EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Germany criticises Danish border control plans

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 11 August 2011

Berlin yesterday (10 August) criticised Danish plans to build new installations on its border with Germany, saying its northern neighbour should wait for European Union clearance before starting any construction.

"There is not the slightest reason now to build parts for a new Danish border control system, which raises considerable doubt over compatibility with the Schengen treaty, as well as with the European Commission and the German government," he said.

The European Commission, which sent an inspection team to the site, said Denmark had failed to justify its new border controls and that the tighter security system currently imposed on its frontiers requires strict monitoring.

Danish lawmakers cleared the way for the measures last month. They are the product of an election-year agreement between the ruling coalition and the anti-immigration Danish People's Party that called for protection against "brutal crime", smuggling and human trafficking.

The measures have upset Germany and stirred debate about freedom to travel within Europe's 'open border' Schengen zone. The European Commission is pressing the Danish authorities for more details and says it may need to visit the border again.

In his statement, Hoyer said that until Brussels had come up with a final decision on how to handle the matter, Denmark should keep its construction plans on ice.

"As long as the European Commission has yet to form its opinion, it is incomprehensible to create facts on the ground already," he said.

EurActiv with Reuters

COMMENTS

  • Just a note to the editor - the article starts off with a quote followed by "he said", but it's not clear who is being quoted. Only in the 5th (second last) paragraph does it seem the person being quoted is Hoyer.
    By :
    Anonymous
    - Posted on :
    11/08/2011
  • Germany is right. Denmark has to wait otherwise the role of the Commission as Guardian of the Treaty would be undermined. But even more: the Commission should suspend the Danish project until it makes up its view regarding the compatibility of the national project with Community law. And Germany should be entitled to admissibly challenge the Commission's "inaction" beyond the 3 months deadline (against to the outdated case law of the CJEU).
    By :
    SP
    - Posted on :
    11/08/2011
  • Let us be frank - the EU is failing as I write, the Schengen area is only as good as the virtually unpoliced borders it shows to its non-EU, non-Schengen neighbours. France and Italy were at loggerheads over the flood of migrants from Tunisia and Libya which the Italians could not stop from landing, so they aribitrarily 'shared out' the miscreants by giving them temporary papers. Now the Danes want to stop 'human trafficking' (slavery, by another word) from Germany! And I thought the British Empire got rid of slavery world wide due to the Christian politician William Wilberforce, and a little help from the Royal Navy. Oh dear, looks like we have to do it all over again then.
    By :
    Michael JR Jose
    - Posted on :
    11/08/2011
  • The actions don't make sense. Germany has a long "sea" frontier with Denmark. It is simple to get a small boat and move people or goods from the north German coast to any of the Danish islands. Having sailed in the area (purely for pleasure) I know just how easy it is. I have no doubt that customs agents at the land frontiers could make a difference - but in any case they would be addressing symptoms - not causes. Still, I would expect nothing else from cheap politicians with simplistic ideas. People traffiking and the like need to be stopped at the EUs borders, not internally.
    By :
    Mike Parr
    - Posted on :
    11/08/2011
  • Michael JR Rose, My feeling is unfortunately, that the Danes are just showing their true faces these years.....forgotten all about Wilberforce, US Virgin Islands - whom are still treated as 'lower human beings' by the Danes, who can't even apologize - almost 100 years after they sold the islands including the people living there - is that not what's called human trafficking, - they are now trying to show off - acting as if they don't like this...hm!! What about the danish, european, middle eastern and nordic people and many others, they each year - still - deport?? The closed border...they do not want the borders closed again to make anyone stay out...it's being made in order to be able to control the people living inside their borders...everyone else is just being deported...what the government in the country is doing these years....it's called BRAINWASH and, believe me.....the danes would love if they could go back to slavery and the 18th century...they don't even try to hide this...even in their history books you can read about the ONLY reason they stopped trading slaves...- because people like Wilberforce stopped them ....
    By :
    Anonymous
    - Posted on :
    19/08/2011
Background: 

Denmark's centre-right government on 11 May decided to introduce border controls at its ports and airports, as well as along its only land border with Germany and its bridge to Sweden.

The European Commission asked for additional information and said it would not accept any roll-back of the Schengen Treaty.

On 12 May, a meeting of EU interior ministers was held, at which Denmark explained that the measures being proposed concerned the strengthening of customs controls in order to counter criminal activity by organised gangs, and promised that Denmark would continue to respect the rules of the Schengen agreement.

On 19 July the European Commission issued a critical preliminary statement just after its experts visited Denmark to assess the situation.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Videos

Justice & Home Affairs News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Justice & Home Affairs Promoted

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising