EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Bulgaria News
Turkey News
Germany News
Spain News
France News
United Kingdom News
Poland News
Czech Republic News
Slovakia News
Hungary News
Romania News
Serbia News
Greece News
Italy News
Bulgaria Turkey Germany Spain France United Kingdom Poland Czech Republic Slovakia Hungary Romania Serbia Greece Italy
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Divided EU calls on Palestinians to unite

Published 26 January 2009
Printer-friendly versionSend to friend

EU foreign affairs ministers were yesterday (25 January) divided over whether to condemn Israel for using excessive force during its recent incursion into Gaza and over what policy to adopt vis-à-vis Hamas.

In discussions over dinner ahead of a two-day meeting, foreign ministers from the 27-member bloc called on divided Palestinian factions to unite to make a recently-brokered ceasefire permanent (EurActiv 19/01/09) and to ease the distribution of humanitarian aid to civilian victims in Gaza. 

Czech Foreign Minister Karel Schwarzenberg, whose country holds the rotating EU presidency, stressed the EU view that a united Palestinian government led by President Mahmoud Abbas was fundamental to progress, and called for crossings to Gaza to be kept open "on a regular and predictable basis". 

The ministers invited their counterparts from Egypt, Jordan, Turkey and the Palestinian Authority to attend the meeting. Egypt has a particular role to play, as it has leverage over the Hamas militants who rule the Gaza strip, a diplomat told EurActiv. 

Hamas is on the EU's list of terrorist organisations, but Swedish Foreign Minister Carl Bildt, his Finnish counterpart Alexander Stubb and even their French colleague Bernard Kouchner are of the opinion that if progress is to be achieved, there is a need to "talk to Hamas", a diplomat told EurActiv, adding that his country is more "neutral" in this context. 

"But the more we do, the more we need to work with the [Hamas] authorities of Gaza," the diplomat further said. 

The Union is also divided as to whether to condemn Israel for the Gaza operation, which took the lives of over 1300 people, most of them civilians. Israel used phosphorus bombs, the use of which is prohibited in densely-populated areas, and bombed the UN Relief and Works Agency (Unrwa) compound in Gaza City. 

Ireland, Belgium, Cyprus, Greece, and Sweden are demanding an international inquiry into alleged violations of international law by both Israel and the Hamas terror group. Yet Germany, Italy, the Nethelands and Romania are reluctant to challenge Israel for fear of sabotaging the EU's push for Tel Aviv to open the Gaza crossings, according to diplomatic sources quoted in the Israeli press. 

(With agencies.)
Positions: 

Egyptian Foreign Minister Ahmed Aboul Gheit said after talks in Brussels that he hoped an international donors' conference on Palestinian reconstruction could be staged by 28 February, Reuters reported. He added that the conference would require damage assessments and the support of the European Union, the United Nations and others. 

Aboul Gheit also said he hoped a united Palestinian government could be established to deal with funds raised. 

"We need to force the Israelis to negotiate and also tell them to open crossings and to give Palestinians a chance to live in a normal way," he told reporters. 

Oxfam, a group of non-governmental organizations from three continents working worldwide to fight poverty and injustice, called on European Foreign Ministers to insist that Gaza’s borders are completely opened to allow the required massive levels of humanitarian aid needed by 1.5 million people into the area and end the 19 month-long blockade at their meeting with Israel’s Tzipi Livni today.

“Humanitarian agencies are being obstructed from getting in the quantity and type of aid the people of Gaza desperately need. Aid workers are being stopped at the border and not allowed in,” the statement reads.

“Massive amounts of aid are needed but it is having to be channeled through a tiny opening. Rebuilding what in population size is the equivalent of Barcelona is restricted to 120 truck loads of aid a day. We need an superhighway for aid not a country back road,” Oxfam warns.

The agency added that EU ministers should press all sides to ensure that the ceasefire last and that there is not a return to violence.

Background: 

Last June, Israel and Hamas agreed to a six-month ceasefire. The uneasy calm was periodically violated by armed factions in Gaza, which launched rockets at Israel's border settlements. Israel responded by periodically suspending shipments of supplies into Gaza and by closing all border crossing points. In November and early December, Hamas stepped up its rocket attacks before unilaterally announcing the formal end of the truce. The Israeli public and government subsequently gave Defence Minister Ehud Barak freedom to respond. 

Israel launched a land attack on Gaza on 3 January in the framework of its 'Cast Lead' operation, launched on 27 December 2008, targeting Hamas infrastructure in a bid to put an end to rocket attacks by Palestinian militants on Israeli border towns. 

The military operation left over 1,300 Palestinians dead, the majority of them civilians. Some 300 Hamas fighters are believed to have been killed and the majority of the tunnels along the border with Egypt have been destroyed. Thirteen Israelis, ten of whom were military personnel, lost their lives in the fighting. 

The timing of the operation speaks for itself: Israel launched the attack in the final days of George W. Bush's administration and ended it just before Barack Obama's inauguration as the next US president. 

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising