EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Merkel mulls 'convention' to draw up new EU treaty

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 27 August 2012

German Chancellor Angela Merkel is considering an EU 'convention' to draw up a new treaty for closer European political unification and help overcome the bloc's sovereign debt crisis, the weekly Der Spiegel reported on Sunday (26 August). Merkel later denied the report.

Germany, the European Union's biggest economy, has long argued for more national competences, including over budgets, to be transferred to European institutions but faces strong resistance from other member states.

Merkel hopes a summit of EU leaders in December can agree a concrete date for the start of the convention on a new treaty, Der Spiegel reported.

The idea, which the magazine said Merkel's European affairs advisor floated at meetings in Brussels, recalls the 100-plus strong convention of EU lawmakers set up in 2001 - inspired by the Philadelphia Convention that led to the adoption of the US federal constitution - charged with the task of preparing a European constitution.

The charter that finally emerged was rejected by French and Dutch voters in 2005 and it became instead the basis of the EU's Lisbon Treaty which is still in force today.

Many member states, recalling the lengthy disputes and setbacks that preceded the Lisbon Treaty's entry into force, are reluctant to embark on another prolonged process of institutional reform.

Some countries such as Ireland would have to hold a referendum on any new treaty and the process would increase pressure in Britain - where opposition to closer EU political union runs high - for a complete withdrawal from the EU.

However, Germany believes a much closer fiscal and political union - with EU oversight of national budgets - is needed to ensure that member states get their public finances fully in order and to restore stability to the euro currency.

'I want Europe campaign'

The report by Der Spiegel comes amid signs that Angela Merkel is preparing German public opinion for a further round of European integration.

On Thursday (23 August), Merkel backed a campaign to persuade Germans of the benefits of European unity. Called "I want Europe" ("Ich will Europa"), the campaign includes a video message describing the virtues of European integration, saying it had brought "peace, prosperity and understanding with our neighbours."

"Amidst all the controversy … we must not forget one thing," Merkel said in a written statement posted on the 'Ich will Europa' website. "Europe is not just a matter of the mind, Europe is and remains primarily a matter of the heart. Europe is our future."

"I want Europe" brings together politicians past and present including the country's President Joachim Gauck, Merkel and former Chancellor Helmut Schmidt, with celebrities including German football captain Philipp Lahm, AFP reported.

It is backed by 11 academic institutes and several media groups.

Positions: 

Angela Merkel later appeared on the ARD summertime interview on Sunday evening where she was asked about the idea of organising a convention on the new EU treaty (read full transcript here).

Merkel denied the report in Der Spiegel, saying: "I am not calling for a convention, but I have been demanding for some time that we do not stand still concerning the steps we have taken. For example the fiscal compact. If we had not made the fiscal compact as a treaty amongst 17 countries, but if the UK would have been willing to agree to a treaty change, then the question would have been how this could be discussed."

"In such cases in Europe a convention is convened under the Lisbon Treaty. But that is not what it is about now. The point is to consider what the next important steps are that we must take."

Next steps: 
  • 18-19 Oct. 2012: interim report on finalising economic and monetary union to be presented at EU summit in Brussels.
  • 13-14 Dec. 2012: final report and roadmap for further economic and monetary union to be adopted by EU leaders at Brussels summit.
EurActiv.com with Reuters

COMMENTS

  • The Annex I to the Lisbon Treaty is based on Brussels nomenclature -- which does not exist any more. It seems, that the staff did not find it necessary to scrutinize the situation and irresponsibly has made the easiest choise -- to copy/paste from the text of previous Treaties. Though the reality is absolutely new... To say -- the new -- conditionally -- since the Regulation replacing Brussels nomenclature with the current "Combined nomenclature" has JUST appeared in ... 1987. So the EU lives with the defective Lisbon Treaty now.

    By :
    Lisbon Treaty must be renewed
    - Posted on :
    27/08/2012
  • Sure, a Constitution that benefits Germany. Why not? Of course that will take years to implement, if at all. But what about moving to help businesses invest in Europe -- Now? No need for a Constitution for that. Where are the entrepreneurs? Or did all the fresh new tax increases chase them away?

    Create an economic framework where Europe is a good place to invest.

    By :
    John
    - Posted on :
    27/08/2012
  • In ALL the countries supposedly clamouring to join the EU it is NOT the citizens of those nations who are campaigning for Mr Fule's idea of endless expansion and enhancement of his bureacracy; rather it is special interest groups who push that idea.

    The original "Treaty of Rome" created a "common market" which has been eminently successful in creating a Franko-Germanic relationship of cooperation rather than what was habitually confrontational. Therefore, for those of us old enough to remember WWII and its immediate aftermath which included Soviet occupation of more than half the Continent of Europe, today's EU is overall a success.

    However the ambitious youthful achievers do not always make the most successful adults. Wiz-kids like anything/anyone else need to mature as well as grow. Otherwise it makes for "too soon old, too late smart"!

    If Europe, like the maturing youth, is to continue its success, it must shed the garments and trappings of childhood and youth and while keeping the vision find the path of the future.

    Sometimes this path will be illuminated by the experiences (successes AND failures) of others) at other times it will be uncharted, but in all cases the pace must be dictated by realistic expectations and pausing while mending MISTAKES that threaten the UNION.

    There are THREE such mistakes that cry out; if they are not successfully attended to, any one of these will derail Europe as it is envisioned to be.

    1) The Euro: The common currency must be maintained; it must be expanded. This is best done by making it MANDATORY for dealings BETWEEN member states; I.e. British-Polish trade needs to be DENOMINATED in Euros and ONLY Euros. They can each be left to their own devices and currencies for INTERNAL matters.

    2) Immigration: The Schengen situation is absurd! Some countries supposedly IN the EU are excluded, while there are others NOT in the Union who are excluded. Movement of people in/out of EU needs to be centrally controlled from Brussels; I.e. a member passport to be an EU passport until such time as the European Central government takes on the task of issuing ALL external travel documents. For the present internal movement between states needs to be regulated but this needs to involve the Central government in policing and repatriating.

    The Veto: At present many matters of substance are subject to blocking by ONLY ONE (of 27) members.
    This needs IMMEDIATE correction. Of course any change of power relationships between the individual states and the Central authority would need more than a simole majority; for this a formula of say 2/3s of states representing 60% of population (recent census)might suffice. In any case a fuuture repetition of a Veto of a financial move by one member not even in the common currency needs to be prevented.

    Until the above are ALL corrected I suggest the idea of "expansion" needs to be on hold!

    By :
    david tarbuck
    - Posted on :
    27/08/2012
  • Very surprising.
    The fiscal pact already includes Commission oversight over national budgets as well as the right for the Commission or another signatory of the pact to bring national budgets before the ECJ.
    Maybe Merkel is just anticipating a negative vote on the fiscal pact and the ESM by the Constitutional Court.

    By :
    Charles
    - Posted on :
    27/08/2012
Background: 

At the last EU summit in June, European leaders were presented with a report and roadmap on the eurozone's longer term future.

The report, Towards a Genuine Economic and Monetary Union, was drafted jointly by European Council President Herman Van Rompuy and European Commission President José Manuel Barroso in collaboration with Eurogroup President Jean-Claude Juncker and European Central Bank (ECB) President Mario Draghi.

The most far-reaching suggestions in the report included:

  • Setting "upper limits" on member states' annual budgets;
  • "Prior approval" for issuing government
  • debt "beyond the level agreed in common";
  • Issuance of "common debt" as a medium term option;
  • Setting up an EU "treasury office";
  • Closer coordination on "labour mobility" and "tax coordination".

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising