EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Cypriot president says he was forced to accept EU bailout

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 18 March 2013

Cypriot President Nicos Anastasiades said yesterday (17 March) he had no choice but to accept a painful tax on the country’s bank deposits in return for international aid, saying the alternative was bankruptcy.

 

In a nationally televised address, the president called it the least painful option under the circumstances before going on to accuse eurozone finance ministers of forcing Cyprus into this deal, Euronews reported.

Breaking with previous EU practice that depositors' savings are sacrosanct, Cyprus and international lenders agreed at the weekend that savers in the island's outsized banking system would take a hit in return for the offer of €10 billion in aid.

The decision to introduce levies on deposits are 9.9% for those exceeding €100,000 and 6.7% on anything below that, according to the bailout agreement, announced on Saturday morning.

The news stunned Cypriots and caused a run on bank machines, most of which were depleted within hours. Electronic transfers were halted.

Outside Cyprus, the move unnerved depositors in the eurozone's weaker economies and investors fearing a precedent that could reignite market turmoil.

Anastasiades promised those savers they would be compensated by being given shares in banks guaranteed by future natural gas revenues.

Cyprus is expecting the results of an offshore appraisal drilling this year to confirm the island is sitting on vast amounts of natural gas worth billions.

Softening the blow?

The Cypriot government was working on a proposal to soften the blow of a bank deposit levy on smaller savers ahead of a parliamentary vote on Monday (18 March) on the measure central to a eurozone bailout designed to avert bankruptcy.

Anastasiades’s centre-right Democratic Rally party, with 20 seats in the 56-member parliament, needs the support of other factions for the vote to pass. It was unclear whether even his coalition partners, the Democratic party, would fully support the levy.

Approval of the deposit cut is far from a given. No party has an absolute majority, three parties say outright they will not back the tax, and a vote initially planned for Sunday was rescheduled to allow more time to build a consensus.

Faced with a growing public backlash, Cypriot finance ministry officials began discussions with lenders on Sunday to lessen the blow for smaller savers.

In Brussels, a spokesman for Olli Rehn, the European commissioner in charge of economic affairs, said changes to the amounts paid by different depositors could be acceptable given that the financial impact would be the same.

"Essentially parliament is called to legalise a decision to rob depositors blind, against every written and unwritten law," said Yiannakis Omirou, speaker of parliament and head of EDEK, the small Socialist party. "We refuse to subscribe to this."

Even though there was no immediate sign of savers taking fright in other parts of Europe badly hurt by the regional debt crisis, some feared a precedent had been set.

Independent financial experts and governmental sources believe that the Eurogroup and the European Central Bank need a flawless execution of the bailout agreement, because the deal will likely serve as blueprint for future bailouts. Most likely recipients of such bailout packages are the so-called PIGS countries: Portugal, Italy, Greece and Spain.

Russians lose money

Foreigners hold some 40% of the €68 billion sitting in Cypriot banks, and most of that belongs to Russians, who for decades have favoured the island as a place to stash their money.

Forbes said on its website that ratings agency Moody's last year estimated the holdings of Russian businesses in Cyprus at $19 billion, with another $12 billion held there by Russian banks.

Forbes also cites other press estimates which place the personal deposits of Russians in Cyprus between 8 and 35 billion euros.

“Confidence in Cyprus as a safe place to deposit money is going to be reduced to zero,” Anatoly Aksakov of the Russian association of regional banks was quoted as saying by Interfax news agency and the Greek daily Kathimerini

Positions: 

Sharon Bowles, chair of the European Parliament’s Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee, said she was appalled by the Cyprus bailout which includes ‘bailing-in’ some guaranteed deposits – i.e. swapping them for shares. “This grabbing of ordinary depositors' money is billed as a tax, so as to try and circumvent the EU’s deposit guarantee laws. It robs smaller investors of the protection they were promised. If this were a bank they would be in court for mis-selling!,” she said. “The lesson here is that the EU’s single market rules will be flouted when the eurozone, ECB and IMF say so. At a time when many are greatly concerned that the creation of the ‘Banking Union’, giving the ECB unprecedented power, will demote the priorities of the single market, we see it here in action. “Deposit guarantees were brought in at a maximum harmonising level so that citizens across the EU would not have incentives to move funds from country to country. That has now been blown apart. What else will be blown apart when convenient - the capital requirements we have been slaved over the new recovery and resolution rules? What does this mean for confidence in cross-border banking and resolution and preventing the fragmentation of the baking sector? “When the dust has settled on this deal, which I hope it never does, we will see that the single market has been sold down the river for a shoddy price. All the worse as the consequences on Cyprus of the Greek bond haircuts were obvious.”

EurActiv.com with Reuters

COMMENTS

  • In the EU no one can hear you scream. (with apologies to the film Alien, a SF film about a beast that bleeds acid and kills indiscriminately -- sounds like the EU).

    The authoritarianism of the EU is breathtaking. The expropriation of private wealth in savings accounts crosses a line we should all be very afraid of.

    It is more and more evident that the key decision-makers are making this up as they go along, have no clue what to do, and are too puffed up with their own self-importance to change their minds and are instead thinking of how they will look in the history books. Such hubris!

    Every crisis has critical event from which it mutates into something more terrible especially when the interventions are not working and feedback leads to the failure of hysteresis. Cyprus looks like that mutation.

    By :
    terreverte
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • This is a terrible move with potentially terrible consequences further down the line. The rational thing to do for individuals with money in banks in peripheral Eurozone countries is to withdraw their money from the bank as fast as possible and deposit it somewhere else, even stuffing under the mattress or buying something tangible like gold or diamonds.

    Cyprus might be cited as a special case because of Russian money, but other struggling peripheral Eurozone countries could now also become special cases on any basis you wish to invent.

    For banks in peripheral countries it potentially means their borrowing costs could go up & they'll pass those costs on to their struggling customers, it potentially destabilises them the minute the country they're situated in is nearing a potential bailout. That means the Eurozone may have to bailout more banks as there won't be any depositor confidence.

    It helps further deepen economic divisions in the Eurozone, but I suspect German, Dutch, Austrian even Swiss & UK banks will benefit from a flight of capital seeking safety.

    Also, in Cyprus's case why were small depositors also targeted? That seems unjust to say the least as the vast majority are not Russian Mafia or money launderers, just ordinary people trying to get by.

    A very worrying and unhelpful precedent has been set.

    By :
    Justin Pugsley, Principal, JJPAssociates
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • If Cyprus has natural Gas worth Billions then WHY accept Debt via a potential blackmail scenario ??
    The FALGAFT Plan from what I read would help fix the National Economic issues so why not adopt that scenario. ??

    By :
    Alyn Roule
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • I use the term "fictitious capital" to describe what the Big Bankers, public and private, are attempting to inflict on the ordinary 99% people who through their entrepreneur led labour create ALL REAL value, capital included.
    In the middle of the 19th century Karl Marx coined this term to describe the notes and loans that governments and gentry used to finance wars, luxuries, estates and otherwise living beyond their REAL means. Only his term was really new, Aristotle and many who followed him before Marx, elaborated on the dangers of worthless money. Democratic Athens and militaristic Sparta supplied the concrete examples of value and fictitious (worthless).
    At Marx’ time such paper would accrue during "Boom" times as the economy expanded and would usually max out at around 10-12% of a countries GDP. As long as the good times rolled on it was not a problem, but came a crisis of over production (of all the wrong things) there would be the day of reckoning. Ergo, the bill collectors came and cash not paper promises was the order of the day. This resulted in a variety of ways to settle; some were paid in part or in full but more often bankruptcies and swindles resulted. Then the stage was set for the next cycle - boom bust.
    Today though the situation with 'fictitious' or 'counterfeit capital is vastly different.
    100 years of pumped up growth for growths sake first based on the now discredited ideas of John Maynard Keynes has produced a situation where some 20 times the worlds gross product exists as fictitious capital, a counterfeit collection of deficits, bills, bonds, exchanges, derivatives, bubbles (real estate) swaps and the latest fraud, "quantitive easing". (Le Monde Diplomatique puts it at 50 times)
    $$Dollars, Єєuros, RRubles, Ль, &с…all the same!!
    To grasp the idiocy inherent in these figures imagine approaching your friendly personal banker for a loan, line of credit or mortgage some 20 times your net collateral worth; how far do you suppose that might fly?
    Yet with the above listed gimmicks, that is precisely what members of the bankster clique, supported by military-industrial complexes do amongst themselves.
    Every day we read of new Central and private bank meetings, "Increasing capital base" is their current fad.
    OFF THE WALL! There is not a farthing of REAL capital in all of this rat-bag of lies, swindles and manipulations.
    REAL capital is ONLY accumulated labour dedicated to enhancing future production. Ergo entrepreneur led LABOUR (of the 99%) is the only source that can augment existing capital or create new.
    The banksters, led by the IMF, USA FED, and British "financial services" are well aware of this fact but that will not stop them from attempting to download this fraud onto the REAL product of Labour in the form of "bailouts" of "sovereign" debts, to be serviced by taxes on the REAL producers.
    The 99% will be robbed of (much prepaid) social services and benefits to service "debts". “Austerity” it is called when those who had NO hand in running up this fraud are required to pay interest that will amount to 40-60% of the future product of their labour. Gone will be pensions, good schools, decent medical care, infrastructure (e.g. utilities that work reliably), environmental protection; even adequate diets will be history.
    "Let them eat cake!" exclaimed La Royale Marie Antoinette.
    Let them eat (genetically modified) garbage, implies La Grande Dame Christine La Garde, of the International Monetary Fascists(IMF)
    So Greece, you are the front line today, Italy and Spain may be next, but do not think that any country, including the relatively well off Germany or the resource rich Canada and Australia will be forever exempt. Ms Merkel, beware!
    The "poor little ones" are but appetizers; they will whet the appetites of these financial service vultures and jackals. For certain, like buzzards flocking to road kill. if they succeed in the beginning the taste of financial carrion will make them hunger for more, and they will finish only when the 99% of humanity is subject as debtors to enslavement by the 1%.
    But this does not have to be!
    Greece, Cyprus, you can repudiate the fraud! Lead the way! DEFAULT, Repudiate, is the way to go!
    99%; be inclusive! Occupy-Idlenomore, Support Greece and Slovenia today, Italy Spain, …, &c. tomorrow and.../?/ the world in future.
    Hold on to your souls! Hang tough!
    You have a WORLD to WIN!!
    P.S. For those of you who may have read this comment previously, Churchill’s advice immediately springs to mind:
    “When you have an important point to make, don’t try to be subtle or clever. Use a pile-driver. Hit the point once. Then come back and hit it again. Then hit it a third time – a tremendous whack.”

    By :
    david tarbuck
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • This is "right wing populist" but the facts are there!
    Bailouts on Wall st are of course part of the same; then the politicians go to the moguls to "donate" to their campaigns for election. Some call it "democracy!"

    What have "progressives" to say on the subject? Is there a collaborative solution? Do we leave it to demagogues?

    Why I Don't Support Europe's Bailouts
    Our political leaders borrow ever more money to pay off the banks, which return the favor by lending ever more money back to our governments
    By TIMO SOINI
    When I had the honor of leading the True Finn Party to electoral victory in April, we made a solemn promise to oppose the bailouts of euro-zone member states. Europe is suffering from the economic gangrene of insolvency—both public and private. Unless we amputate that which cannot be saved, we risk poisoning the whole body.
    To understand the real nature and purpose of the bailouts, we first have to understand who really benefits from them.
    At the risk of being accused of populism, we'll begin with the obvious: It is not the little guy ho benefits. He is being milked and lied to in order to keep the insolvent system running. He is paid less and taxed more to provide the money needed to keep this Ponzi scheme going. Meanwhile, a symbiosis has developed between politicians and banks: Our political leaders borrow ever more money to pay off the banks, which return the favor by lending ever more money back to our governments.
    In a true market economy, bad choices get penalized. Instead of accepting losses on unsound investments—which would have led to the probable collapse of some banks—it was decided to transfer the losses to taxpayers via loans, guarantees and opaque constructs such as the European Financial Stability Fund.
    The money did not go to help indebted economies. It flowed through the European Central Bank and recipient states to the coffers of big banks and investment funds.
    Further contrary to the official wisdom, the recipient states did not want such "help," not this way. The natural option for them was to admit insolvency and let failed private lenders, wherever they were based, eat their losses.
    That was not to be. Ireland was forced to take the money. The same happened to Portugal.
    View Full Image

    Getty Images
    Unfortunately for this financial and political cartel, their plan isn't working. Already under this scheme, Greece, Ireland and Portugal are ruined. They will never be able to save and grow fast enough to pay back the debts with which Brussels has saddled them in the name of saving them.
    Setting up the European Stability Mechanism is no solution. It would institutionalize the system of wealth transfers from private citizens to compromised politicians and failed bankers, creating a huge moral hazard and destroying what remains of Europe's competitive banking landscape.
    Fortunately, it is not too late to stop the rot. For the banks, we need honest, serious stress tests. Stop the current politically inspired farce. Instead, have parallel assessments done by regulators and independent groups including stakeholders and academics. Trust, but verify.
    Insolvent banks and financial institutions must be shut down, purging insolvency from the system. We must restore the market principle of freedom to fail.
    If some banks are recapitalized with taxpayer money, taxpayers should get ownership stakes in return, and the entire board should be kicked out. But before any such taxpayer participation can be contemplated, it is essential to first apply big haircuts to bondholders.
    For sovereign debt, the freedom to fail is again key. Significant restructuring is needed for genuine recovery. Yes, markets will punish defaulting states, but they are also quick to forgive. Current plans are destroying the real economies of Europe through elevated taxes and transfers of wealth from ordinary families to the coffers of insolvent states and banks. A restructuring that left a country's debt burden at a manageable level and encouraged a return to growth-oriented policies could lead to a swift return to international debt markets.
    This is not just about economics. People feel betrayed. In Ireland, the incoming parties to the new government promised to hold senior bondholders responsible, but under pressure they succumbed, leaving their voters with a sense of disenfranchisement. The elites in Brussels have said that Finland must honor its commitments to its European partners, but Brussels is silent on whether national politicians should honor their commitments to their own voters.
    I was raised to know that genocidal war must never again be visited on our continent and I came to understand the values and principles that originally motivated the establishment of what became the European Union. This Europe, this vision, was one that offered the people of Finland and all of Europe the gift of peace founded on democracy, freedom and justice. This is a Europe worth having, so it is with great distress that I see this project being put in jeopardy by a political elite who would sacrifice the interests of Europe's ordinary people in order to protect certain corporate interests.
    Mr. Soini is chairman of the True Finn Party in Finland.

    By :
    david tarbuck
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • Well I have just transferred my savings from my Spanish bank back to the UK. I am sure I'm not the only one to do it either. Any person who lives in Spain Greece Ireland or Portugal that doesn't take most of their cash out of the banks is taking a big risk. The only reason that Germany has done this to Cyprus is just to test the water. The next EU country that needs a bail out?......well! Just make all efforts to put your savings in a safe place, out of reach of the EU.

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • The Great Train Robbers got 30 years - who is accountable for this state authorised theft?

    By :
    Edward99
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • @ Philip royle
    Good decision Philip. My worry is that they haven't thought this through.

    Could be a good time to buy up the world's supply of second hand mattresses!!

    By :
    George Mc
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • Edward99, In answer to your question it's Germany.

    Let me propose a scenario. The Eu unelected dictators, commissioners and other Eurocrats get their heads together with the Cypriot Government.
    The have to get a plan together. What ever the plan is, it's agreed that the end result must show Germany the EU and the Cypriot government in a good light. It must also raise money.
    One of the Eurocrats says "I know we can take 6.75% from poor Cypriot savers and 9.9% from the rich Cypriot savers. Now there will of course be wild outrage on the streets, there may be riots, but here's the cunning plan. At the last second in rides the Cypriot Government on it's white horse and shining armour. It will shout that it's wrong to tax the poor people of Cyprus and demands that the 6.75% tax is withdrawn which of course Germany and the EU will agree to sorted!"

    So the poor Cypriot savers will hail their Government as saviours of the people and go home rejoicing in the Eu and it's mighty benefactor Germany for saving their hard earned money. Mean while the rich get to pay for the bail out........ well their only Russian and rich so who cares about them?

    And they all live happily ever after.

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • Thank you George Mc. As this story was unfolding I rang one of my Spanish brother in laws. He is one of the few people I know that has an large lump of money in a bank. I told him what was being reported on the British press. It just so happened that he was watching the same story on the Spanish press. The stories were completely different.
    While the UK press and news outlets were telling what we now know to be the truth. The Spanish news was saying it's all rubbish and nothing to worry about It was only extra bank charges and nothing more, an extra charge on the rates! and made no mention of the 6.75% tax on people with under €100,000. So he dismissed my claim.
    It must have played on his mind as this morning I got a call from him and an apology. As I type he is sorting out his money so it's save and telling as many of his friends to do the same as quickly as possible.
    This Cyprus thing is just to test the water. The next bail out, and there will be another, will be very interesting. How will the EU and Germany deal with the inequality of taking money from Cypriot private bank accounts and not from Spanish or Irish or Greek?

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • @ Philip Royle

    Philip, I agree with your assumptions. This is a template for what may happen if any of the PIGS need a bail out.

    I just cannot get over the absolute arrogance of Germany who appears to be in the 'Head Girl' role.

    It would appear that the bullying of Cyprus and the results of this could endanger the Euro. We can be very harsh on the Banks in the UK but at least we can have some confidence that our money is fairly safe. What will this do to the confidence in the Banks and the economy of Cyprus. Following on from that ask the same questions about what it will mean for Portugal, Italy, Greece and Spain.

    I had thought that the Euro problems were disappearing into history when it fact it looks like it has possibly stumbled into another deep crisis.

    What's the odds on Euro2 with just Netherlands, Germany, Austria, Finland and Finland in the club with Euro1 getting cut loose.

    I am not a fan or either the EU or the Euro but we need this crap like a hole in the head.

    One of my Neighbours friends is in a bit of a panic as they have sold their house and transferred money to a Solicitors Account in Cyprus. They are now worried that they may be £20,000 Euros down which will also mean that they may not be able to buy their house.

    By :
    George Mc
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • George Mc!! How bitter and twisted I must have become!! When I read your comment about buying up second hand mattresses, I immediately thought of the Mafia phrase "going to the mattresses". This refers to the scene in the Godfather when Sonny mobilises his forces agains the other Families and the Tattaglias for the attempts on Don Corleone's life - in effect, going to war and oh, how my heart leapt!! And then I realised that, yours being the voice of reason was referring to a hidey-hole to secrete one's savings!! I just need to calmmyself down now and wait for a genuine (no offence intended) "call to arms"!!
    PS. I bet I get a visit from Britain's answer to the Stasi (we have got them now, you know!)

    By :
    Don Latuske
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • On a more serious note, I do suggest that people, especially in the Eurozone, look to other non-eurozone countries to move whatever remains of their savings. I can with a clear conscience suggest Poland where the ING bank is offering interest rates on some of their products of 5.85% - unheard of here in the UK for some years. Poland's government have discussed joining the euro in 2017 but that decision has been put off interminably since I can remember. Given the current situatuation, which I can believe will take a generation to overcome, it seems to me that Poland will join the euro on the 12th of Never. I do believe, however, that as the debt mountain stays high and reduces slowly if at all, eurozone governments (and I can imagine a mad-dog government of LibDem/Lab liars in the UK) will seriously consider a "tax" on savings/pensions etc., if they can see no other way out of the situation.
    Poland (although Polish people marvel at what I say) is seen as pretty much the only country with any real growth in the EU for the coming period and seems to have been hardly affected by the credit crunch/banking failure.

    By :
    Don Latuske
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • I would think your neighbour is in a very difficult position. I have recently retired and only lately have I developed an interest in things EU. I must admit to not being a natural political animal I find some of the things I read a tad over my head. But what I do read and understand very often leaves me quaking with rage!
    My take on thing quite simple is that the EU is running at full speed just to stand still.
    I have the benefit of having input from three EU countries. France where my sister in law has lived for over 40 years and all her children are French. My own family in the UK and of course my family here in Spain. What I know and what I hear from ordinary people fly's in the face of the EU and member states government propaganda.
    For me the EU is like communism, a political ideal that doesn't work. The problem is that the big countries like Germany and France are keeping the whole thing going but it's all artificial. I have no doubt that somewhere in a German government building there is a document on Germanys exit from the EU. The same in France.
    All their doing now is prolonging the agony.

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • @ Don Latuske
    "I just need to calmmyself down now and wait for a genuine (no offence intended) "call to arms"!!"

    Don, I have my old RN uniform in the loft ready for action. Getting into it might be problematical, but I am available!

    By :
    George Mc
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • Hey welcome to euroextremism. The brussels bankers are worse than the mob. I feel for the people of cyprus, we in the netherlands are starting to feel the crunch to. Our economy is in the second spot just in front of the greeks,gotta love the euro huh.
    This is all a game , the bankers hold the purse strings in europe , and who are the bankers. Bilderbergers!!
    They are empire building period, and all the countries in hotel california are just pawns. Get used to it folks euroextremism is not democratic and countries like cyprus are just going to loose for the bigger picture. Its one big created bailout show .
    The next move from brussels will be,(we have to move swiftly with fiscal integration then all these problems will go away)??
    Its good that van rumpass is going ,although i still dont know whos president he thought he was, and i dread the though of what his replacement will be .
    They need to listen to the people and not the banks. Give us our countries and democracy back!!!!
    And no im not a nationalist or populist or whatever they like to call people who dont agree with their beliefs. We in the netherlands are just as ripped of by brussels as the rest, and its time to stop the plundering...

    By :
    klassen
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • George Mc and Don Latuske. I still have my Beret and RA cap badge some where! what with my general service medal we'll make a formidable force.......so long as it doesn't stray too far from the pub! lol

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • George, Philip - you put me to shame. I only had my CCF uniform (RAF) which I had to return after leaving (being de-mobbed!) when I entered the sixth form. But what I lack in miltary training I can make up with a calm, well-controlled honicidal fury. Running berserk, I think the Vikings called it!!

    By :
    Don Latuske
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • klassen, I am quite surprised that someone from the Netherlands is a fellow Eurosceptic. But welcome to the club! I would slightly disagree that the bankers are the sole cause of the Euro woe's After all they have been allowed to do what they do by the EU and member governments. But with that said I agree we need to get our democracy back where it belongs in our own countries. The EU has it's use but it's just been allowed to get toooooo big!

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • By :klassen- Posted on : 18/03/2013

    Really ! You just talked as one populist or nationalist!..

    By :
    an european
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • Klassen, I have always failed to understand what is wrong with terms such as nationalist or populist. As far as I could ever love a thing, then I "love" my country (just!).If that makes me a nationalist, so be it. If, by populist, one means going along with the majority, then, yes, I am a populist. As Yossarian says in Catch-22, when he is asked rhetorically by his commanding officer, "what would happen if everybody said they did not want to fight" (referring to WW2) then Yossarian answers, logically, "Then I would be a fool to want to (fight)".
    When push comes to shove, there are no Europeans, just frightenend and impoverished Germans, French, British, Dutch...........et al

    By :
    Don Latuske
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • Klassen. You have me confused. You call me a nationalist and a populist (whatever that is?)
    And yet you say 'The Brussels bankers are worse than the mob' and 'Give us our countries and democracy back' and then you say your not a nationalist ??????

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    18/03/2013
  • Argentinian practices in the EU. How deeper can government leaders sink in the "Year of the European Citizen"? At least the citizens are still civilized, given their behavour towards the opportunistic political mobs, which roam around in Brussel.

    By :
    Willem,a Dutchman
    - Posted on :
    19/03/2013
  • Cyprus: A paradigm for Spain, Greece, Portugal and Italy
    When the European historical leaders proceeded with the creation of the European dream, they had in mind a family which will respect human rights, freedom and of course its citizens. A family, which will look after its people, despite their ethnicity. A family, through which, solidarity, will create a better and a more prosperous future. It seems that, those European leaders, understood half a century ago that in order for a European country to prosper, their neighbours should proposer as well.
    The economic crisis in Cyprus was mainly created by the exposure of the Cypriot banking sector to the Greek debt, which, as agreed by the EU leaders, was reduced with a haircut. The truth is that one month prior to this decision of the Greek haircut, and while the EU officials where assuring that the Greek bonds are guaranteed, the German banks were selling those bonds to the Cypriot banks with a discount.
    Last Friday, the Eurogroup decided to send a small member state to an ongoing recession, while ignoring that the outcome of this decision will soon backfire to other EU members which are facing similar economic problems.
    Last Friday, the European leaders acted as national leaders and not as Europeans, neglecting the fact we are all sailing in the same boat, adding to the slow death of the European dream.
    Last Friday, the European leaders violated fundamental human and European laws and values, and imposed to the Cypriot government an all-out haircut on Cypriot deposits. This, naturally, created a panic which resulted in many depositors expressing their willingness to withdraw their deposits from the country. This will create an even bigger economic problem to Cyprus, with unforeseen outcome which will probably lead to more austerity measures. It is difficult for us to believe that Eurogroups decision was made in order to server the interest of the Cypriot and the European people, and everybody will have to wonder that once this decision was implemented to a small economy such as Cyprus, what will be the measures that will be introduced to Italy or Spain?
    As a European and Cypriot citizen I believe in the dream of a united Europe, as it was perceived by Shuman, Monnet, Adenhaur and Spinelli. As a European citizen I am asking from my national parliament to act today as a European body and reject this agreement for the sake of the Spanish, the Italians, the Portuguese, the Greek and the Cypriot people. I am asking from our national members of Parliament to reject this agreement for the sake of the future of EU and for the sake of our children.

    By :
    Christos
    - Posted on :
    19/03/2013
  • I am sorry for your country Christos. But you have now woken up to the truth behind the 'European dream' or should I say 'Nightmare' Many of us have seen this but the Blinkered and blind smaller countries that join have been fooled.
    They are allowed to drink from the wine cup of the Eu but as every one knows wine isn't free and there will be a price. Cyprus is paying. Spain Portugal Ireland and in a few years the Eastern block EU countries will follow. The EU is a running sore that will never heal. I wish you country well and hope you come out the other side in one piece but with a clearer view of the EU and the truth behind it. But I wouldn't shout about it you'll just be treated like the British!

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    19/03/2013
  • First priority for the EU is to purge itself of the British and their "financial services pimps of Wall st!

    Only then will the EU be able to get away from fictitious capital - quantitive easing and all the rest of the sleazy Bankster tricks!!

    By :
    david tarbuck
    - Posted on :
    19/03/2013
  • The Euro is by far the greatest threat to the global economy and the actions over Cyprus may well mark a milestone in it's eventual demise.

    Simply put so much Euro debt is held across borders within Europe's fragile banking system & elsewhere that should members start leaving, it could cause banking collapses, which will quickly ripple across the world.

    The Euro is a currency without a country, a central bank with a limited mandate, and members who are unwilling or unable to make the sacrifices to keep the single currency in existence. People in peripheral Eurozone countries are already paying a bitter price through economic depression and mass unemployment.

    Historians will probably come to view the formation of the Euro, without first putting in the necessary fiscal stabilisers, as one of the greatest financial follies ever attempted by humanity.

    The catastrophic consequences of the break-up of the Euro would make the US sub-prime crisis look like a rehearsal.

    All those boasts about how Europe had triumphed over economics and the law of the jungle look increasingly deluded and dangerous.

    The only experiment more crazy than the Euro was probably communism, but this one has the potential to wreck lives all around the globe and not just in Europe.

    The Eurozone crisis is already spinning beyond the control of Europeans and after Cyprus they look even more incapable of managing the crisis they engineered through poor design.

    The world quite rightly increasingly lives in fear of the Eurozone and its potential to unleash a global disaster.

    By :
    Justin Pugsley, Principal, JJPAssociates
    - Posted on :
    19/03/2013
  • Well said Justin and very true!

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    19/03/2013
  • Ah, Mr. Tarbuck!!! Wildly lashing out at other themes than this particular one, as usual!! Yes, by all means, get rid of the British. I think others may follow and we will leave you with your EU pals, you know, the gangster shysters that have just robbed, quite illegally, innocent, hard-working Cypriots (and to appease your mindless hatred of the Brits, I shall exclude those ex-pats there)and who knows what other countries' depositers are to follow?!!

    Regards, as usual, to your Uncle Jimmy

    By :
    Don Latuske
    - Posted on :
    19/03/2013
  • @ Don Latuske
    Don, Please don't encourage Mr Tarbuck. Unless he is cut and pasting large articles from Pravda and the Morning Star he usually confines himself to short consistent sentences of Bollocks.

    By :
    George Mc
    - Posted on :
    19/03/2013
  • @ Justin Pugsley

    Your post in very true, regrettably.

    The Eurozone is not being very clever with Cyprus as I can see the possibility of the Cypriot Parliament rejecting this with the country going bust and the Russians rushing to to save them for a big say in any gas and oil supplies.

    By :
    George Mc
    - Posted on :
    19/03/2013
  • Lets start of again by saying im not a nationalist or anything of the sort. What i am is worried, i see a form of extremism developing and its in the zealous defence of a currency that is just to costly , not only financially ,but people are also suffering, and its not worth it.
    Whats developing is euroextremism, and this by itself is worrying. They will do what it takes to defend this rotten currency. Country after country have fallen because of the euro. Poverty is on the rise, democracy is starting to stumble, and were all going bankrupt.
    Whats wrong with this picture folks?
    Any kind of extremism is just plain bad, regardless of origin.
    The euro was create to stop extremism and is having the opposite effect, its just a disaster , and there are some countries whom seek opportunity and profit at the expense and downfall of some countries, this is so wrong, just plain wrong.
    And yes to my countrymen from the netherlands, a referendum is a crok. In the 80s the dutch goverment signed into law a bill which states,(regardless of which constitution ,dutch integration into europe cannot and will not be stopped). The outcome of a referendum in holland is nonbinding, these are games rutte/samson are playing and are biding for time to fullfill their obligations to brussels.
    The have sold the shop , lock stock and barrel , problem is most people in NL dont know it yet.

    By :
    klassen
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • George Mc - you can't really blame them if they did fall into the embrace of the Russians. Given the craziness going on out there it wouldn't be surprising if the British military weren't asked to leave as result of this nonsense to be replaced by the Russian military. Woops that would put the cat among the pigeons & deeply upset NATO!

    By :
    Justin Pugsley, Principal, JJPAssociates
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • @ Justin Pugsley

    Justin, no disagreement there. In addition because the EU foreign policy is guided by someone with no experience (Ashton,) with a strong guiding arm from Germany. They have not realised that the Russians may be looking for a replacement for their only 'warm water' port in Syria if that all goes belly up.
    The Russians are many things but stupid is not one of them.

    By :
    George Mc
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • I have no doubt that this whole thing was planed down to the smallest detail. They
    (Not yet really sure who 'they' are yet) Were waiting for one of the small EU euro zone dead weight countries to get to the position that Cyprus finds it's self in now. They will kill a load of birds with one crack of the whip. They will learn the strength of feeling around the Euro zone, 'they' will send a shot over the bows of other dead weight euro zone countries, 'they' will see what happens when a country goes bankrupt, 'they' will find out what happens to a country that leaves the Euro. And lastly 'they' will find out what happens to the the Euro zone when one of the countries fails and the reaction of the rest. I have no doubt that the Euro zone can stand the loss of Cyprus, as I say I'm sure it's all been planed. With that said there is with every plan an unknown factor. I look forward to finding out what that unknown factor is and how it plays out. Interesting times indeed!

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • Philip, you're asking whether it is cock-up or conspiracy. I'd suggest the former. I don't think these people running the show are smart enough to conspire.

    I agree though that events are providing real-world tests of various solutions, but to suggest this is all planned out, would be stretching the ability of Europe's leaders to think beyond their re-election.

    By :
    terreverte
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • Philip like terreverte I tend to go with the cock-up theory as well, I really don't believe that planning by committee with all its compromises can be that smart & this latest salvo is not smart at all.

    Plus Germany holds elections in September I think? So Merkel has an eye on that and some tough love to the 'ill disciplined southerners' should go down well with the German electorate.

    Also, if Cyprus leaves the Euro it sets up a nasty precedent and the Eurozone really doesn't want to go there, because if one leaves the rest can potentially go as well. It's like pulling the thread on a jumper and watching it unravel and the markets will yank on that string until it falls apart.

    By :
    Justin Pugsley, Principal, JJPAssociates
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • terreverte and Justin thank you. But I am, like many scratching my head. If it is a cock up it's a monumental one and says more about the intelligence of the EU elite. They must be thick as pig s--t! Even I could see the problems, possible consequences and out comes as soon as I saw the deal. I just cannot for the life of me think that the EU elite or 'Them' are that thick. And may I add I am a complete Euro sceptic and wouldn't trust a politician as far as I could throw one! Which leads me back to a meticulously conceived plan by 'them'.
    If it turns out to be a cock up, even the most die hard Europhile must have a moment of pause and think WTF!

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • there are mainly corrupted russian mafia money in Cyprus banks !! A corrupted Cyprus Governemental Problem indeed !!

    Should Cyprus become an real EU-member or being a russian Kadjachstam for the the future!

    By :
    an european
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • Agreed 'an European' But I would say that Cyprus isn't the only EU country with buckets of Russian Mafia money. I would also suggest that Russia isn't the only country that has money hidden in EU banks. China?

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • Hi Philip, I think you've got it in one, add in the need for many compromises (because this is decision by committee), a focus on national interest first, a complete misunderstanding of the dynamics of markets and human psychology (ie how people will react at getting their savings raided) and you have the recipe for dreadful decisions.

    But don't forget these are the same kinds of people who launched a single currency with no proper fiscal support mechanisms, a central bank with too narrow a mandate, no centralised banking regulation or supervision, no proper system for crisis management, took no account what so ever of issues such as the potential for economic divergence.

    It's a bit like building a car, which only has an accelerator, but no breaks and no stirring wheel so when you come to a bend there's little you can do accept try and put one in while in motion. And that is the ultimate stupidity in this whole affair.

    In the end national self interest will triumph and that's why I'm not optimistic for the future of the Eurozone. It simply demands much too much sacrifice from all concerned including ultimately the Germans because they'll have to pay to bail everyone else out and they can't afford it, the problem is just too big.

    By :
    Justin Pugsley, Principal, JJPAssociates
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • Philip royle - Posted on :20/03/2013
    Do you mean Secret Banking ?
    Switzerland YES ! NOT the EU because the EU doesn't tolerate such secrets banks apart one EU-state Luxembourg!

    By :
    an european
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
  • an European. I have no proof just a resignation that the whole of the Eu is corrupt to one extent or another. May be the Eu doesn't allow it but member states? who knows what goes on behind closed bank vault doors? I mean it would appear that the HSBC has been laundering money for years?

    By :
    Philip royle
    - Posted on :
    20/03/2013
Anastasiades: 'Cyprus was given no choice'
Background: 

The entire island of Cyprus is officially EU territory, but the country is divided. Turkey, an EU candidate, doesn’t recognise the Republic of Cyprus and has occupied the northern part of the island since 1974.

Cyprus is heavily exposed to the Greek crisis and needs to salvage its banking system, which in recent years has become a haven for rich Russians.

Eight months of inconclusive talks on a bailout package

have turned tiny Cyprus into a big headache for the eurozone, triggering fears of a financial collapse that reignites the bloc's debt crisis.

Nicos Anastasiades, who won a resounding victory in the February elections, promised to “restore the credibility of Cyprus”. He faces weeks of difficult talks with foreign lenders on a financial rescue for the nation. 

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Euro & Finance News videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Euro & Finance Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising