EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

EU seasick with African boat people

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 12 April 2011, updated 13 April 2011

Italy quarrelled with other European Union governments yesterday (11 April) over how to handle thousands of migrants fleeing violence in North Africa, while the EU executive urged the bloc to do more for the refugees.

Divisions have deepened among the EU's 27 governments on how to tackle the refugee crisis in the region, with some capitals worried that offering shelter to too many migrants will encourage more to attempt to enter Europe illegally.

But the European Commission has said EU capitals need to overcome differences and prepare to resettle some of the almost half a million people displaced by violence so far.

Italy has borne the brunt of the crisis and wants other EU governments to help it care for some 25,000 people who have arrived on its shores as a result of turmoil in Libya, Tunisia and Egypt.

At a meeting of EU interior ministers in Luxembourg to discuss migration pressures, Italy's Roberto Maroni accused his counterparts of failing to show solidarity with Rome.

"Italy has been left alone," he said. "I wonder whether in this situation it makes sense to remain in the European Union."

Most EU governments say people arriving in Italy are mostly economic migrants seeking jobs in Europe, and not asylum seekers or refugees in need of international protection.

They say Rome should be able to deal with them, and have reacted angrily to Italy's decision to start offering them temporary residence permits that would allow them to travel freely throughout most of the EU.

"I was quite dissatisfied with Italy's surprise decision to pass on its problems to all the others without prior notice," Dutch Minister for Immigration and Asylum Gerd Leers said.

Austria's Interior Minister Maria Fekter said Vienna would investigate how it can stop migrants from crossing its borders.

"We will look into what extent we will recognise visas issued by Italians, especially whether we allow in people who cannot feed themselves," she said. "This would be a feeding ground for crime which I cannot allow."

Rising pressures

However, the EU's home affairs commissioner, Cecilia Malmström, warned EU governments would have to consider taking in more people from North Africa in the future, while stressing the bloc had already assisted Italy with funds and equipment.

She pressed interior ministers to offer shelter to thousands of refugees stranded at Libya's border with Tunisia, mostly poor foreign workers from Asia and other parts of Africa who had worked on Libya's oil fields and construction sites.

Aid agencies have repatriated most of them to their countries of origin but several thousand, such as Somalis and Eritreans, cannot be sent back because of unrest at home.

"There is war in Libya and more people will flee. We need to prepare," she told reporters.

Malmström has failed to secure sufficient offers from EU capitals to resettle 800 people stranded on Malta, a tiny EU member state.

"Resettlement from Tunisia is a no-go area for most EU states. It is politically unrealistic," said an EU diplomat familiar with Monday's discussions.

Ministers agreed on Monday on the need to find more cash for the bloc's border control agency, Frontex, to strengthen its ability to patrol the Mediterranean Sea.

(EurActiv with Reuters.)

Positions: 

Belgium too has threatened to re-establish border controls for travellers from Italy.

"It is becoming necessary to check if people who arrive from other member states do indeed meet the criteria for entry on to our territory," said Melchior Wathelet, Belgium's immigration minister, quoted from Luxembourg by the Financial Times.

According to The Times of Malta, Italian Home Affairs Minister Roberto Maroni avoided Maltese Home Affairs Minister Carm Mifsud Bonnici at the Luxembourg meeting. The daily adds that Maroni had tried to blame Malta for an incident in which some 200 migrants drowned off Lampedusa.

Maroni left the meeting halfway through the proceedings, the Maltese daily furter writes, adding that his early departure was interpreted as a snub by the other ministers.

German Interior Minister Hans-Peter Friedrich sharply criticised the Italian government for planning to issue immigrants with temporary visas that would allow them to travel to other European nations.

"Italy must solve its refugee problem itself," Friedrich, a member of the staunchly conservative Christian Social Union (CSU), the Bavarian sister party to Chancellor Angela Merkel's Christian Democrats, was quoted as saying by Spiegel Online.

Conservative daily Die Welt wrote:

"Italy is resorting to a dirty trick to force Europe to deal with the refugee issue. That is unacceptable blackmail. But Rome is right on one point: the refugees are a matter for the whole of Europe and not just for the Mediterranean countries directly affected."

Background: 

Last February, Italy declared a humanitarian emergency on the Mediterranean island of Lampedusa after 4,000 people arrived there by boat from Tunisia after a popular revolt ousted its president.

Since then, the civil war in Libya has added to the immigration pressure on Lampedusa, where an estimated 20,000 immigrants have arrived since the beginning of the 'jasmine revolutions'. The population of Lampedusa is only 5,000.

Amnesty International and Médecins Sans Frontières have criticised migrant living conditions on Lampedusa. Television footage reveals appalling hygienic conditions on the overcrowded island.

Last week the Italian government gave its green light to a decree allowing economic migrants from Tunisia to move freely throughout the Schengen area for a three-month period. France said it could re-establish border controls.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Videos

Global Europe News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Global Europe Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising