EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Mandelson calls for EU reform, UK referendum

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 08 May 2012

Former EU trade commissioner Peter Mandelson issued a ‘wake-up call’ to pro-Europeans, demanded a referendum on the future of the UK in Europe, and claimed the EU’s institutions need to be reformed.

In a key speech last Friday (4 May), Mandelson, who quit his Commission portfolio in 2008 to serve the last months of Gordon Brown’s Labour premiership, claimed that Europe was moving inexorably towards a more political union to reflect the fiscal convergence arising from the eurozone crisis.

“The governance of the EU is going to need to change,” Mandelson said in a speech in Oxford, prescribing a series of EU institutional reforms which he claimed had emerged following talks with “a lot of heads of government, ministers, business CEOs and leading academics”.

Smaller Commission, new ‘executive committee of the EU’

These suggestions included shrinking the current Commission, merging its functions with the Council “to form a full governing board, which includes every member state”, and forming a “smaller EU executive committee of the EU, rather on the model of the European Central Bank”.

He claimed he was echoing the sentiments of former UK prime minister – and noted eurosceptic – Margaret Thatcher, in asserting that “for Britain, the facts of globalised life are European”.

Two European strategies were gaining traction in the UK: one fiercely eurosceptic, which wants the country to leave the EU completely; the other aiming to keep Britain within Europe, but at an arm’s length, he said.

He believed the government of David Cameron favours the latter strategy, which Mandelson likened to keeping the UK in Europe as a “Hong Kong to Europe’s China, or a Canada to Europe’s United States”.

Euro likely to emerge stronger from the crisis

Mandelson claimed both these strategies will have the same effect, and see the country frozen from an increasingly united European project caucusing around the single market to the detriment of the UK.

He gave a staunch defence for the single currency – blaming the structure of the currency rather than the idea of it for its current woes – and claimed it is likely to emerge stronger from the crisis.

Mandelson called for a referendum in the future of the UK’s position in Europe, but said this should be conducted in a way that addressed the full implications for the UK’s future, but he acknowledged his views were shared by few of his compatriots.

He described his intervention as a “wake up call” to a generation of business leaders and politicians.

“The British public needs to engage with what is at stake. The European mandate that the [Edward] Heath government secured in the 1970s belongs to another time and another generation,” Mandelson said.

Meanwhile Mandelson's Labour party won victory over its Conservative and Liberal Democrat counterparts in local elections held in the UK last Thursday (3 May). The coalition partners lost control of numerous local councils - including cities such as Birmingham and Southampton - as unpopular austerity policies continue to bite, and a double-dip recession holds sway.

Labour veteran Ken Livingstone failed, however, in his bid to unseat the charismatic Conservative mayor of London, Boris Johnson.

EurActiv.com

COMMENTS

  • My model is the creation of a European Senate in Bratislava, pan-European party candidates to be elected by universal suffrage as representatives. Less than 200 seats. In return the EESC would be abolished. The Senat would get the right to authorise the Commission to present legislative proposals, budget control rights etc. It would also be empowered to elect the Commission President and replace the Commission President by constructive motion of distrust. The European Parliament would stay as it is.

    By :
    Rebentisch
    - Posted on :
    08/05/2012
  • Hurrah for Mandelson. But not for a referendum since the majority of British (and European)voters know little or nothing of what goes on in Brussels or Strasbourg and are ignorant of the issues at stake

    By :
    mamiemoo
    - Posted on :
    08/05/2012
  • Hurrah for Mandelson. But not for a referendum since the majority of British (and European)voters know little or nothing of what goes on in Brussels or Strasbourg and are ignorant of the issues at stake

    By :
    mamiemoo
    - Posted on :
    08/05/2012
  • How is it possible to take Mandelson seriously? This is the man who was forced to resign twice for misleading/lying the British Parliament. This is the man who who said " we are terribly relaxed about people getting filthy rich". This is the man who now runs his own consultancy company and has not disclosed who are his clients. He , in short speaks only for the 1% who seek simply to line their own pockets at the expense of the 99%.

    By :
    mclpl
    - Posted on :
    09/05/2012
  • I don't understand mamiemoo's views about voters not knowing what goes on in Brussels/Strasbourg. If that were to be true, then it is clear that teh current political structure and model is wrong. It should be clear and transparent enough for most voters to know how the system works. I feel I am quite well read about domextic and international current affairs and that I have a reasonable understanding of the EU structure but I still sometimes find puzzling, for example, the workings of the European Parliament( what is the manifesto? what are they going to be dealing with during each parliamentary session?), the realtionship between the roles of President of the European Council (of ministers)and the President of the European Commission. I believe it has been designed opaquely to ensure it is a "tuen-off" for the voters. Mamiemoo - please understand that these people do NOT know better than us what we want!! We, the people are the masters, not the politicians or bureaucrats.

    By :
    Don Latuske
    - Posted on :
    28/05/2012
  • Mandelson is in effect in favour in increasing the powers of the Council, where States carry a heavier weight and more veto possibilities on issues touching their national sovereignty. It is a smart move, because it advances traditional British intergovernmentalism under the guise of institutional reform, and it consolidates British obstructionism under the guise of intergovernmentalism.
    The institution organization he proposes, especially the "executive committee" has at least one historical forerunner: the German Confederation 1815-1866, which was the successor of the Holy Roman Empire, a loose and undemocratic confederation consisting of nearly 40 states and whose organization was defined by the Treaty of Vienna: "Les Etats de l'Allemagne seront indépendants et unis par un lien fédératif" .
    Austria held permanent presidency of Mandelson's equivalent executive committee, there were 17 permanent members, and the lesser principalities were occasionally allowed according to a rotation principle.
    Such an organization would be less federal than the current one, because the Executive Committee would not draw any legitimity at all from the Parliament (at least the Parliament approves the Commission under the current setup), and hence the Parliament would be definitively relegated to a mere chatting room.
    If Mandelson's proposals are really the best thing British "pro-europeans" are willing to offer, then I think it is best for the EU and for Britain to part routes in a dignified, democratic and friendly manner.

    By :
    Charles
    - Posted on :
    01/06/2012
Peter Mandelson
Background: 

Peter Mandelson is a British Labour Party politician , who served in a number of cabinet positions under both Tony Blair – from whose government he twice resigned – and Gordon Brown. After his second resignation, he served as the European Commissioner for Trade from 2004 to 2008. He rejoined the government sitting in the House of Lords  on 13 October 2008, until Labour was replaced by a new coalition government in May, 2010. He is currently president of the left-leaning think-tank, Policy Network.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Video General Promoted 2

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising