EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

EU takes a step closer to curbing short-selling

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 16 November 2011, updated 17 November 2011

The European Parliament yesterday (15 November) cast an overwhelming vote against financial markets as it rubber-stamped a bill to curb short-selling and trading in credit default swaps (CDS),  blamed for fuelling speculation on sovereign debt and exacerbating Greece's debt woes. 

The draft law would prevent anyone from buying a credit default swap – a type of insurance policy against a defaulting issuer of the debt - without owning a stake in the corresponding debt.

"Naked" short selling, purchasing an insurance contract on a security without actually owning it, has been blamed for driving the kind of speculation which increases the likelihood of the issuer's default.

"Purchasing Italian CDS, for example, will now be possible only if the buyer already owns Italian government bonds or a stake in a sector highly dependent on the performance of these bonds, such as an Italian bank," says a European Parliament statement on the draft ban.

Many governments blame CDS for driving up the cost of a country's borrowing and therefore its sovereign bond yields. And the more a country, like Greece, looks like it will default, the more default swaps are bought, critics argue.

The yield on 10-year Greek bonds rose from 5% at the end of November 2009 to 6.5% by mid-February 2010, corresponding with a spike in the purchase of CDS.

But market and UK officials have criticised the legislation, arguing it will do more damage than good. The UK is home to the EU's biggest financial market. 

UK officials in Brussels have questioned the legality of an EU authority's ability to ban short-selling. They are currently suing the ECB over possible curbs to clearing houses dealing in euro currency outside the eurozone.

Financial players, especially hedge funds, whose operations are heavily reliant on short-selling, argue that the practice and CDS are fundamental ways to keep markets liquid.

Their position was bolstered by a report the European Commission tried to brush under the carpet which showed little correlation between CDS and bond spreads.

"The empirical investigation that has been conducted by the task force on how the sovereign CDS and bond markets interact, provides no conclusive evidence that developments in the CDS market causes higher funding costs for Member States," the report leaked to the Dutch newspaper Het Financieele Dagblad said.

But the ban appears to have been predestined by political pressure.

In June, French President Nicolas Sarkozy and German Chancellor Angela Merkel called on the commission to impose a ban on speculation against the widening yields of sovereign debt.

This is in stark contrast to another regulation on credit rating agencies that was waved through yesterday. Parliamentarians and large EU governments have cast it as a climbdown because it stops short of suspending the ratings of countries with rising sovereign debt.

France, Italy, Greece, Spain and Belgium all have short-selling curbs in place. France extended the duration of its ban last week.

The EU ban is due to come into force a year from now in all 27 countries. 

Positions: 

"This is a short-sighted ban driven by politics rather than sound economics. By banning uncovered CDS we will only encourage the creation of new, more complex and opaque, financial products," Syed Kamall, Conservative MEP for London, said in a statement. 

"We have previously expressed our concerns about the impact of a ban on uncovered sovereign CDS. It could not only reduce liquidity and increase volatility in debt markets, but also increase government borrowing costs and reduce real economy investments in EU member states," said Andrew Baker, the CEO of the global hedge fund association AIMA

EurActiv.com

COMMENTS

  • "Financial players, especially hedge funds, whose operations are heavily reliant on short-selling, argue that the practice and CDS are fundamental ways to keep markets liquid."

    A straightforward lie. I used to buy and sell UK gilts in the 1980s (I took a variety of positions - long and short - mostly short) - there was zero problems with liquidity i.e. the ability to find a willing buyer and a willing seller - and yet there was a total absence of CDS.

    You know when banksters lie - they open their mouths and speak against proposals that may put a damper on their gangster-like activities.

    By :
    Mike Parr
    - Posted on :
    18/11/2011
  • "This is a short-sighted ban driven by politics rather than sound economics. By banning uncovered CDS we will only encourage the creation of new, more complex and opaque, financial products," Syed Kamall, Conservative MEP for London, said in a statement.

    A ban against short-term gains which are done on a "beggar may neighbour" basis - the neighbour in this case being countries such as Italy, Greece and doubtless Spain...... Still one would not expect any other comments from a Tory whose party is supported by the UK finance sector (I would not grace it with the label "industry").

    By :
    Mike Parr
    - Posted on :
    18/11/2011
Background: 

The European Commission proposed a regulation on short-selling in September 2010 in the wake of the biggest turmoil in financial markets since the second world war.

Short-selling happens when assets are borrowed, sold and then bought back in order to pocket the difference between the original and end prices.

The Commission has also suggested restrictive measures on so-called 'naked' short-selling which involves selling assets that have not even been borrowed in the first place.

The European Parliament and the member states have since clashed over specific measures to be applied to naked short-selling of government bond derivatives, notably credit default swaps (CDS). Some EU politicians accuse speculators of using these sophisticated financial instruments to bet on a Greek debt default.

On 19 May 2010, Germany became the first European country to ban naked short-selling in shares of the country's 10 most important financial institutions.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Euro & Finance News videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Euro & Finance Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising