EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Innovation recovery plans in chaos, says report

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 04 June 2009

A report to be published in a month's time lambasts national recovery plans for failing to achieve global coordination of innovation policies to combat the recession. It concludes that a massive global conference on innovation is needed to promote cross-border collaboration.

The 'Stimulating Innovation' report, due to be officially launched in July, argues that while G20 governments have set aside more than $200 billion for new innovation programmes, there has been little coordination between them. 

The UK, for example, is putting $2.1 billion toward loan guarantees for SMEs, while Germany is extending its write-downs, the study notes. 

The report was presented at a high-profile meeting in Brussels this week (2 June), which brought together policymakers, university leaders and innovation experts from both the private and public sectors. 

They argued that innovation ideas must be coordinated between countries in order to maximise the value of the many economic recovery packages currently in force. 

"In 1944, the world's economic leaders met at a resort in New Hampshire called Bretton Woods, and initiated a new economic order. Now, in the age of the knowledge economy, we believe that a new effort at global collaboration is needed," says the declaration, signed by innovation leaders from across the EU. 

Talk first, act later 

Without cross-border cooperation, they concluded, industrialised countries including the EU member states would lose out in the long run. 

Dialogue is the key, they argued. "The declaration suggests, as a first step, international discussion comparing and studying each country's experiences of what actually works and what doesn't when trying to stimulate innovation." Such best-practice comparisons would eliminate unnecessary - and costly - trial and error, cutting down on needless investment in research that has been successfully carried out elsewhere. 

Green tech and ageing 'obvious starting points' 

"A relatively easy area in which to start collaborating," says the report, is in "R&D and innovation-incentives intended to solve the grand challenges of our day – including research on climate change, alternative energy and healthcare for an ageing population". 

It also identifies scientific visas, intellectual property rules and "other legal regimes that limit mobility of researchers and ideas" as areas where heightened international cooperation is not only desirable but imperative. 

However, the speakers were less clear on precisely what measures countries should take, or what new mechanisms they should set up, to achieve these cooperative goals. 

Positions: 

European Movement President Pat Cox, a former president of the European Parliament, chaired the meeting and argued that "if we're going to do things collaboratively, we need to be able to agree on how we measure performance. These steps might sound very basic, but when you don't have them, you have to build them brick-by-brick". 

He specified a number of areas where international cooperation should begin: benchmarking; key performance indicators; how you go about publishing results; milestone publications; the extent of openness and access to research findings, and the rules around that; clearing house rules; and whether or not financial regulations are sufficiently engaged in this.

TVM Capital Managing Partner Helmut M. Schühsler explained that "what we're really trying to do here is raise awareness about a couple of simple truths at a time when trillions of dollars are being pumped into the economy". 

"Will anything materialise out of this? We don't know. Unfortunately, this world is not a playground where everyone cooperates and collaborates and is happy. This world is, as far as commercial enterprise is concerned, about competitive advantage, not just on the corporate level, but on the societal level." 

"The fact is, the kind of innovations we decide to make today, and how we make them happen, will decide - not only for the next 50 years, but forever – how the various groupings in society fare on this uneven playground."

Background: 

Since the global recession deepened in late 2008, almost every industrialised nation has launched a national economic stimulus package. 

Within these economic 'rescue plans', significant funding is often allocated to innovation programmes: R&D (research and development), education and stimulation of the high-tech and science sectors.

The EU's recovery plan amouns to 170 billion euros and represents approximately 3% of EU GDP, after economic stabilisers like unemployment and welfare payments have been taken into account.

More in this section

Advertising

Sponsors

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Innovation & Enterprise Promoted videos

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising