EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Three commissioners to act as Ashton's deputies

Published 15 March 2010 - Updated 17 March 2010
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

Catherine Ashton, the EU's recently-appointed foreign policy chief, will be able to trim her busy work schedule and counter criticism of her lack of visibility thanks to the assistance of three EU commissioners, who will act as her deputies.

Štefan Füle, the Czech commissioner for enlargement, Andris Piebalgs, his Latvian colleague responsible for development, and Kristalina Georgieva, the Bulgarian commissioner for humanitarian aid, will all assist Ashton, a Commission official said.

Catherine Ashton has endured attacks from several quarters, including French ministers, for not flying the EU flag at hotspots such as earthquake-hit Haiti or being unable to attend European gatherings.

But Commission representatives said the situation was going to change, as the EU's first-ever High Representative for Foreign and Security Policy, who is also commissioner for external relations, will now be able to use colleagues as deputies.

"I wish we had dealt with the issue of deputies at the intergovernmental conference [laying the ground for the Lisbon Treaty], but here we are," said one Commission official, who asked not to be named.

"In a European Union of 27 countries, she - or anybody else - will always be attacked for being here and not somewhere else," a diplomat told EurActiv.

Asterisks fill Lisbon Treaty void

The Lisbon Treaty, which entered into force in December last year, does not provide any deputies for the EU's foreign policy chief. However, when European Commission President José Manuel Barroso first disclosed his new team, asterisks were marked against the names of three commissioners to indicate that they would work in "close cooperation" with Ashton.

"There are three commissioners in President Barroso's college of commissioners who work in a cluster with the High Representative, and in certain circumstances they can do certain things when she is not able to do them," the Commission representative said.

The official described Füle, Piebalgs and Georgieva as "cluster commissioners" who would sometimes help Ashton be in "more than three places at a time" and who "can do things on her behalf in certain circumstances".

National ministers also 'useable' for carrying EU message

By the same token, national ministers from the 27-member bloc are equally "useable," on the basis of a pre-agreed mandate, to carry the EU's message, the official continued.

Spanish Foreign Minister Miguel Angel Moratinos, for instance, is widely acknowledged as a Middle East expert, while Sweden's Carl Bildt has extensive expertise in Western Balkan troubleshooting.

However, the official admitted that the procedures for working out such "deputising" were not yet clear. "We will have to see how deputising will go on in practice," he said.

A deputy inside the EU External Action Service?

In addition, Ashton could use a deputy from the ranks of the upcoming European External Action Service (EEAS), the official said. But he suggested that this role would be of lesser political importance.

Large EU countries such as France and Germany are struggling to place their diplomats in key positions in the EEAS, including the open position of secretary-general and the two deputy secretary-general jobs.

But according to sources, what those countries are seeking is influence in the EEAS kitchen rather than political visibility. The Commission official explained that no matter who becomes the most important EEAS official under Ashton, he or she could not "deputise" in a political manner but rather in a functional one.

"So we have three sources for HR deputies, two as alternatives rather than deputies, because this triple-hatted structure is rather a rare commodity," the official said, making it clear that only the three commissioners could act as real deputies.

Positions: 

EU foreign affairs chief Catherine Ashton voiced her dismay on Sunday over the criticism that has been heaped on her performance, but said she was confident she could succeed in the job, Reuters reported.

"It would have been nice to have had something a bit different," Ashton, who is British, told the BBC when asked if she was surprised at the degree of hostility she had faced.

"When you have a new job that's built on three people's jobs [...] it's inevitable that some people will be dissatisfied. I hope though, as they see what I do, that they will become more and more satisfied with what I'm doing," she said.

Ukraine's EU ambassador Andri Veselovski told journalists he was "amazed" that Ashton had been criticised for travelling to Kiev for the inauguration of his new president instead of attending an EU ministerial meeting (see 'Background').

He said he had found the dilemma "strange", as in his words, Ukraine is "a huge country at your door" and was at a crucial point in its development. The new president had made an important political choice by coming to Brussels for his first visit, a trip which materialised largely as a result of Ashton's visit to Kiev.

Had Ashton not gone to Kiev, that would have been "very strange," Veselovski said.

"President [Lech] Kaczyński of Poland comes, and Ashton does not come…come on!" he mused.

If you want to react on this article about Catherine Ashton’s deputies, please click here.

Background: 

Soon after taking office, EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs Catherine Ashton found herself under fire, first for not having travelled to Haiti after an earthquake hit the impoverished country on 12 January (EurActiv 25/01/10)

More recently, France's defence minister criticised Ashton for having preferred to visit Ukraine rather than attend a defence minister's meeting in Palma de Mallorca (EurActiv 26/02/10).

The Lisbon Treaty does not provide deputies for the EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs. However, analysts consider that she has a "near impossible" job desription, as she combines the duties formerly held by the High Representative for Common Foreign and Security Policy Javier Solana, the role of the foreign minister of the country holding the rotating EU presidency, and the post of vice-president of the European Commission (EurActiv 10/12/09 and EurActiv 05/03/10).

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising