EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Merkel preaches federalism to MEPs, warns Britain against EU exit

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 08 November 2012

German Chancellor Angela Merkel made a strong federalist speech in the European Parliament yesterday (7 November) before leaving for London, where she urged Prime Minister David Cameron not to turn his back on Europe and work with her to avoid deadlock at European Union budget talks later this month.

Merkel spent the afternoon meeting MEPs, culminating in a two-hour discussion centred on the EU's economic troubles and the upcoming negotiations on the shape of the bloc's next long-term budget.

Merkel called for strengthening economic policy coordination and more joint fiscal policy.

Merkel warned MEPs that much remains to be done to get a handle on the eurozone crisis, arguing that members of the EU single currency must press reforms and draw a roadmap for unity. On several occasions, she quoted Jacques Delors, the long-serving Commission president and considered one of the “fathers of Europe”.

Ahead of a December EU summit to deal with the debt crisis, Merkel told lawmakers that countries must allow the European Union to police budgets when necessary if the bloc is to maintain prosperity.

"Much still has to be done to win back trust in the European Union as a whole," Merkel said. "We cannot stop halfway. We have to be creative: We have to find our own new solutions."

She also said policies need to become "more common," adding that a pan-EU supervisory body with the power to police banks to avoid risks must be effective. She said budgets across the EU must be determined with a one-for-all outlook.

"Trust in the EU needs to be re-won," Merkel said in her speech.

Merkel also brought up complicated treaty changes as one possible solution to the crisis. Europeans have to be "ambitious and demanding, and not shy away from a change to the contractual basis," she said.

Transferring sovereign powers over to the EU cannot be ruled out, Merkel said. She continued her lobbying for austerity measures that have restricted growth in the countries hardest hit, saying that "the effort is not in vain."

'I cannot imagine Europe without Britain’

Merkel insisted that the United Kingdom is an indispensable part of Europe hours before her scheduled meeting with Cameron.

"I believe you can be very happy on an island, but being alone in this world doesn't make you any happier," Merkel said after British politician Nigel Farage, leader of the anti-European UK Independence Party, urged her to tell Cameron that Britain should quit the EU.

Cameron, who wants to stay in the bloc under renegotiated terms, argues that the EU must tighten its belt at a time when the eurozone debt crisis looms large, and many countries are faced with austerity and shrinking household budgets.

Describing plans to increase the EU budget as "ludicrous", Cameron has threatened to veto any deal he thinks is not in Britain's interests and will push for a real-terms freeze.

The leaders met in London to try to iron out differences over the EU's proposed €1 trillion budget for 2014-2020 that threaten to block a deal and fuel fears that London is drifting away from the 27-nation union.

"Despite differences that we have it is very important for me that the UK and Germany work together," Merkel said before the start of her meeting with Cameron.

"We always have to do something that will stand up to public opinion back home. Not all of the expenditure that has been earmarked has been used with great efficiency ... We need to address that," she said.

Positions: 

Socialist and Democrats leader Hannes Swoboda told Merkel her commitment to Europe was “not sufficient”.

“Germany has traditionally played a leading role in Europe but under your leadership this is no longer the case. Where is your commitment to a strong Europe with a clear long-term vision,” he said.

"The policies that Chancellor Merkel advocates for countries such as Greece and Portugal – and for the whole of Europe – are threatening the social cohesion of Europe. The Troikas at work in several of these countries should not be supported, as they are 'Destroykas', undermining the principles of the European social model."

European People’s Party leader Joseph Daul emphasised the need for an EU budget to energise the economy. "We are convinced that the European budget is indispensable for getting out of the crisis. We must therefore invest in Europe. So I do not quite understand the Council's position. On the one hand, it backs us in the Europe 2020 Strategy and asks us to make further commitments, but on the other hand wants to cut spending. We need a [budget] that matches our ambitions. We need investment in research and development, and in innovation, both powerful sources of growth and therefore jobs all over Europe. We must carry this logic through to its end," Daul said.

ALDE group leader Guy Verhofstadt underlined the need for action to tackle the underlying causes of the crisis and the key role of Germany in agreeing to an exit strategy.

"The German government's own economic advisory council has proposed the useful idea of a debt redemption fund that is temporary, will not require a treaty change and will reduce interest rates across the Eurozone meaning that painful austerity measures will not be in vain. At present, German taxpayers are, in effect, paying for the dividends of the bond holders of government debt."

"Europe now has no choice but to put in place a genuine economic government supported by a single European bond market that can ensure both high liquidity and low interest rates," the ALDE leader said.

Martin Callanan, leader of the European Conservatives and Reformists group, told Merkel that he had sympathy with German taxpayers. However, he also warned that removing national economic sovereignty was a recipe for social unrest, which would take too long to implement to have meaningful effect on the current crisis. He told her that Germany faces the same fundamental choices as at the start of the crisis - namely to produce the 'Big Bazooka' needed, or to allow some countries to be unshackled from an overvalued currency. He called for the currency crisis to be tackled so that the EU can focus on the real challenge of its decline in global competitiveness.

UKIP leader Nigel Farage MEP suggested she should tell Cameron: 'Look, David, this simply doesn't work anymore, it really is time for the United Kingdom to leave the European Union.

“All I am suggesting Chancellor is that we have a simple amicable divorce and we shall all get on much better in the future."

GUE/NGL President Gabi Zimmer told Angela Merkel that austerity policies should come with a danger warning. "Your policies of austerity are forcing people into poverty, into unemployment and are destroying SMEs. Austerity kills, as my group let you know today before this meeting."

Zimmer also said: "The last two measures of the Memorandum of Understanding, the suspension of employment protection for one year and the reduction of the minimum wage for workers under 25 to two-thirds of the national minimum wage, have recently been deemed as directly at odds with the European Social Charter by the Council of Europe's European Committee of Social Rights, making them illegal."

EurActiv.com with Reuters

COMMENTS

  • A good first step for solving budget and other "deadlocks" would be an EU WITHOUT Britain.

    The Eu would be better off without "The City" and its financial services toady David Cameron.

    Ms Merkel, Germany has the most productive WORKING CLass in the world; too often in the past it has been shafted by paper shufflers who have to appropriate their products because "financial services" itself consists of "fictitious capital" which has NO REAL VALUE.
    As Leader of such a productive entity as is Germany, YOU need to WAKE_UP smell the coffee. Stop pandering to the parasites; see to it that the REAL 99% who produce all get to enjoy the fruits of their labour without most being appropriated by others.

    By :
    david tarbuck
    - Posted on :
    08/11/2012
  • Are the British really the only people in the EU that find a rise in the EU budget indefensible at a time when national governments are making big cuts in spending & the people of Europe are suffering economic hardship?

    I ask that as a serious question to see how other Europeans feel on this & hopefully the responses won't the usual tripe like why doesn't Britain get out of the EU (be patient that will happen).

    It's almost like the European Commission has become like some sort of holy European order like the Vatican once was - fully detached from economic realities in the pursuit of some divine purpose.

    By :
    Justin Pugsley, Principal, JJPAssociates
    - Posted on :
    08/11/2012
  • The original idea ( I believe) of the common market was for the business sector to have free movement of goods, So what happened, how did we get to this point ? and now the possible central EU Government running the whole of Europe from Brussels telling each country what they can and cannot do ? Ho sorry we already have this, but they want more !!!!!

    Businessman to Bank manager, I need 1 million extra per year for the next five years, so that I can maintain my business/Life style and my profits in order to give the competition in Romania/Bulgaria/Poland etc a chance to undercut my Company and raise their standards of living.
    Bank Manager, Are you MAD !!!!! why would you want to do this and end up going bankrupt and being unemployed.

    Please can WE just take a step backwards and reflect on what the hell's going on !!!

    By :
    Tony Nichols
    - Posted on :
    08/11/2012
  • @Justin Pugsley

    It's reall very simple. The completion of the Single Market is quite simply the only way to get Europe out of recession. This costs money. Isn't that amazing.

    However, using that basic economic principle called economies of scale, spending 1 euro at the EU level, if invested correctly, is far more efficient then 1 euro at national level.

    That and the EU budget increase, in real terms, is absolute peanuts compared to overall EU government expenditure. If it, were to multiply by 3 for example, it would still make no difference on Memberstates austerity plans because it is so so so so small.

    I'm sorry, but the fact is that the UK electorate believes the absolute rubbish put out by the eurosceptic media for the past 20 years. When the arguments are put before those who are informed, they really don't stack up in the least.

    By :
    Antipopulist
    - Posted on :
    08/11/2012
  • Nigel Farage is 'anti-EU' not "anti-European". One would expect Euractiv to be aware of the difference.

    By :
    kev
    - Posted on :
    08/11/2012
  • Antipopulist - what you say about economies of scale may apply at a commercial level, but in the UK at least it has resulted in an explosion of new regulation and a bureaucratic boom.

    Far from EC bureaucrats replacing national ones, it has resulted in government depts having to employ more and more bureaucrats to negotiate EU rules, then interpret them and then implement them.

    Also, the EU extends far beyond just regulating a single market, it would be truly awesome if it just stuck to that.

    And the UK's financial contribution is far from 'peanuts' especially at a time when welfare benefits, the national health & education are being cut to help balance the budget.

    I think Cameron's argument is correct - the EC budget should fall as well - but it appears everyone else in Europe thinks the EC should have inflation busting budget? I think the solution is to let them pay for it if they want to, but not expect others to as well.

    By :
    Justin Pugsley, Principal, JJPAssociates
    - Posted on :
    08/11/2012
  • Justin is right - the EC budget needs to be cut and could be done so easily if the expenditure was targetted to those countries needing e.g. major improvements to infrastructure. I spend a lot of time in Poland and have seen major improvements there. Linked to this, however, is the need for much greater controls of the funding of projects and clear demonstration of achievement of project goals and benefits along with a major reform of areas such as the CAP (40% of budget for 5% of the population? Utter madness) and eliminating e.g. funding of rich landowners. Until these points are addressed, then recession or no recession, I would vote for not one penny more.

    By :
    Don Latuske
    - Posted on :
    08/11/2012
  • David Tarbuck comments: "good first step for solving budget and other "deadlocks" would be an EU WITHOUT Britain."

    The UK is now no.2 net contributor to the EU budget after Germany, so that statement doesn't stack up.

    The sentiment is true however, as the UK should contribute zero to the EU. Why we should be paying for rebuilding Eastern Europe and subsidising French farmers is beyond me.

    By :
    Charles_M
    - Posted on :
    08/11/2012
  • By : Antipopulist- Posted on : 08/11/2012reply
    Completely right !
    Europe will go federal instead to be completely deregulated!

    By :
    an european
    - Posted on :
    09/11/2012
  • After two World Wars and being on the winning side Britain is the only thing that ever legitimised the EU, now we're leaving people around the world are going to be asking why.

    ...and we're going to tell 'em!

    By :
    Leon
    - Posted on :
    09/11/2012
  • I never voted for the Europe we have today so why should I tolerate it. I am 100% going to be voting UKIP just like hundreds of thousands of other people!

    By :
    R.McGrail
    - Posted on :
    09/11/2012
  • Actually, a Federal Europe will become by a mile the most regulated place on earth. A fully Federalised Europe under French guidance will steadily regulate Europe out of more and more industries as if labour costs weren't a big enough challenge already.

    Washington, Beijing and Tokyo will be delighted for the economic gifts from a European elite more interested in creating endless red tape rather than wealth and jobs for its citizens.

    It's tragic and deeply disturbing that an obsession with European federalism and the Euro is actually condemning entire populations in southern Europe to perpetual penury and creating lost generations. The social costs of this will be huge and I fear deeply for the future of Europe!

    By :
    Justin Pugsley, Principal, JJPAssociates
    - Posted on :
    09/11/2012
  • As a Brit, I wonder how many of my fellow compatriots realise how important the EU and its pooled elements were when Mad Cow disease took its toll on the UK and certain parts of mainland Europe. Without access to such integrated means (funds) of response to a crisis, especially to one of an ethical nature, how would the UK have coped? Badly or not at all to my mind if one considers the level of incompetence, delay and suffering caused to the animals somewhat needlessly slaughtered, the individuals infected and those who ultimately succumbed to a purely, man-made illness. It is quite one thing to be against further integration at a fiscal level, i.e. vis-à-vis the Single Market, however when push comes to shove, I believe Angela Merkel is right and we should take proper notice. Island or not, in my humble opinion we live in a world where we are stronger and more protected in a group rather than trying to go it alone. Like everything these days [under the auspices of a capitalistic system of government] this of course comes with an undeniable cost.

    By :
    GD Evans
    - Posted on :
    09/11/2012
  • @Charles_M
    No idea where you get "The UK is now no.2 net contributor to the EU budget after Germany"... it is in fact the fourth behind, Germany, France and Italy.
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_the_European_Union#Net_contributors_and_recipients
    "As a proportion of GDP, net contributors pay from 0.09 percent (Ireland) to 0.53 percent (Denmark), and net recipients receive from 0.04 percent (Spain) to 5.33 percent (Lithuania).
    The four largest net recipients in absolute terms are: Poland, Greece, Hungary, Portugal. The four largest net recipients in per capita terms are: Luxembourg, Lithuania, Estonia, Greece The four largest net recipients as a proportion of GDP are : Lithuania, Estonia, Luxembourg, Hungary.
    The four largest net contributors in absolute terms are:. Germany, France, Italy, UK The four largest net contributors in per capita terms are: Denmark, Finland, Germany, Italy. The four largest net contributors as a proportion of GDP are : Denmark, Italy, Germany, Finland."

    By :
    GD Evans
    - Posted on :
    09/11/2012
  • @GD Evans

    Your Wikipedia figures are for 2009. Suggest you look at the 2011 numbers, last full year available.

    By :
    Charles_M
    - Posted on :
    09/11/2012
  • @Justin Pugsley

    "Washington, Beijing and Tokyo will be delighted for the economic gifts from a European elite more interested in creating endless red tape rather than wealth and jobs for its citizens."

    Oh really?

    Well you seem to be concerned about the wealth of a small clan of billionaires rather more than that of the citizens. The EU attracts the most capital investment thanks to its high quality public goods, healthcare, higher-education, infrastructure at the disposal of a productive workforce, living in an unpolluted environment. The rule of law governs their civilisation and ensures freedom for all, including markets.

    You may call that "red tape" but don't worry some day soon people in Asia and America will be delighted to introduce lots of it rather than working on their hands and knees paying for the opulent lifestyles of oligarchs, as we were ourselves doing 200 years ago.

    By :
    Andrew Finningley
    - Posted on :
    12/11/2012
  • Hi there just wanted to give you a brief heads up and let you know a few of the pictures aren't loading correctly. I'm not sure why but I think its a linking issue. I've tried it in two different web browsers and both show the same outcome.

    By :
    north face jackets cheap
    - Posted on :
    16/11/2012

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Euro & Finance News videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Euro & Finance Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising