereignty and far less interference from Brussels.

Some 45% of the Dutch are in favour of European Union membership, with 37% opposed, according to an opinion poll by Maurice de Hond published on Jan. 20.

Dropping the euro in favour of the national currency would only lead to temporary volatility, Mark Pragnell of Capital Economics said, adding that the Netherlands would not lose the EU as a trade market, given the importance of the Dutch port of Rotterdam, Europe's largest.

Last year, Capital Economics published a report commissioned by Simon Wolfson, a British eurosceptic businessman, exploring ways in which a country could quit the euro.

Advertising

Comments

an european's picture

But the end of a single market would be a programmed Netoxication of their own local economy !

james everts's picture

Nobody should worry. Wilders is politically entirely isolated. If he would win any election, he can never have absolute majority, and not a single one of the civilized parties (his own being comparable to Le Pen's creeps) is prepared to side with him on the merest issue, let alone form a government!

Lost in the maze's picture

Is "Wilders" Dutch for delusional?

Tim Vine's picture

There are clear and obvious advantages for the Netherlands and other countries to quit the EU and / or the Euro. The arguments against such a reassertion of national sovereignty are based on a fear of Brussels punishing such countries by restricting their access to the single market.

At the end of the day, the Netherlands and other like minded countries will have to call the EUs bluff by leaving and renegotiating just the free market aspects of their relation. After all, that's all that the vast majority of counties want out of Europe - keeping their democracy while trading with friendly neighboring states.

james everts's picture

"Just the free market aspects"? Do you know what you are talking about? Why all the trouble now that Switzerland restricts foreigners' access? Your "free market aspects" require common regulation, my dear. Look at what is going on in the TTIP negotiations. A battle about what? Tariffs? No, regulations! Financial services included.

Texas wants to split off,'Padania', Bavaria, Scotland.. Whenever the (extreme) right smells an economic benefit it starts gathering votes around a mono-dimensional, tunnel-visionary split. Will there be a monetary union of the remainder of the UK with Schotland after a split? Of course not.

What the likes of Wilders and the murky Le Pen call blackmail, is the most obvious and correct answer to splitters, because they will continue to show up, now and in 100 years. Out of the EU? OK, but than out of the goodies as well. Nothing "free market aspects" only.

Maartje van Putten's picture

I cannot agree more with the comments of James Everts. However let me give you another concern I have with the Netherlands. While from an economic point of view we are indeed well introduced in the EU and benefi a lot. However the Dutch education system did NOT al all run with the same spirit and educate from primary school to high schools or even at Universities how the EU system works. I believe that even the average member of national parliament does not know the difference between the Commission or the Council.
For example the students at ( Gymnasium) high school for this year 6th grade, last year, exams got a special program about the American Civil War for the entire year. Of course very interesting but If you ask them when and how intensive they learned about the EU arcitecture they tell you it was maybe 2 lessons in the 4th grade. I even recall I have noted schoolbooks in what Turkey was an EU member. It is time for the Netherlands to make Europe a must program at schools. To begin with 8 years old children.

Let us go for that.

Dr. Maartje van Putten
Member EP (1989-1999)

Maartje van Putten's picture

One more addition. I also recall the ratification process of the Maastricht treaty. I went to see the debate in the Parliament in the Hague. It was put at the agenda on Thursday evening almost at the end of parliaments work week. Only the Dutch Liberal party had as speaker their party leader Mr. bolkenstein the later EU Commissioner and for the rest it was mainly backbenchers and no press. I was chocked. Europe is never taken to the public as a substantial change in our being as a nation. That will be ' paid out' now.

Typing on Ipad in Kampala not easy. Sorry
M. Van Putten

Content Partners