EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

MEPs back EU organ donation action plan

Published 17 March 2010
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

Europeans needing organ transplants should face shorter waiting times after MEPs voted on Tuesday (16 March) for measures to improve the supply and safety of donated organs, while curbing illegal trafficking.

Member states will have to establish a new national authority to supervise organ donation and are expected to appoint "transplant coordinators" in hospitals to discuss donation with families of deceased patients.

The European Parliament's public health committee voted in favour of two reports designed to boost organ transplantation and curb illegal trafficking – a directive on quality and safety of organs and an action plan to improve donation rates. 

MEPs also took a firm line against illegal organ trafficking and emphasised that organ donations must be "altruistic, voluntary and unpaid" and living donations should be seen as complementary to post-mortem donations.

New organ authorities to be established

In his report on the new organs directive, Slovak MEP Miroslav Mikolášik said each EU member state must now set up a national authority responsible for quality and safety standards of organs intended for transplantation.

This idea had been floated in the original proposal put forward by the European Commission, but the Mikolášik report adds that the new body can be either a public or private entity, provided it is not-for-profit.

The authority will have to maintain a national quality programme covering all steps from donation to transplantation or disposal, based on rules laid down in the directive. To facilitate cooperation between member states, the Commission will set up a network of authorities and establish systems to transmit information.

The authorities will approve donor procurement organisations and transplant centres, set up reporting and management systems, collect data on the outcome of transplants and supervise organ swaps with other member states and third countries.

Traceability from donor to patient and vice-versa will be part of the system, along with reporting arrangements for adverse reactions, to protect patients and donors alike. Confidentiality of patient data must be respected in line with national rules, MEPs agreed.

Fighting organ trafficking

MEPs on the Parliament's public health committee said any money paid to donors should be strictly limited to compensation for "expenses and inconveniences related to the donation".

Financial incentives to donate must be avoided, said MEPs, and member states must ban advertising on organ donation for financial gain.

One controversial element of the directive was a clause on living donation. MEPs decided living donation should "predominantly be carried out among family members and close relatives" and "where there is no suitable organ available from a deceased person."

The intention in limiting non-related donation is to clamp down on cases where living donors are paid for donating a kidney.

Action plan focuses on best practice

In a separate own-initiative report by Spanish MEP Andres Perello Rodriguez, the public health committee backed a Commission action plan on organ donation and stressed that swapping information and best practice among member states will help countries with low organ availability to improve their donation rates.

The appointment of transplant donor coordinators is a key step towards improving donor detection and organ donation rates, says the draft report.

MEPs urged national health authorities to consider using schemes whereby citizens are given the option of joining a donor register when applying for a passport or driving licence, and to consider offering online enrolment in national or European donors' registers.

Member states are also asked to include references on national identity cards or driving licences identifying the holder as an organ donor.

The use of transplant coordinators to boost donation rates has been pioneered by Spain, where 35% of people donate their organs – twice as many as the EU average. Spain, which holds the rotating six-month EU presidency, is keen to have a first reading of the new organs directive in May.

Positions: 

German MEP Peter Liese (European People's Party; EPP) backed the use of transplant coordinators and coordination systems. "A lot of people who die are willing to give organs but the hospitals don't have time to manage the whole process of organ transplantation and donation, so there isn't the necessary provision," he said.

He said the EU needs common safety and quality standards but should avoid creating new bureaucracies when implementing the new directive and action plan.

Speaking ahead of the vote, he said fighting organ trafficking is an issue of medical safety and not just about crime prevention.

Liese, himself a medical doctor, said living donation should be an option but that harvesting organs from deceased donors is preferable.

Slovak MEP Miroslav Mikolasik (EPP), rapporteur on the organs directive, said the Parliament's talks with the European Council had been constructive and a first-reading agreement is "still a realistic goal".

He said there will be deep discussions with member states throughout next month in an effort to fine-tune the wording, with a view to a full vote by MEPs in Strasbourg at the end of May.

"One of the leading principles behind the directive is that donation should be voluntary and unpaid. This prevents under-the-table payments to donors," he said.

Background: 

Over the past 50 years organ transplantation has become an established practice worldwide and is often the only treatment available. However, queues are long, with 60,000 patients now on waiting lists in the EU. Every day 12 people die while on a list.

This has sparked an upsurge in illegal organ trafficking, a practice which benefits criminal gangs and can have profoundly negative consequences, particularly for the donor.

Efforts to boost voluntary organ donation through public awareness campaigns have met with limited success. Some countries operate an "opt in" system where citizens are presumed not to be donors unless they actively choose to register. Others have an "opt out" system whereby citizens are automatically registered as donors unless they explicitly choose not to be.

Spain and others have boosted voluntary organ donation rates by establishing a network of transplant coordinators, who liaise with families of deceased people to discuss transplantation options.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Advertising

Advertising