EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Schulz: EU collapse is a 'realistic scenario'

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 26 April 2012, updated 02 May 2012

The collapse of the European Union  is a "realistic scenario," as member states are claiming back power, xenophobia  is increasing and so are calls to reintroduce border controls, said the president of the European Parliament, Martin Schulz.

“In the past few months we have witnessed a disturbing trend towards renationalisation and ‘summitisation’: the Heads of State and Government are arrogating more and more decisions to themselves, debating and taking decisions behind closed doors and in disregard of the Community method,” thundered Schulz.

Speaking in front of the College of Commissioners he underscored the need for an even closer cooperation between the Commission and Parliament. That “is an important sign that we are defending the Community method with determination.”

Schulz complained that the latest crisis shows an acceleration in the creation of Parliament-free zones. “By means of the Fiscal Compact, an attempt was made to create a Fiscal Union beyond the control of Parliamentarians, by-passing the Commission,” he said.

“Together we can oppose the trend towards 'summitisation' and 'renationalisation'. This development is extremely dangerous, as we were reminded again only last week by the Franco-German call for the reintroduction of border controls: any assault on freedom of movement is an assault on the foundations of the European Union,” he told the College.

His remarks come as the eurozone is shaken by a severe debt crisis and the 27-country bloc is divided by disputes over the Schengen Area and border control.

European Council President Herman Van Rompuy echoed Schulz concerns as he warned in Romania that the "winds of populism" were affecting the free movement of persons within Schengen, one of the EU's key achievements.

Worries about "populism" at the EU level have increased as National Front leader Marine Le Pen received a record number of votes in the first round of the French presidential elections held on Sunday. 17.9% of French voters cast their ballot for the far-right candidate.

EurActiv.com

COMMENTS

  • EU people need clear message from the "elite". However, the EU bureaucracy,carefree and satiate, became so lazy and arrogant that its brain lost the ability to think. It seems to be the end of the end or "final curtain" without fundamental reforms related with concrete actions and concrete responsibility. Hopfully REFORMS...

    By :
    Fundamental reforms needed
    - Posted on :
    26/04/2012
  • The movement to build a new Europe, a better one, more democratic, more efficient and more powerful to the rest of the world is called federalism and should come from the will of European people to have a common future.

    That is what the European Federalist Party wants to create by having members from all countries in Europe and participating in all the elections all over Europe. If there isn't a will from the people, nothing will be done or it won't be democratic.

    By :
    Luc
    - Posted on :
    26/04/2012
  • Interesting article, let's hope it comes true

    By :
    Charles_M
    - Posted on :
    26/04/2012
  • The sooner the whole thing collapses and we revert to government within individual nations of people, by the people, for the people, the better.

    The EU was always intended to be a near totalitarian system in which the views of ordinary people were to be ignored - witness Heath's statement on television "I have never understood why ordinary people bother their heads about these things - why don't they leave it to the politicians?"

    Unfortunately for the self-selected, self-styled elite, when it comes to le crunch, there are far more "ordinary people" that elite few, and by sheer weight of numbers - in addition of course to being right, ordinary people across Europe are now making their voices heard increasingly loudly. and if they are not listened to, the noise will become louder still and more violent until freedom and independence are recovered.

    By :
    Idris Francis
    - Posted on :
    26/04/2012
  • What arogance . Who the hell does he think he is , the nations of Europe will soon proudly stand side by side bound by friendship and mutually beneficial treaties. Not in the straight jacket of EU red tape and tethered to the rotting corpse of the euro .

    The EU is dead , Long live Europe

    By :
    Kevin
    - Posted on :
    26/04/2012
  • The previous commentators have missed something - this was a directly elected person speaking - i.e. he was elected by his fellow citizens as an MEP - it is called - democracy. It could function better in the EU it does so badly because another bunch of politicians (the member states) are pulling back power for themsleves. I invite the commentators to consider the events of the past century when everybody "did their own thing" e.g. Germany circa 1912 had an ethinic cleansing plan for Eastern Europe (lebensraum) etc etc - I'm not pointing the finger at Germany - I'm giving it as an example of what was happening almost within living memory. The EU ain't perfect but it is much better than what went before.

    I notice a number of cowards posting - why not use your full names - something to hide?

    By :
    Mike Parr
    - Posted on :
    27/04/2012
  • This is mostly not concerned Mr. Schulz, and other EPs, who are directly elected. However, let's remember their trips between Brussels and Strasbourg. These trips are clear evidence of collapse in their minds and atrophied common sense… Moreover, are You satisfied with army of bureaucrats in Brussels? Who elected them? Are they competent? Or at least responsible for something….

    By :
    to Mr. Mike
    - Posted on :
    27/04/2012
  • Mr Schultz has clearly been in Brussels too long. Schengen without FBI-like arrangements is not such a good idea.
    The "Community method" is not as such the only good method. Summitization does not make the EU undemocratic, because national gov't ministers are sent there by their parliaments with mandates.
    And when the European Commission asks for 7% more money at a time like this, they live too far away from eocnomic realities. The European Parliament can prove it really represents European taxpayers by blocking that.

    By :
    Ron Batten
    - Posted on :
    27/04/2012
  • Tired old chesnuts being wheeled out.

    MEPs would prefer not to move between Strabourg, Bx and Luxy - but the French want to keep Strasbourg. Un-elected bureaucrats? - show me one that is (or perhaps the Brits elect theirs?) Armies of bureaucrats - the city of Birmingham has more local government employees than the EC. As I said, tired, unoriginal and frankly stupid comments, from tired unorginal anti-EUites.

    If Schultz has been in Bx too long (maybe he has) I'd suggest it was for his constitutents to decide. Mr Batten since you seem to think he has I encourage you to stand against him at the next Euro elections - doubtless you would have a following (is that the baaing of sheep I hear?).

    With respect to summits - there were plenty before WW1 and WW2 - and look how successful they were.

    By :
    Mike Parr
    - Posted on :
    27/04/2012
  • Well Mike Parr he wasnt elected by me or anyone else in the UK . Who is he ? Some polition from a failed country who couldn't get elected at home so became a second rate MEP and having failed at home wants to tell the rest of Europe what the score is . Get real ,the EU though in its infancy had some good ideas is now just a gravy train for failed freeloaders of the political classes. The sooner it is consigned to history the better for us all

    By :
    Kevin
    - Posted on :
    27/04/2012
  • Hi Kevin, the "failed country" you refer to is err Germany. & no he would not be elected by you QED. (hopefully you have an education that allows you to know what this stands for although judging by the comments - I do wonder). Gravy train - hmm did you vote UKIP I wonder - that would be the same bunch that had to errr pay back money because they "fiddled their expenses" - perhaps they were on your gravy train?

    I have one last "poodle" question - if the EU fails - where does that leave "Rule Britannia" - do UK "subjects" all become better US poodles - do tell.

    By :
    Mike Parr
    - Posted on :
    27/04/2012
  • We salute Mr. Schultz's proposals!

    Also, the best gift to EU that Merkozy along with Schauble can do is to resign for ever, all of the them! They almost destroyed EU. Sarkozy has my wishes to lose the second round of the French Presidential Elections as well as we wsih that Merkel will lose the 2013 elections in Germany!

    Good luck to lose the elections Merkozy Sarkel!

    PS.: Schauble is persona non grata for chairing the Eurogroup. The new chair must come from PIIGS or at least Southeastern Europe.

    By :
    Kate
    - Posted on :
    28/04/2012
  • I hope he's right and that a collapse is imminent. To hell with this Soviet 2.0, we want to be free again!

    By :
    Swede
    - Posted on :
    29/04/2012
  • We call the present news portal to lobby in EU to create jobs in the PIIGS countries, yesterday!

    Thank you very much in advance for your cooperation!!!

    By :
    Kate
    - Posted on :
    29/04/2012
  • Hi Mike , UKIP fiddeling expenses ? Untrue statement.

    What do you mean 'if the eu fails ' it has already ,its just a question of what will be the most painless way to dissband it

    The relationship the Uk has with USA is niether here nor there and certainly no concern of anyone but them

    By :
    Kevin
    - Posted on :
    30/04/2012
  • The only people that like the European Union are the ones that are making money out of it. EU Parliament, EU Commission etc and every Member of national Parliaments that are having their "wages" and vast Expenses, wonderful trips on the best 'planes' with first class service, and all they have to do is obey EU orders like the rest of us MUGS for still paying our taxes that allow all of them to take us for fools.

    National Government have a choice to make, the people cannot afford any more to pay for national politicians as well as contribute to foreigners to do the job THEY have been elected to do. One or the other has to go. Make up your mind which. Time is running out.

    By :
    Anne
    - Posted on :
    01/05/2012
  • The only people that like the European Union are the ones that are making money out of it. EU Parliament, EU Commission etc and every Member of national Parliaments that are having their "wages" and vast Expenses, wonderful trips on the best 'planes' with first class service, and all they have to do is obey EU orders like the rest of us MUGS for still paying our taxes that allow all of them to take us for fools.

    National Government have a choice to make, the people cannot afford any more to pay for national politicians as well as contribute to foreigners to do the job THEY have been elected to do. One or the other has to go. Make up your mind which. Time is running out.

    By :
    Anne
    - Posted on :
    01/05/2012
  • i flagk a commentary by mystake. i as trying to answerSuede when he said ' I hope he's right and that a collapse is imminent. To hell with this Soviet 2.0, we want to be free again!

    ´.....well,if this as soviet unon e wouldn't be laughft at, in the corridors of dipomacy all over the orld..russiams,chinese, gulf arabs,americans..e are euromidgets,a and they have other term for us. also e ould hav a military alliane' but the EU has none of the above, it looks the ussr in 1991 that yes,becaause the neo-liberals we placed in chaarge of our countries are destroying the original EU (that neede to be improved) and replaced it by this neo-liberam dunn...i didn't sign in for this. you have an idea hat is living ith 77 euros a month, being a chronic patient (spine injury)? no fun an all..

    By :
    dinamism
    - Posted on :
    02/05/2012
  • For everyone whining about how much they want to see the EU collapse... the only way European countries are going to retain any power in the future is by banding together. That means more centralisation and more power given to Brussels. Breaking things up and reversing the engine will lead to dead end alleys, moribund economies and marginalisation on the world stage. All the while the rest of the world will move on without you.

    The choice is yours to make.

    By :
    FlorbdeFlorb
    - Posted on :
    04/05/2012
  • FlorbdeFlorb: sadly there are no EU Countries "banding together" as you call it. There is only one Country in that band of brothers that is calling the tune. Here in the UK we have one person that has recently called for Germany to "To forget World War Two and help 'deliver firepower' for Nato and the West, and THAT came from British defence secretary Philip Hammond.

    He perhaps should read some of what happened in World War two and NONE should ever forget it, and remember after the First World war people said THEN there would never be another war and none should ever forget that either-sadly they did. If none learn from History, that History will indeed repeat itself. I doubt there will be a World left after a third World War though.

    Philip Hammond should resign from the post he presently holds. He most certainly should read the REAL History of World War two of listen to those that went through that War from all walks of life-WHILE THEY ARE STILL ALIVE. HISTORY WILL INDEED REPEAT ITSELF IF THEY AND MR hAMMOND IN PARTICULAR, DO NOT LISTEN AND LEARN.

    By :
    Anne
    - Posted on :
    04/05/2012
  • 'The choice is yours to make ' (Florbdeflorb)
    Well the chance would be a fine thing. Though promised by many the choice has yet to be offered.
    Meanwhile you may like to ponder the alternative to the never ending downward spiral that the eu is inflicting on us all .

    http://www.tfa.net/campaigns/better-off-out/

    By :
    Kevin
    - Posted on :
    07/05/2012
  • The people Kevin, cannot continue to pay for their own British Government to govern-which it cannot do as long as we remain in the EU-and also pay the many billions of British Pounds to a foreign organisation also? Those days have gone because we have already ""disappeared"" most of our money on paying the European Union billions of pounds each and every year since 1972 already. No wonder we are nearly 'broke'.

    This Government has already set up EU REGIONS through the EU's Localism Bill, now Act, in England. Scotland is already an EU Region as is Wales, an extra layer of Governance this Country has never had before, nor needed previously and quite simply the people cannot afford it.

    The idea is of course so that the EU's Committee of the Regions will directly govern THEIR EU REGIONS, cutting out our Government-in other words-has our government put itself out of a job?

    It is not xenophobia Martin Schulz President of the EU Parliament, to want to close our borders, we simply cannot afford to pay for those that wish to come here because our borders no longer exist or because the EU wants to become one big STATE, especially when perhaps there isn't enough work to find for them-even if they did want to work which many do not. Perhaps it is time for our elected MP's to decide whether they want to govern our Country or not, because WE, the people can no longer afford to pay for a British Government that cannot Govern AND pay foreigners to govern it as well-which you may not understand is absolutely contrary to the people’s Common law Constitution. One or the other must go-which?

    By :
    Anne
    - Posted on :
    07/05/2012
  • I really do not understand why anybody would think that a United States of Europe government would be any better than their own national government. I am not at all enamoured of my own in the UK (and that is in reference to any of the main political parties)- it is axiomatic that politicians are liars. They are not altruistic in terms of having an ethos of public service for the good of their electorate. The current crop of "elected" EU offials e.g. Schultz, Barroso, van Rompuy etc., are no better. I believe that they think they know best. Yet it seems to me that most sensible-minded people can see that Greece and the other "bailed out" countries are not being best served by their own and other politicians. We do not need to have a centralised european government that regulates our lives to death. We just need a simple relationship with each other that enables us to trade, travel and live. Trade has been going on for centuries in a quite satisfactory manner. Travel is for most people a matter of going on holidays and living in each others' countries also only really affects a minority of people and had been happening long before the creation of the EU, which itself had been built on deception. In any event, I would be pleased to hear any responses that suggest Monnet's original idea of a High Authority governing us (or dictatorship by any other name) would be an improvement on politicians.

    By :
    Don Latuske
    - Posted on :
    28/05/2012
  • The E.U. and the Zone are an artifice. the Zone is constituted of national members,each with its own cultural, linguistic, border and racial and self identifications. It tried to model itself on the United States and it has failed. China's economy is slowing down and emerging markets will grind to a halt. The Second Shoe is about to drop.

    By :
    Marcus
    - Posted on :
    17/06/2012

Advertising

Videos

EU Treaty and Institutions News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

EU Treaty and Institutions Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising