EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

War of letters reveals Georgia’s political tensions

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 12 March 2013

The chairman of the Georgian Parliament has responded strongly to criticism from the European Parliament’s centre-right European People’s Party bloc that Tbilisi’s Prime Minister could "close European doors" by backsliding on democratic reform.

Twenty-three MEPs published an open letter to Georgia's Prime Minister Bidzina Ivanishvili on 6 March, accusing him of backsliding on democracy.

The signatories include Jerzy Buzek, erstwhile Polish premier and former European Parliament president, Elmar Brok, who heads Parliament's foreign affairs committee, and former Lithuanian head of state Vytautas Landsbergis - all three affiliated to the European People's Party (EPP).

The 23 MEPs listed a litany of grievances, including public pressure on legislators; pressure on the judiciary and the public broadcaster; inflammatory rhetoric and use of mobs to silence political opponents; and the frequent use of hate speech.

Georgia's “European perspective” could be compromised under such circumstances, the MEPs warned.

Since elections on 1 October (see background) the political situation in Georgia has been marked by a standoff between Prime Minister Bidzina Ivanishvili and President Mikheil Saakashvili. Saakashvili’s camp has been repeatedly accused of amplifying its messages using lobbyists and a number of conservative Western politicians.

>> Read: Georgian foreign minister lashes out at EU centre-right party

David Usupashvili, Chairman of the Georgian Parliament and chairman of the Republican Party of Georgia, which is part of the Ivanishvili-led ‘Georgian Dream’ coalition, wrote to the 23 MEPs, asking them to check their facts before throwing accusations.

“Please do not set President Saakashvili and his former regime as a standard as it would be an insult to Europe […] I urge you to abstain from signing statements based on unsubstantiated claims, as you will soon feel embarrassed for your actions,” Usupashvili wrote in a letter dated 10 March.

He strongly rejected the MEP's assertion that Tbilisi's pro-European stance could be threatened by the current administrations intent to axe a constitutional provision allowing the President to sack a government and appoint a new one without parliamentary approval.

Ivanishvili and Saakashvili met on 4 March for the second time after the October elections. The news website Civil Georgia quoted Ivanishvili saying that Saakashvili had not given him a clear answer on whether he supported the proposed constitutional amendment.

Although ‘Georgian Dream’ holds a majority in Parliament, this falls short of the 100 seats required to pass constitutional reforms. Saakashvili has downplayed the issue, saying he has no intention of using this constitutional right to sack the sitting government and appoint a new one without Parliament’s approval.

Saakashvili has reportedly complained that activists from his his United National Movement (UNM) were being persecuted as well as mid-level officials from the previous government. He also complained about attacks on the judiciary, which he said was under threat from the authorities, and the new government’s “campaign to impose political control over the media”.

Local media quoted Ivanishvili as saying that this was a "pot calling the kettle black" kind of argument, suggesting that Saakashvili was responsible of similar wrong-doings while his own UNM party was in power.

EurActiv.com

COMMENTS

  • Geogia like Ukraine ought to REJECT EU "report cards".

    By :
    david tarbuck
    - Posted on :
    12/03/2013
  • Mr.Ivanishvili is little by little taking Georgia back to the Russian orbit. This is a conscious, well planned action. Mr.Usupashvili, former soviet comunist party activist (today he pretends to have anti-soviet credentials, like Shevardnadze did), but with more pro-western image, is helping Ivanishvili to conceal his anti western (eu/nato) plans. It's a sad story of once one of the most promissing post-communist country becoming a small copy of Putin's Russia.

    By :
    Arjan
    - Posted on :
    12/03/2013
  • I completely agree with Mr. usupashvili: “Please do not set President Saakashvili and his former regime as a standard as it would be an insult to Europe". I would like to remind the signatories, especially EPP members and Mr. Elmar Brok, that the leadership of his party CDU is describing Mr.Saakashvili as "crazy","a hot head" and "dangerous"(see the cable #08BERLIN1542,14.11.2008).So please,stop using double standards and hypocrisy.

    By :
    zura danelishvili Georgia
    - Posted on :
    12/03/2013
  • Mr. Angry man from Georgia (zura danielishvili),

    Nobody is defending Saakashvili. He is gone (alomost). Your "talking points" about "crazy" Saakashvili are not interesting any more, you are not any more in opposition and the electoral campaign is over. By the way, these "talking points" about "deviant" and "sick" president of Georgia are written in Moscow, before even your party "Georgian Dream" was founded. I was working in Moscow in 2004-2006 and the guys were already "working" on that at Lubianka. Did you ask anybody who was writing these texts you have learnt by heart?

    Saakashvili lost, and it's only his own fault. But you are not credible at all. The assault on courts, on local governments, on independent universities - you are behaving badly. You are behaving badly, because you are afraid of loosing. You want to destroy your adversaries before next elections, you are in a hurry.

    And stop blaming Saakashvili and EPP, we are fed-up with this in this town. I'm socialist, I didn't like Saakashvili's extreme liberalism in economy, but your government is just a proxy of a foreign power and is not democratic at all.

    Your justice minister, who was here last week, is just as scaring as any north korean or cuban officials (sorry, Cubans are much friendlier). Sorry to tell you that. Your objective is to put EU against Georgia and then to celebrate Russian victory. Maybe you don't know it, but your boss knows. Ask him if you have the chance to dare. All the best!

    Arjan Van den Berg,
    Expert on Energy, SLC, Brussels

    By :
    Arjan
    - Posted on :
    12/03/2013
  • Mr.Arjan Van den Berg. You are fed up with truth, because it is bitter.

    By :
    zura danelishvili Georgia
    - Posted on :
    12/03/2013
  • made this comment relating to Ukraine but as the circumstances are similar it applies also to Georgia.

    As they have to date been presented BOTH the "Customs Union" and the "Association Agreement ought to be rejected by Ukraine AND GEORGIA.

    KGB Putin's C.U. is an OVERT bully boy move to regurgitate the former S.U.; dismissing that one is thus the obvious way to go.

    The threat from the EU is covert and hidden at the bottom of the bag of carrots (and candy) thus there is the hidden danger born of not actually comprehending what a naive entity such as Ukraine or Georgia might let itself in for. Those who offer such carrots are just as eager for the powers of "regime change" as are the other above mentioned bully boys of the Soviet Union.

    Obviously many look at German automobiles and French perfumes through rose coloured lens and ignore the realities of: Greece, Portugal, Romania, Bulgaria, Hungary, &c. How realistic is it to think that Ukraine's road to Paris or Berlin will be shorter than that for any of the above?

    The correct course for Ukraine/Georgia at this point in time is to pursue:
    1) Self help; make it ourselves e.g trams, buses, rail-cars,
    2) Free trade among equals world-wide with reciprocity and protectionism limited to defense against predatory trading practices.
    3) special attention to developing relations with such as:
    Turkey, China, Iran, India, Egypt, Georgia, Ukraaine, Celac, African Union and all of N.A.M.
    4) good relations with C.U. and EU on the same basis as these others.

    By :
    david tarbuck
    - Posted on :
    13/03/2013
  • EPP resolution: "In the light of the recent events in Georgia that have undermined its democratic standards,The European People’s Party underlines with a high degree of satisfaction the progresses made during the last years in the fields of rule of law and democratic standards". 23 Then Jesus talked to the people and to his disciples.
    2 He said, ` Pharisees have taken Moses' place.
    3 So obey and do everything they tell you to do. But do not do what they do. They say what should be done, but they do it not. 25 `You Pharisees will have trouble. You who are not true to yourselves! You wash the outside of a cup and a dish clean. But inside they are full of greed and wrong ways!
    26 You blind Pharisees! First clean the inside of the cup and the dish so that the outside will be clean too.

    By :
    zura danelishvili Georgia
    - Posted on :
    15/03/2013
  • OOOH! maybe the new Georgian voice, independent of the NATO regime changers, will get a BAD "report card"!!

    By :
    david tarbuck
    - Posted on :
    28/03/2013
Background: 

The opposition coalition Georgian Dream won the parliamentary elections held on 1 October 2012 and its leader Bidzina Ivanishvili, a billionaire who made his fortune in Russia, became prime minister.

Ivanishvili first asked his political foe President Mikheil Saakashvili, whose United National Movement (UNM) took 40% against 55% for Georgian Dream, to resign. Later, under Western pressure, the Ivanishvili’s government and Saakashvili entered a coalition.

Saakashvili’s mandate expires in the autumn of 2013 and according to the constitution, he cannot be elected for a third term. He has been in office since 2004.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Europe's East News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Europe's East Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising