EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Merkel warns Greece, endorses Tobin tax

Published 10 January 2012
Comments2
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

German Chancellor Angela Merkel warned yesterday (9 January) that Greece must make rapid progress on its second rescue package – including a voluntary write-down on its public debt held by private creditors – before it receives further EU aid.

The warning came at a bilateral meeting with French President Nicolas Sarkozy held in Berlin. Merkel also said European finance ministers should map out plans on a financial transaction tax by March, despite Britain’s pledge to block any such levy across the European Union.

"We must see progress on the voluntary restructuring of Greek debt," Merkel told a joint news conference with Sarkozy.

Merkel: No rescue plan – no aid

"From our point of view, the second Greek aid package, including this restructuring, must be in place quickly. Otherwise it won't be possible to pay out the next tranche for Greece."

Merkel said she would talk about Greece with International Monetary Fund chief Christine Lagarde. They are to meet in Berlin on Tuesday.

Banks, insurers and investment funds have been negotiating with the Greek government for weeks on a bond swap scheme which aims to cut its debt-to-GDP ratio to 120% from roughly 160% currently.

Meanwhile, Merkel backed the idea proposed by Sarkozy for the eurozone to introduce its own transaction tax if all EU countries cannot agree.

The Group of 20 top global economies has abandoned attempts to agree a transaction tax in the face of opposition from the United States, China, Britain and others.

Britain isolated on Tobin tax

Britain says it will veto such a tax at the EU level unless it is adopted on a global scale, fearful of the impact in the City of London financial centre. The issue could split the European Union at a summit planned for 30 January.

Without Britain's support, an EU-wide tax is impossible. But this would not stop a smaller group of nations within the bloc advancing with their own tax.

However, even within the eurozone, there is disagreement and countries such as Ireland want the tax to apply either to all 27 states or be dropped. Dublin has carved out a niche in London's shadow as a major centre for funds administration in Europe, and promoting the industry is a top government priority after the Irish banking crash.

Sarkozy vowed last week that France would push ahead with the tax unilaterally if other Europeans dither, and told reporters in Berlin: "If we don't set the example, it will not be done."

"We have no doubt we are going to start a trend in the eurozone for everyone to adopt this tax, which is exactly what is needed," he said.

Swiss chief banker resigns abruptly

Meanwhile, during the course of the Merkel-Sarkozy meeting the chairman of the Swiss National Bank, Philipp Hildebrand, resigned with immediate effect.

The development followed revelations that his wife Kashya bought €400,000 worth of US dollars in August, three weeks before the central bank intervened to cap the Swiss franc.

Positions: 

"To introduce a tax on financial transactions in the eurozone only doesn't make any sense because it would create huge distortions among countries," said Karel Lannoo, a financial markets expert with the Centre for European Policy Studies, a Brussels thinks tank. Lannoo said such a scheme was unlikely to win sufficient political backing.

But Sony Kapoor, founder of think tank Re-Define, said a tax among some EU countries was workable if collected correctly. "The best way would be to adopt a UK stamp-duty like approach where you change the basis of the taxation from the location of the trade or financial institution to the origin of the asset," said Kapoor.

"It could apply to eurozone registered financial assets such as company shares and bonds and derivatives transactions on those. So trading in German and French assets would be taxable,"  Kapoor said.

“The danger in this proposal lies in the fact that the end user will have to pay for all this as it is highly likely that banks will pass these extra charges on to small businesses”, said Patrick Gibbels, the Brussels representative of the European Small Business Alliance. “SME bank lending is already endangered severely by the upcoming CRDIV requirements where banks are required to retain capital[… ]. We should be helping SMEs do business, not putting obstacles in their way.”

Next steps: 
  • 10 Jan.: German Chancellor Angela Merkel meets with IMF chief Christine Lagarde.
  • 20 Jan.: Italian, French and German leaders meet in Italy.
  • 23 Jan.: EU finance ministers meeting in Brussels.
  • 30 Jan.: EU Summit of 27 heads of state in Brussels.
EurActiv.com with Reuters

COMMENTS

  • Greece was fine before it joined the European Union this is the fault of the European Union. The public in Greece, Ireland and the UK don’t want to be in the European Union. The architects of the EU were former Nazis some in the SS. This goes along way to explain the fascism and thievery of the European Union parasite elite who are slowly ruining us all.

    By :
    Walter Hallstein
    - Posted on :
    19/01/2012
  • Merkozi are ready to spend another 500 billion Euro to support Serbia and Greece, their tools for controlling the Balkans and dominating the Central Europe.

    By :
    Meridian
    - Posted on :
    29/01/2012
Merkozy in Berlin
Background: 

Under the Greek rescue plan, private creditors are being asked to voluntary accept a nominal 50% cut in the value of their Greek bond holdings in return for a mix of cash and new bonds, although there are suggestions that may not now be enough.

Private-sector involvement is a key part of a new €130 billion bailout package that needs to be in place by March to ensure Greece does not default on its massive debt.

But talks are not progressing as fast as hoped. Complicating matters, European Central Bank policymaker Athanasios Orphanides has called for the private-sector deal to be scrapped and an advisor to the German finance ministry said plans for a 50% write-down were insufficient.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising