EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

EU youth job strategy under fire

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 16 September 2010, updated 30 January 2012

The European Commission yesterday (15 September) launched its flagship initiative to tackle youth unemployment and promote mobility, but critics have already said that it mainly re-brands existing funding and will largely rely on member states for its implementation.

The Commission's initiative aims to "unleash the potential of young people to achieve smart, sustainable and inclusive growth in the EU" and will deal with the youth aspect of policies for the next ten years as part of the 'Europe 2020' strategy.

The three strands of action set out in the initiative are improving youth education and training, facilitating mobility for study and work, and providing a new framework for youth unemployment, which currently stands at an EU-wide average of 20.9%, up from 14.7% in March 2008.

"Finding a job is what millions of young Europeans are most concerned about. 'Youth on the Move' will create new momentum at EU and national level to improve support for young people so that they can find a job, make a living and pursue their own plans," said László Andor, the EU's commissioner for employment, social affairs and inclusion.

No clear strategy

However, the Party of European Socialists (PES) criticised the proposal and said it failed to present a clear strategy to tackle youth unemployment.

"The crisis affects in a particularly harsh way young people and if the European Commission doesn't present a clear strategy to address this, we risk losing an entire generation to youth unemployment and youth poverty," said PES President Poul Nyrup Rasmussen, who urged the Commission to introduce a youth guarantee offering young people a job, training or further education within four months of leaving school.

"The labour market for young people also needs to be strengthened: more jobs must be created, including tailor-made jobs for young people along with incentives to hire young people. Interns need to be better protected by adopting European minimum standards for internships," Rasmussen added.

Working with member states

The Commission stressed that most of the measures should be achieved by "working with" and "supporting" member states, citing in particular the EU's '2020' targets of increasing the proportion of young people in higher education from 31% in 2008 to 40% by 2020 and decreasing the number of early school leavers from 15 to 10% for the same period.

Ensuring social cohesion across the whole Union is "no easy task," said Androulla Vassiliou, commissioner for education, culture, multilingualism and youth.

Indeed, €1 billion euro is currently earmarked for youth under the EU's lifelong learning scheme in the 2020 strategy, and €6 billion euro will come from the European Social Fund to address these causes.

Critics say that the initiative offers no new funding instruments other than a micro-finance programme whereby 45,000 loans are expected to be issued over the next eight years to the value of €500 million, if backed by European Investment Bank funding.

"We don't need any new agencies, we can use existing instruments for this," Vassiliou said.

According to recent surveys, more than 40% of employers attach great importance to the experience gained from working and studying abroad.

In response to concerns that students in one member state still cannot transfer grant funds to another, Andor said he would be "urging member states to do away" with the problem.

A scoreboard will be set up in order to rate member states' removal of the legal obstacles to learning mobility, one of the basic principles of the EC Treaty.

The Commission also intends to launch a European job vacancy monitor later this year to make it easier for young people to consider working in another member state and fill vacancies that exist under the EURES scheme.

An alternative global university ranking system will be also be launched as an alternative to ones that consistently rank US universities at the top by including 'a more complete and realistic picture of higher education performance'.

With regards to including more private sources of funding for tackling youth issues, Vassiliou cited the Commission's Green Paper on pension reform, where including internships in pension contributions is expected to feature in stakeholder discussions (EurActiv 08/07/10). 

Positions: 

EuroChambres, the European association of chambers of commerce, Secretary-General Arnaldo Abruzzini spoke bluntly with regard to the chances of the initiative making a difference. "Let's be frank," he said, "public employment services have a very mixed track record, yet the Commission places them at the heart of this youth mobility agenda."

"Meanwhile, intermediary bodies such as chambers, which are constantly liaising between the providers of training and employment opportunities and young people, are not even mentioned," Abruzzini said. 

The Young European Socialists (ECOSY) believe that education and young people should be at the centre of the Youth on the Move flagship initiative. "The European Commission reduces students down to future workers, academic enrichment to professional skills and fails to mention the democratization of education," said ECOSY Vice-President and Slovak Socialist MEP Katarina Nevedalova.

Nevedalova added: "Mobility can be a key factor to improve education. Actions that would reinforce mobility and improve education quality, but are missing from the initiative, include the active targeting of those with lower level of education; more effective incorporation of exchanges into the general higher education systems; and specifically allowing the use of structural funds to improve education infrastructure of member states."

"Real investments are needed to reach those goals and, as a young MEP, I will make it my priority to ensure that the budget for YoM is sufficient to achieve that," she said. 

European Youth Forum President Tine Radinja welcomed what he saw as a delayed focus on youth in order to ensure future economic sustainability.

"All over Europe, hundreds of youth organisations are intensively active in working to help towards the social and economic integration of young people, and in some cases, even create jobs for them," Radinja said. "It is time to recognise their prominent role for youth development and promote their work."

Calling on the Commission's Youth in Action Programme to be granted greater funding in the next budget cycle, Radinja stressed the need for greater youth participation and coordination of youth policies.

"We expect a stronger link between the new EU Youth Strategy and its participatory mechanisms in the implementation of Youth on the Move to fully achieve their potential, young people need a more concrete investment that goes beyond their integration to the labour market," he said, proposing that a Green Paper on Youth Participation be put forward.

Background: 

The EU's '2020' strategy replaces the Lisbon Agenda, adopted in 2000, which largely failed to turn the EU into "the world's most dynamic knowledge-based economy by 2010".

Some of the strategy's targets are to boost employment to 75% and reduce the number of people living in poverty and social exclusion by at least 20 million.

One of the strategy's flagship initiatives is called 'Youth on the Move'. Its aim is to enhance the performance and international attractiveness of Europe’s higher education by promoting student and trainee mobility in order to improve the employment of young people.

Last year, a downgraded employment summit in Prague agreed on a 10-point plan which urged the EU 27 to swiftly step up action to increase access to employment, particularly for young people, as well as to upgrade skills, satisfy the needs of the labour market and promote mobility (EurActiv 08/05/09). 

One million more 15-24 year olds are unemployed following the crisis. 40% of under-25s who are employed work on a limited contract.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Innovation & Enterprise Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising