EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Portugal given lifeline ahead of 'Battle of Spain'

Published 11 January 2011 - Updated 20 January 2011
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

The European Central Bank threw Portugal a temporary lifeline yesterday (10 January) by buying up its bonds, as market and peer pressure mounted on Lisbon to seek an international bailout soon. But analysts said that in the euro zone's simmering debt crisis, the Battle of Spain would likely prove decisive in 2011.

A senior eurozone source said on Sunday that Germany, France and other eurozone countries were pushing Portugal to seek an EU-IMF assistance programme, following Greece and Ireland, to prevent contagion spreading to much larger Spain, the fourth biggest economy in the euro area.

The eurozone source said Lisbon would need between 50 billion and 100 billion euros in loans, similar to Ireland, which accepted an 80 billion euro EU-IMF rescue in December after a banking crisis caused by a burst real-estate bubble lumbered the state with huge liabilities.

Portuguese Prime Minister José Sócrates said last Friday his country had no need of outside assistance because it was ahead of schedule in reducing its budget deficit.

Socrates, who heads a minority socialist government, is stubbornly avoiding a bailout, mindful of the traumatic history of Portugal's two International Monetary Fund rescues since its return to democracy in 1974.

The memory of the IMF's involvement, in 1977 and in 1983, is so etched on the Portuguese psyche that the country's media is not even mentioning that it would primarily be the European Union that would finance any bailout this time.

'Little chance of escaping'

German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schaeuble denied Berlin was pushing anyone to seek assistance, but he did say it was defending the euro. A French government official also said it was nonsense to suggest that Paris and Berlin were pressuring Lisbon.

But economists and market analysts believe it is only a matter of time before deficit-laden Portugal, whose stagnant economy has lost competitiveness since joining the euro zone, has to seek aid.

"If market spreads keep rising, Portugal has little chance of escaping a bailout," said Laurence Boone, research director at Barclays Capital in Paris.

Asian powers more generous?

But the European Union is preparing to fight the Portuguese crisis with one hand tied behind its back because Germany continues to block any financial lifeline for a country until it is actually drowning.

Astonishingly China, which pledged last week to buy Spanish government bonds, is doing more to help Madrid than Berlin is.

Japan too announced that it will use its foreign-exchange reserves to buy more than 20% of the bonds released by Europe's financial aid fund in late January to assist Ireland, Bloomberg reported on 11 January.

Japanese Finance Minister Yoshihiko Noda said at a Tokyo news conference that it was "appropriate for Japan to make a contribution as a lending nation to increase trust in the deal".

In a Reuters poll last week, 44 of 51 economists surveyed expected Lisbon would need a bailout, but only seven thought Spain would need outside help, even though most expect Madrid's credit rating to suffer another downgrade soon.

Spain is the euro zone's fourth largest economy and would stretch the capacity of the currency bloc's financial safety net - the 440 billion euro European Financial Stability Facility - to the limit if it had to be rescued.

"Spain has a serious, realistic chance of avoiding a programme because of the government's actions to reduce the fiscal deficit, reduce public borrowing needs, make structural economic reforms and repair the financial sector," a senior EU official said.

After months of denial, Spanish Prime Minister José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero's minority Socialist government has acted to cut public spending, step up privatisation and bring forward long-delayed pension reform.

Nevertheless, bond market pressure is likely to be fierce, with investors fleeing peripheral eurozone sovereigns over worries about their ability to repay their debts as interest rates rise, as well as fears of write-downs for bondholders.

European Union officials are searching for ways to reinforce the euro zone's financial backstop by increasing its effective lending capacity and broadening its scope for action.

German resistance

But German Chancellor Angela Merkel, facing hostile public opinion and fearing a constitutional court veto, has rejected any pre-emptive standby credit line for troubled eurozone countries before they are forced out of capital markets.

Berlin has so far also opposed any increase in the size of the rescue fund and any use of that money to buy sovereign bonds in the secondary market, or help recapitalise troubled banks.

German resistance will be put to the test when eurozone finance ministers meet on 17 January to discuss a comprehensive response to the potentially systemic crisis.

If they are unable to agree on any strengthening of the financial safety net, it could hasten a backlash in the markets.

Indeed, markets are still pricing in a 15-20% marginal possibility of a Spanish default in each of the next five years.

Spain's woes, like Ireland's, result mostly from the bursting of a real estate bubble that was inflated by cheap euro interest rates. Unemployment stands at 20% and the economy is barely growing at all.

Although Spanish public debt is still well below the eurozone average and the two biggest commercial banks, Banco Santander and BBVA, are in good shape, the state faces contingent liabilities from a damaged financial sector.

Madrid's fiscal problems are compounded by the need to recapitalise its unlisted regional savings banks, the cajas, which were merged to 17 from 45 in an overhaul last month and have an unrecognised exposure to bad real estate loans.

Spanish banks also have a large exposure to Portuguese public debt, and would suffer if they could not use Portuguese bonds as collateral in central bank liquidity operations.

Both Spain and Portugal face big funding crunches in April and mid-year. Portugal must repay more than 12 billion euros in the first half of 2011. Spain faces bond redemptions of 15 billion euros in April and another 15 billion in July.

So the euro zone may not have long to build a more effective firewall before the flames start licking around the Iberian peninsula.

(EurActiv with Reuters.)

Positions: 

"We are quite negative on Portugal. We believe it will be tapping the European Financial Stability Fund next. We're not so sure about Spain. It's a question of a toss of the coin," said Pavan Wadhwa, European rates strategist at investment bank JP Morgan.

Madrid's fiscal challenge was easier to deal with than that of Greece, Portugal and Ireland, Wadhwa said, adding that the government in Madrid was making progress in cutting the budget deficit and using privatisation revenue to reduce borrowing needs.

Deutsche Bank economists Gilles Moec and Marco Stringa said in a note that the Lisbon government would have to significantly "over-issue" debt in the first four months of the year to avoid a sharp deterioration in its cash position, while Portuguese banks would face a peak in their refinancing needs in January and February.

"It would be rational for Portugal to call for external help sooner rather than later," they said.

"The losses related to the commercial real estate sector are potentially two to three times as big as those linked to the residential sector," said Laurence Boone, research director at Barclays Capital in Paris.

Boone considers Spain's debt situation manageable, provided that 10-year rates remain below 7%. The yield on Spanish bonds with that maturity was around 5.5% at the end of last week, but Portugal's borrowing costs were 6.95% and rising.

Finnish Finance Minister Jyrki Katainen said today (11 January) that Portugal needs to take decisive political steps to calm international markets.

"Portugal has already announced many actions, but it would be good to review what more could be done," Katainen told Finnish broadcaster MTV3.

He also said Ireland may not be the last country to seek financial aid from the European Union and the International Monetary Fund, but declined to say whether there were discussions about providing a loan to Portugal.

Background: 

After Greece and Ireland received EU-IMF bailouts last year to cope with their swollen public debts and deficits, Portugal is seen as the next candidate for a rescue despite efforts to put its public finances in order.

On 2 May 2010, eurozone finance ministers agreed to activate a joint EU-IMF aid package worth 110 billion euros to help debt-laden Greece. Under the deal, Athens received 80 billion euros in bilateral loans in three years spanning until 2012. 30 billion came from the International Monetary Fund (IMF).

In November, it was the turn of Ireland. European Union finance ministers agreed on 21 November to a request from Ireland to help it deal with its crippling debt problem.

At the 17 December summit EU leaders agreed to create a permanent financial safety net from 2013 and the European Central Bank moved to increase its firepower to fight the debt crisis that has rocked the euro zone.

But at Germany's insistence, the 27 leaders said the long-term crisis-resolution mechanism, to be added to the EU's governing treaty, would only be activated "if indispensable to safeguard the stability of the euro as a whole".

They also decided there was no need to increase an existing temporary rescue fund, which some analysts say could be insufficient if Spain and Portugal need EU/IMF bailouts after Greece and Ireland, nor did they discuss using it more flexibly.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Advertising

Advertising