EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Estonia fends off Russian accusations of ‘Nazi glorification’

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 20 July 2012

Russia has reacted angrily to a recent gathering in Estonia of World War II veterans attended by the defence minister, saying Estonia was "glorifying" Nazi Waffen SS veterans. Talinn insisted that the event had “nothing in common with recognising Nazism”.

Russia said that the gathering last weekend in Saaremaa was “aimed at glorification of former SS-men and local collaborationists”. According to Moscow, the event could be interpreted in “no other way than intentional propagation of pro-Nazi attitude in Estonian society”.

In a statement, a spokesperson of the Russian Foreign Ministry also called the gathering “undisguised jeering at the memory of those who saved the world from ‘brown plague’ at the expense of their own lives.”

Estonian Defence Minister Urmas Reinsalu denied in a written statement to EurActiv that the event was a glorification of fascism. A European Commission official said the EU executive would study the situation before reacting.

Russia, which lost 20 million people in World War II, is particularly sensitive to attempts to present all war veterans in the same category. Moscow also keeps Estonia, a former Soviet republic, under close watch (see background).

Russia seems particularly that the Reinsalu delivered a speech at the veterans’ event.

“His expression of gratitude to fascism vassals for ‘saving the honour of Estonian people’ is evidence of ‘mythopoetry’ of the official Tallinn in relation to World War II events,” the Russian spokesperson stated.

Russian media report that among those present were the veterans of the 20th Waffen SS division and other Estonians who fought on the Nazi side in WWII against Soviet occupation of the country.

The Estonian Anti-Fascist Committee, an NGO, accused Reinsalu of “demonstrating to the whole world that Nazi ideology can be justified and those who followed Hitler’s orders can become national heroes”.

Europe turning a blind eye?

“The reason for such negligence to the norms of law and morals is based on only one thing – the higher echelons of power in the European Union are turning a blind eye to neo-Nazi sentiments and refuse to pay attention to the falsification of history and the making of Nazi criminals in Europe into heroes,” the Anti-Fascist Committee stated, quoted by the Russian TV channel RT.

Asked by EurActiv to comment on the accusations, Reinsalu said in a written answer that the Estonian Parliament recognised “the merits of those who fought in the name of Estonia’s independence”.

On the other hand, he insisted that the Parliament had “unequivocally” condemned the crimes against humanity perpetrated during the Soviet and National Socialist German occupations, “regardless of the citizenship of the perpetrator or where the crimes were carried out”. 

The minister further wrote that “the gathering of the Association of Estonian Freedom Fighters held in Saaremaa last week was a civic initiative event to commemorate those who fought for Estonia’s freedom as well as the victims of the occupation regimes. Accusations that depict events held to commemorate the victims of totalitarian regimes as manifestations of neo-Nazism are erroneous and deeply offensive.”

He insisted that his country consistently condemned the crimes of all the totalitarian regimes that occupied Estonia – Nazism and Stalinism – and denounced “all attempts to distort this message”.

EurActiv.com

COMMENTS

  • Is EurActive a Russian government media channel?! Why the only "External links" are the Russian propaganda links?
    It is surprising that Russian Government dares to comment the issues of WWII at all (refer to: Katyn massacre: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Katyn_massacre; the Molotov-Ribbentrop secret pact where Stalin and Hitler divided Eastern Europe etc.)

    Here's a balanced comment from the accused side:
    http://www.kmin.ee/en/reinsalu-accusations-against-estonia-are-false)

    Furthermore, Russia speaking about morals and ethics? Lets think about Syria or war in Georgia or Chechenya...) LOL!

    By :
    M.L.
    - Posted on :
    20/07/2012
  • Russia has absolutely nothing to lament about. There is a very big Nazi-problem in Russia itself. And there is this upcoming Stalinism. So, why is EA serving as a russian propaganda-speaker??? Estonia is a very successfull democracy in Europe.
    Russia is no trusted "watchdog", it a problematic troublemaker. So, please, don't give them so much room to spoil European unity!

    By :
    gustav
    - Posted on :
    20/07/2012
  • This little country has a tragic history. I would hope that, within those who fought for independence, it condemns those who did so by collaborating with the Nazis.

    By :
    Charles
    - Posted on :
    20/07/2012
  • I agree with 'gustav' that Fascist like movements in Russia are the real problem, not commemoration of people who fought against Soviet occupation. Russia has failed to come to terms with the fact that the so-called Russian Liberation Army (aka ROA), trained and equipped by the Nazis and commanded by the former Red Army Lt. gen. Andrei Vlasov, was composed of tens of thousands of Russians who had chosen to fight against Stalin and his God-less autocratic regime. Vlasov and several of his generals were eventually captured and executed on Stalin's orders but even today there are Russians abroad who admire his and his commanders' courage to stand up against Stalin's regime.

    By :
    Over the Ocean
    - Posted on :
    21/07/2012
  • And why shouldn't have Estonians fought against the territorial designs of a greedy, self-serving Georgian sociopath? They had a moral imperative to do so.

    By :
    Ross
    - Posted on :
    21/07/2012
  • Glorifying these old Nazis is truly disgusting. The EU should reprimand the government, as well as the government of Lithuania, where they just re-buried their Nazi-era leader with state honours. It's revolting.

    As usual, the excuse is than anyone who was anti-Soviet must be a hero. No matter that they butchered, or assisted or assented to the butchering of tens of thousands of people.

    These are criminals. They should have long been jailed.

    By :
    decent
    - Posted on :
    21/07/2012
  • If the Russians had not allowed that Turkish fruiterer lookalike, Mr Iossef Dzhugashvili to rise through their ranks unopposed - then we would not be having this discussion.

    By :
    Ross
    - Posted on :
    22/07/2012
  • Response to Ross:
    While Dzugashvili (aka Stalin) was a Georgian, there were many other nationals in the revolutionary communist clique. Trotsky and Litvinov were Jews, Derzhynski was a Pole, Molotov, Voroshilov and dozens of others were Russians.Two of Stalin's three wifes were Jewish, one was a sister of Lazar Kaganovich known as the chief murderer of millions of peasants in Ukraine, the Don region and Kuban during forced collectivisation in the early 1930s.

    By :
    Over the Ocean
    - Posted on :
    22/07/2012
  • The same tired Russian accusations, ignoring that when the moment for freedom came, the Estonians were fighting both the Nazis and Soviets on two fronts, and it was the Estonian flag the Red Army ripped down in Tallinn. Ignoring that the Latvians were stationed as guards at Nuremberg, not convicted at Nuremberg.

    The only crime here is commemorating those who fought only against Soviet RE-occupation. Consider, what kind of occupation it was on the part of the Soviets that anyone would even consider fighting with one occupier (Nazi Germany) against the prior occupier (Soviet Union, occupied Estonia first).

    The only rewriting of history is Russia whitewashing its rape of the Baltic states while Stalin and Hitler were partners in carving up Eastern Europe.

    By :
    PJV
    - Posted on :
    04/08/2012
Veterans at Saaremaa, photo RIA Novosti
Background: 

In 1939, the Soviet Union and Nazi Germany concluded the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact, the secret protocols of which divided Central and Eastern Europe into respective spheres of influence.

The same year, Germany launched the Second World War with its attack on Poland and the Soviet Union started to fulfil its role by invading Poland from the east, at the same time concentrating large forces on the borders of the three Baltic States and Finland.

The Soviet Union occupied Estonia along with Latvia and Lithuania in 1940. The Soviet occupation was followed by Estonia’s occupation by Nazi Germany in July 1941. In September 1944 Estonia was again occupied by the Soviet Union. Estonia regained its independence in 1991.

For the most part Estonians were mobilised by force by the totalitarian regimes that occupied Estonia what is against international law.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Europe's East News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Europe's East Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising