EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Facing Schengen expulsion, Greece locks up immigrants

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 29 March 2012

To avoid being expelled from the EU border-free Schengen area, Greece is accelerating construction of prison-style asylum centres, putting it at odds with court rulings in other countries that asylum seekers shouldn't be treated as prisoners. Greek authorities defend the plans, citing similar facilities in France and Spain.

Michalis Chrisochoidis, minister of Citizen Protection, warned on 26 March that Greece faces expulsion from Schengen if the country fails to manage illegal immigration by June when an EU evaluation team is expected.

Greece has had problems sealing its coasts as well as a 130-km are on the Turkish border, leading to pressure for a clampdown on immigration traffic. Greek authorities have reported that some 90% of illegal immigrants in the EU enter through Greece, many fleeing unrest and poverty in the Middle East and Africa.

Courts in several other EU countries have ruled that Greece is not complying with minimum standards of treatment for asylum seekers. As a result, illegal migrants who reach these countries cannot be returned to Greece – the point of entry - as would normally be the case under EU law.

Schengen countries have the option of imposing temporary border controls under certain conditions, including security threats, as Denmark threatened to do last year claiming threats from illegal immigrants and criminals.

In a reference to the Greek problem, French President Nicolas Sarkozy said in a recent speech that a country having difficulties controlling its borders should be "excluded" from Schengen.

France also insists that the Schengen governance be made at an intergovernmental level, instead of being managed by the EU Commission.

Attica leads the way

Greek authorities announced on 27 March plans to introduce “closed” centres for housing illegal immigrants in 10 mainland regions.

The municipality of Attica, in the peninsula where Athens is located, has already approved three such centres. In the coming months the mayors of Attica municipality will try to determine the exact location of the detention centres, Greek news media reported.

Giannis Sgouros, the Attica governor, said actions were necessary because of the "visible and immediate risk” to the Schengen Treaty, “with disastrous consequences for the country".

Under the government’s plant, the regions have one week to say whether they agree with the creation of detention centres for illegal immigrants, and to propose sites.

In a written statement, Chrisochoidis welcomed the Attica plan and expressed optimism that the example will be followed by the other regions of the mainland.

As the decision for the remaining nine regions is still pending, the Greek police and the Ministry of National Defence are compiling a list of possible areas that can be allocated for this purpose.

Sources close to Chrisochoidis said the list will take its final form no later than Monday. The Defence Ministry already submitted proposals of using some of its facilities.

However, some problems surfaced.

For example, an abandoned military camp in Amfilochia was considered as a possible immigration camp but it later turned out that the property had been granted to the municipality.

The centre-right New Democracy party, which leads in polls ahead of the early elections to take place on 6 May, is supportive of the speedy creation of closed detention centres.

"We are dealing with a national issue", Fotini Pipili, a member of parliament, told SKAI television.

In contrast, the far-right LAOS party insisted that the country should step up efforts for deportation of illegal immigrants, instead of hosting them.

The Greek news media have reported on the experience of building closed asylum centres elsewhere in the EU. A centre in the northwest suburbs of Paris and one near Lille are cited as "typical examples".

Similar centres also operate in Tenerife, the largest island of the Spanish Canary Islands, and Valencia, the third most populous city in mainland Spain.

Next steps: 
  • 6 May: Elections in Greece and second round of the Presidential election in France
  • June: EU teams to make proposals how to deal with illegal immigrants arriving from Greece
EurActiv.com

COMMENTS

  • Greece France and other countries that hold illegal immigrants in prison like conditions should be fined heavily and not just given a warning, what I can not say now. But can say disgraceful undemocratic actions on the part of these EU countries

    By :
    Michael Kadin
    - Posted on :
    29/03/2012
  • Mr Kadin

    Maybe you could take them in instead then. When possibly up to 10% of the population are illegal immigrants, how do you expect us to take them in when we can't even look after our own. They should be sent back to where they came from and money given to that country from the EU to house them there instead!

    By :
    Pan
    - Posted on :
    29/03/2012
  • Din'd Greece build a fance on the Turkish border,and what happened that Greece cannot stop the infiltration of immigrants?Greece claimed,this fance will solve the problem,or was that a protection from a Turkish invasion?.Is Greece afraid of Turkish invasion,and that is why Greece continue to spent eurozone money they don't even have for arming themselves? If and when Greece learnes to live peacefuly with its neighbors,their real problems of immigration can be solved by co-operation,not by agitating its neighbors,like Turkey.Instead of spending money on Armes Deals with France and Germany,spent it on hiring more border patrols to control the inflow of illigal immigrants to the country.

    By :
    Peter
    - Posted on :
    31/03/2012
  • Illegal immigration has got to be stopped , no matter humanitarian grounds . Building prison like compounds to contain them is a huge expense . Illegal immigrants should be put aboard ships or planes and promptly shipped back to where they came from , no questions asked . Europe is already ruined by immigration ; soon it will be time for Ethnic Europeans to immigrate .

    By :
    David Barneby
    - Posted on :
    14/04/2012
Background: 

The Greek-Turkish border that spans 130 kilometres is safe except for an area of around 20 kilometres near Orestiada and the Turkish city of Edirne, at the place where the river Evros (in Greek, Meriç in Turkish, Maritsa in Bulgarian) crosses the border.

Greek authorities recently expressed the wish to build a fence with EU money at this location. However, the EU Commission rejected the idea, considering that walls and fences were "temporary measures" for which the EU taxpayers' money should not be spent.

It remains unclear if cash-strapped Greece has the means to erect such a barrier.

Recently the Commission said that the number of migrants crossing the Greek-Turkish border had decreased from 2,000 to 500 a week.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Videos

Justice & Home Affairs News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Justice & Home Affairs Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising