EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Eurobonds set to divide summit for growth

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 23 May 2012

The informal “summit for growth” to take place today will discuss several controversial options for injecting confidence into financial markets, including a call for Eurobonds that is likely to divide member states.

The summit was convened to assess the political landscape following the election of French President François Hollande and to pave the way for an official Council meeting at the end of June.

Uncontroversial issues on boosting trade and youth employment by implementing existing EU policies will make way for a no-holds-barred debate as leaders take up Council President Herman Van Rompuy’s offer for a summit discussion with “no taboos”.

Amongst controversial issues set for an airing are Eurobonds, bank recapitalisation, the possible use of the European Stability Mechanism to prop up struggling banks and a financial transaction tax.

Leaders will also discuss the precarious situation in Greece as leaders wait nervously for the outcome of a decisive election next month in the debt-stricken nation.

Growth proposals likely to meet approval across all 27 member states include so-called project bonds, a form of co-financing for earmarked infrastructure projects.

A Commission proposal to pilot the project bonds – in the transport, energy and communications infrastructure sectors – was agreed yesterday (22 May) in concert with the European Parliament and Council.

Eurobonds are the bugbear

But Eurobonds – mutualised debt instruments that would see Germany and other financially stronger eurozone countries guarantee the debt of weaker states – remain controversial.

Last week, Hollande told a meeting of G8 leaders in the US that he would promote Eurobonds at the EU summit, saying he had the support of Italian Prime Minister Mario Monti, Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy and the European Commission.

The Commission has long been a supporter of euro area bonds, producing a feasibility study on them late last year before the initiative was pushed to the background.

Germany remained unprepared to consider the issue on the eve of the summit, claiming such bonds were no answer to the eurozone’s problems, and that fiscal convergence must be strengthened before they can be meaningfully discussed.

German Chancellor Angela Merkel has also refused to budge on her insistence that any growth measures could not come via more deficit spending.

Austria, Finland and the Netherlands are in the German camp on the bond issue.

Meanwhile, Britain is sceptical of a plan to boost paid-in capital of the European Investment Bank by €10 billion – an idea which most member states back – doubting Commission figures claiming such a sum could be leveraged to €180 billion of investment.

The UK is also likely to find itself fighting the proposal for a financial transaction tax, which has crept back on the EU agenda following Hollande’s election on 6 May.

‘Grexit’ will not be discussed

The Eurobonds are likely to be the most controversial issue discussed. “If the Greeks exit the eurozone, there will need to be some clear effort in place to buffer the zone against contagion, such as Eurobonds,” said one EU diplomat.

Leaders meeting today will avoid discussion of a Greek exit – Grexit, in Brussels jargon – with Greece facing elections on 17 June that could hasten its departure from the eurozone if voters back anti-bailout parties. However, they are likely to make a common statement on the situation in Greece.

There are some signs that Berlin may be paving the way for a change of tone on Eurobonds. Speaking in Berlin on 21 May, Germany’s European Central Bank executive board member, Jörg Asmussen, said the eurozone should be backed by “a fiscal union and banking union as well as a democratic legitimised political union”.

Stronger central European fiscal control has long been cited by Merkel as a condition for Eurobonds to be considered, but such controls are strongly resisted in Paris, where they are seen as a threat to national sovereignty.

Whatever is agreed, or disagreed, the outlines of a bargain – seeing France cede sovereignty in exchange for Germany agreeing to guarantee the debt of the eurozone – are on the table.

Next steps: 
  • 23 May: Informal summit to discuss growth
  • 27 June 2012: Formal summit of heads of state and government in Brussels
Jeremy Fleming

COMMENTS

  • Now the picture gets more and more clear : "Germany will cede on debt garantee if France cedes on fiscal sovereignty". The German position sounds pragmatic and the French one ideological. What else is new ?

    Well, we shall see if the new French administration gets rid of gaullist nationalistic heritage and meets Germany somewhere on the way towards the construction of a sensible european economic - and political - governance.

    If it does not (of if it uses elusive arguments such as probable UK opposition) its responsibility will be clearly established. Jean-Guy GIRAUD

    By :
    Jean-Guy Giraud
    - Posted on :
    23/05/2012
François Hollande and Angela Merkel are due in Brussels today
Background: 

Council President Herman Van Rompuy called for the informal gathering of heads of state and government today following the election of François Hollande in France on 6 May.

During his campaign, Hollande rejected the strict austerity measures being imposed through the EU, emphasising that he would push for more growth.

There are no formal decisions to be taken today, but the discussion will be frank, and is designed to pave the way for decisions on growth to be taken at the next formal summit meeting, which will take place at the end of June.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Euro & Finance News videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Euro & Finance Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising