EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

German banks want incentives for Greek debt rollover

Published 21 June 2011 - Updated 23 June 2011
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

Top German banks exposed to Greek sovereign bonds have started to play hard ball with EU governments by asking for further guarantees and incentives if they are to participate in a debt rollover. 

Yesterday (20 June), the German Banking Federation issued a statement demanding better incentives before exposed banks are asked to extend repayments on their existing Greek debt with no strings attached.

The banks' reaction comes on the back of a political agreement struck between EU finance ministers at the weekend to encourage banks which hold Greek bonds due for repayment in the next three years to lengthen their exposure and buy bonds with a longer maturity.

The plan, dubbed 'Vienna plus' and modelled on the 2009 Vienna Initiative, has riled banks in Germany which, alongside French banks, are the most exposed to Greek sovereign bonds. Such a plan is seen as the cornerstone of any new rescue package for Greece.

In a carefully-worded statement, the German banking lobby said "the voluntary roll-overs are necessary to prevent the risk of contagion. Additional incentives, like preferred creditor status or additional guarantees, would help solve Greece's problems just as much as a political consensus on national reforms".

Greece is currently in the throes of a political crisis as its parliament is withholding support for austerity measures needed to guarantee an additional EU bailout package to the tune of €120 billion.

According to research conducted by Barclays, 95% of Greek debt is held within the euro zone by European banks.

Evolution Securities, an investment bank, carried out research estimating that Fortis, Dexia and SocGen have the highest exposure to possible haircuts. Barclays would be the biggest UK lender to be hit, with possible losses of 4.6 billion euros, while bailed out German lenders Hypo Real Estate and Depfa are together exposed to a total of 6.3 billion euros.

Sources in Brussels indicate that only very large banks and bailed-out lenders susceptible to government pressure and regulation will be hit by possible rollovers, while hedge funds will be let off the hook.

"There is no reason for hedge funds to agree to a rollover," said Sony Kapoor, founder of the Re-define think-tank.

Kapoor warns of a risk that Greek bonds will migrate to hedge funds and private equity groups as banks attempt to avoid an extension on the debt.

A spokesperson for the hedge fund industry insisted that fund exposure to Greek debt was comparatively low compared with banks, and that comments to the contrary stemmed from a growing political plot against fund traders.

"It is a red herring that hedge funds are heavily invested in the Greek crisis or have large exposures there," an anonymous industry representative said.

Claire Davenport

Positions: 

"We have advanced on the participation of the private sector, which will be done on a voluntary basis," said Belgian Finance Minister Didier Reynders. "The negotiations are going to start now with the treasury departments in the different states, to see how to obtain a significant participation of the private sector via rollovers," Reynedrs continued.

"The Vienna Plus plan will create large arbitrage opportunities and free riding that may prove to be politically toxic. The sight of vulture funds and hedge funds getting repaid in full while banks are cajoled into taking a hit will be highly controversial," Sony Kapoor, managing director of Re-Define, an international economic think-tank.

Belgian Green MEP and economic affairs spokesperson Philippe Lamberts said: "The reluctance to ensure [that] private creditors properly participate in tackling the Greek debt crisis is prolonging the agony for [the] euro zone. Orderly debt restructuring is inevitable and should have already been set in motion some time ago."

Background: 

In May 2010, the EU and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) extended a €110 billion loan to Greece to prevent the country from sinking into bankruptcy.

In the beginning of 2010, it was discovered that Greece was sitting on debt worth more than €215 billion, while its annual budget deficit was 13.6%.

A second bailout is now being discussed with the EU and the IMF as it appears that Greece will be unable to pay back its debt.

The new deal would total €120 billion, half coming from new EU/IMF aid and the other half mainly from privatisation of public companies such as the post, energy and telecoms.

However, the EU is still divided over the participation of private bondholders. Germany wants private investors to share part of the cost. The European Central Bank disagrees, warning that this would spread a new wave of contagion to other countries via commercial banks, which would see some of their assets depreciated to junk status.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Advertising

Advertising