EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

EU foreign policy 'undermined' by flurry of national initiatives

Printer-friendly version
Send by email
Published 23 May 2008, updated 14 December 2012

Following France's example with the EuroMed proposal, Poland and Sweden are due to present an 'Eastern Initiative' at a meeting next week, in a move which diplomats warned could ruin the EU's patient efforts to craft a common external policy.

The Commission's attempt to forge a European Neighbourhood Policy with countries on its southern and eastern borders will be dealt another blow when Poland and Sweden present their joint proposal for an 'Eastern Initiative' at a meeting of foreign ministers on Monday (26 May). 

Poland and Sweden plan to upgrade their relations with Ukraine, Moldova, Armenia, Georgia, Azerbaijan and possibly Belarus. 

Earlier this week, Benita Ferrero-Waldner, the commissioner in charge of the EU's Neighbourhood Policy, struggled hard to bring France's EuroMed proposals back into an existing EU framework known as the Barcelona Process. 

In a carefully-worded statement, she admitted that the Barcelona Process had its shortcomings and recognised the need to upgrade it with a "more coherent partnership based on co-ownership of the process". 

But before this crisis was settled, Poland and Sweden had come up with their own 'Eastern Initiative'. 

"Bad examples are always contagious," said a diplomatic source, who added that Ferrero-Waldner was now starting to take it personally. A spokesperson told EurActiv that the commissioner was preparing to give a reaction after Poland presents the initiative at the foreign ministers' meeting on Monday. 

Central to the ENP are bilateral action plans agreed between the European Commission and the partner countries. But unlike those bilateral deals, the new regional initiatives, although quite different from one other, tend to focus more on a multilateral framework. 

Moldova for instance has already embarked on a regional initiative known as the South East European Co-operation Process and it is an active member of the Stability Pact for South Eastern Europe - an initiative focusing mostly on the Western Balkans and which is due to be replaced soon by a Regional Cooperation Council. 

In the long term, however, the country wishes its ENP status to be substituted by the more formal EU candidate country status. "ENP is obviously not an appealing option," a source commented. 

Positions: 

Université Libre de Bruxelles Professor Jean-Michel de Waele, responsible for the 'Centre d’études de la vie politique' (CEVIPOL) told EurActiv that "the ENP has always been an empty shell anyway," because the EU cannot develop a proper policy with its neighbours before answering basic questions about its own future, its institutions and its geographical limits. 

He described the Polish initiative as "interesting", but added that like the Sarkozy Mediterranean initiative, it is "empty, without the necessary means, without content, and cannot satisfy countries aiming for EU membership rather than other partnerships". De Waele said that such initiatives "weaken the EU, because they are introduced by certain countries in a very egotistical manner". 

Amanda Akcakoca,  a policy analyst at the European Policy Centre, told EurActiv that although the details of the Polish-Swedish initiative are not yet known, it is not a surprise that Poland is trying to put more emphasis on the Eastern dimension. There have been previous Polish initiatives, not least when Jacek Sariusz-Wolski (now an MEP) was minister of European affairs. 

Akcakoca said the new Polish initiative appears to be quite similar to Sarkozy's initial Mediterranean proposal, although the latter has now been watered down. She said that the developments are "bad news for the ENP", although the prospects for the new initiatives remain unclear. Ukraine for example was not in favour of the initiative, because the country does not want its EU perspective to be "substituted by something else". 

Next steps: 
  • 26 May: Meeting of the General Affairs and External Relations (GAERC) Council. 
  • 19-20 June: EU summit in Brussels to agree on EuroMed's final version. 
  • 13 July: EU-Mediterranean summit in Paris, under French Presidency. 
Background: 

The European Neighbourhood Policy (ENP) was launched in 2004 with the objective of preventing the emergence of divisions with the EU's new neighbours after the enlargement to ten new countries, mainly located in Central and Eastern Europe. 

The policy applies to Moldova, Ukraine, Belarus, Armenia, Azerbaijan and Georgia to the east, and Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya, Jordan, Israel, the occupied Palestinian territories and Lebanon to the South. 

The Barcelona Process, launched in 1995, applies to Algeria, Egypt, Israel, Jordan, Lebanon, Morocco, the Palestinian Authority, Syria, Tunisia and Turkey. 

The European Commission recently presented its own proposals in advance of an EU-Mediterranean summit to be held in Paris on July 13 under the French EU Presidency (EurActiv 21/05/08).

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Videos

Video General News

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Video General Promoted 3

Euractiv Sidebar Video Player for use in section aware blocks.

Advertising

Advertising