EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

EU experts assess policy impact of Lisbon Treaty

Published 04 December 2009
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

The entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty this week (1 December) will see the European Union assume a greater role in protecting the climate and the environment as well as on justice and immigration issues, agreed Brussels commentators in a series of interviews with EurActiv.

"With the Treaty of Lisbon, combating climate change on an international level becomes a specific objective of EU environmental policy," Elaine Cruikshanks, CEO of the Brussels arm of public affairs firm Hill & Knowlton, told EurActiv

The PA boss expects the EU "to act in a more coherent and proactive way to achieve binding environmental targets on the international scene". 

'Greater emphasis' on climate change foreseen 

Georg Danell, managing partner at Kreab Gavin Anderson's Brussels office, agrees. The European Parliament gains greater control over EU decision-making under Lisbon, which Danell believes "will lead to greater emphasis on addressing climate change". 

Indeed, European Commission President José Manuel Barroso "has already indicated that he thinks so" by creating the post of commissioner for climate action, to be occupied by Denmark's Connie Hedegaard. 

The Lisbon Treaty extends qualified majority voting to 40 policy areas, notably those relating to asylum, immigration, police co-operation and judicial co-operation in criminal matters, and the European Parliament gains new powers under the 'co-decision' procedure. 

George Ellis Ruano, founder and director of Brussels-based PR firm Gellis Communications, told EurActiv that "we can expect [the EU assembly] to be significantly more vocal in expressing policy positions with the new rules, and the Parliament will certainly cite its 'democratic legitimacy' as a directly-elected body". 

This view was echoed by Fleishman-Hillard Europe Managing Director Caroline Wunnerlich, who said that the treaty "brings the European Parliament much more into play as the 'co-decider' with the Council of Ministers on a whole range of issues". 

"Greater parliamentary control over agricultural expenditure may have major longer-term implications for farm policy, while fisheries, transport and regional policy will all be subject to a bigger parliamentary say," said Wunnerlich. 

Julia Harrison, managing partner at Blueprint Partners, also expects the "greatest changes" to occur in new co-decision areas like "trade, budget, agriculture, transport, regional aid and justice and home affairs (JHA)". 

The extension of qualified majority voting to areas previously requiring unanimity in the Council, like social policy and JHA, will mean "more movement, more horse-trading and ultimately a more dynamic policy environment," Harrison said. 

The treaty also introduces references to new challenges, such as climate change and energy solidarity, particularly to address concerns expressed by countries like Lithuania and Poland over heavy energy dependence on Russia. 

'More coherent' external voice 

Ellis said "we will likely see greater convergence of foreign policies, especially in relation to climate change and energy," leading in the long term to "a stronger and more coherent external voice for the EU". 

New provisions on civil protection, humanitarian aid and public health aim to boost the EU's ability to respond to threats to the security of European citizens (see EurActiv LinksDossier on 'The Treaty of Lisbon' for more detail). 

Gellis chief Ellis recalls that citizens themselves will now be able to petition the Commission to bring forward new policy proposals under Lisbon. "These 'Citizens' Initiatives' require one million signatures, so expect to see a number of these in the future," he says. 

The public affairs bosses were unanimous in identifying financial services as the policy area where the Lisbon Treaty was least likely to have an impact. 

"I don't think the treaty will bring fundamental changes to […] financial services," said Hill & Knowlton's Cruikshanks. "The EU’s competences in this field are well-established, and it is making good use of these. Changes to the regulatory landscape […] are happening, but not as a result of the Lisbon Treaty," she said. 

Blueprint's Harrison predicts policy areas which were already dealt with under co-decision before the Lisbon Treaty's entry into force – like internal market measures and health and safety laws – will remain as they were. 

Indeed, the only "unknown factor" is whether they will be affected by the Charter on Fundamental Rights becoming legally binding, she said. 

For his part, Gellis founder Ellis does not expect changes to taxation or defence policy. "There was never any intention to alter the decision-making procedure for these policy areas," he said. 

Positions: 

"Foreign and security policy is obviously an area where some of the biggest changes will occur" under the Lisbon Treaty, Georg Danell, managing partner at the Brussels office of Kreab Gavin Andersontold EurActiv

"The new EU competences on energy, justice and immigration, as well as the stronger role for the [European] Commission on trade policy, will likely over time see increased ambition in the EU institutions, but in the immediate future I wouldn't expect things to be very different," Danell said. 

"Energy is a very active policy area right now, but I don’t expect much policy change as a direct consequence of the new energy chapter in the Lisbon Treaty," he added. 

George Ellis Ruano, founder and director of Brussels-based PR firm Gellis Communications, expects the Lisbon Treaty to "impact upon those policy areas already under the remit of the EU institutions, particularly in terms of economic policy, as [it] formalises the position of the European Central Bank by making it an institution of the European Union". 

"Other areas where change can be expected are climate and energy policy and the Union's policies on freedom, security and justice," Ellis said

Elaine Cruikshanks, CEO of Hill & Knowlton's Brussels arm, expects the EU to become "more vocal" on the issue of fundamental rights under Lisbon. 

If you want to react to this article, please click here.

Next steps: 
  • 11-19 Jan. 2010: European Parliament to grill commissioners-designate. 
  • 26 Jan. 2010: Plenary vote on the Barroso II team. 
Background: 

The European Union's Lisbon Treaty, eight years in the making, came into force across the bloc's 27 member states on 1 December. 

EU leaders believe the Lisbon Treaty will rejuvenate the decision-making apparatus of the EU institutions, making the functioning of the 27-member Union more efficient and democratic. 

The treaty re-writes the EU's basic rules, first enshrined in the 1957 Treaty of Rome, in response to some of the criticisms of its member states and their citizens. 

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising