EurActiv Logo
 
4 décembre 2008
Breaking News:

Sections

Mini Sections

Limits to growth? Hush!

Publié: lundi 16 juin 2008   
André Sautou, France

Sir,

Regarding 'G8 energy chiefs worried by oil prices, eye nuclear': 

You say that the International Energy Agency (IEA) is calling for a major boost in clean technologies to address the world's soaring demand for energy ("'Nuclear, along with carbon capture and storage (CCS), renewable energies and energy efficiency, all must play a much more important role,' the IEA said in a 6 June press statement"). 

But who can believe that such energies will be able, when global annual fossil fuel extraction (oil, gas and coal all together) will have peaked and then begun to decline, to satisfy an ever-increasing energy demand? 

Fast growth feeds itself from energy produced at low cost, so that a substantial part of the energy return (EROEI) can be used to increase the annual energy production feeding economic growth. And most of today's energy is still produced at low cost. But why, then, do we have to pay so much when we buy it? 

Answer: Simply because we have recently passed the threshold beyond which energy production (still growing) can no longer satisfy demand (growing faster). 

In this new conjuncture, a substantial proportion of the profits gathered from high selling prices supports the numerical growth of the populations living in the producing countries and the ones they provide assistance to, allowing those populations to buy consumer goods and in doing so, sustain world economic growth. 

Another proportion allows the wealthy elites ruling those countries – and also many speculators – to acquire profitable capital, part of it concerning the development of alternative energies (nuclear, renewables) needed to sustain economic growth. 

But it is now becoming ever clearer that the average energy production cost will substantially increase in the course of the decades ahead. Therefore, the energy investment returns needed to feed energy-production growth will slow to such an extent that finally global annual energy production will come to a standstill and reverse into decline. 

Improving energy efficiency may provide some delay but its limits will soon be revealed. At some point (within the next decades) the ultimate limits to growth will be reached and expansion will then reverse into contraction. Many of us expect that such an event will bring about economic collapse, as the exchange mechanisms between our world economic system's components rest on the existence of a financial bubble kept under pressure as long as markets in expansion allow investors to make profits re-injected into the bubble. 

But even though they know, most people remain primarily concerned with everyday life and do not want to hear or talk about that. Only crazy people (like me), dubbed 'doommongers', dare…but hush! Let's talk about something else…doommongering is insane.

André Sautou

France 

REMARQUE IMPORTANTE Les ´Lettres à l´éditeur´ sont des points de vue exprimés par des contributeurs extérieurs. Etant une plateforme neutre, EurActiv n'a pas vocation à prendre position sur des sujets politiques. Les documents figurant dans la section ´Lettres à l´éditeur´ n'expriment que l'opinion de leur auteur.
Advertising
Advertising