EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Bulgaria News
Turkey News
Germany News
Spain News
France News
United Kingdom News
Poland News
Czech Republic News
Slovakia News
Hungary News
Romania News
Serbia News
Greece News
Italy News
Bulgaria Turkey Germany Spain France United Kingdom Poland Czech Republic Slovakia Hungary Romania Serbia Greece Italy
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Merkel says EU could back Greece as 'last resort'

Published 25 March 2010
Printer-friendly versionSend to friend

Germany will urge European Union leaders to agree that International Monetary Fund (IMF) and bilateral European aid could be used as a "last resort" for Greece if it reached the brink of insolvency, Chancellor Angela Merkel said on 25 March.

Speaking ahead of a summit n Brussels later today of EU leaders, who have been split over what help to give Greece to resolve its debt crisis, Merkel said Germany was prepared to sanction a mix of the two measures to bail out a country if it could no longer fund itself on capital markets.

"At the summit today and tomorrow, the German government will push its view that any emergency support should come from a combination of the IMF and joint bilateral help from the euro zone. But again I say, this can only be a last resort," Merkel said.

"I will argue strongly that this decision - that of IMF plus bilateral aid - must be made. And we will again work very closely with France on this," she said in a government declaration to the lower house of parliament.

Germany had staunchly resisted calls from other states to promise help for heavily-indebted Greece, and Merkel said she was not doing so now.

"I repeat again, this is not about concrete aid, it's about specifying and carrying over the decision made on 11 February," she said, referring to a pledge made last month by EU leaders to take coordinated action to uphold stability if necessary.

Greece was not insolvent and had pledged to carry out an "ambitious programme" of spending cuts, Merkel said.

"A good European is not necessarily one who offers help quickly. A good European is one that respects the European treaties and national rights so that the stability of the euro zone is not damaged," Merkel said.

Merkel added that the instruments available to safeguard monetary union were not sufficient at present, and that steps would have to be taken to correct this.

"We must put an end to using tricks," she said.

If countries did not play by the rules, a mechanism needed to be put in place to restore order without destabilising the currency bloc, Merkel said.

"That is why I will also urge that the necessary changes to the [EU] treaty are made so that unwanted developments can be tackled with suitable sanctions, quicker and earlier."

Merkel said EU budgetary rules were not cut out for "a deliberate undermining of [their] criteria, as we were forced to undergo with Greece".

"If a member of the currency union were to become insolvent in the current situation, it would mean grave risks for all in Europe," Merkel said.

(EurActiv with Reuters.)

Positions: 

Speaking in Parliament on 24 March, European Commission President José Manuel Barroso said the Commission believes that it is now appropriate to create, within the euro area, an instrument for coordinated action which could be used to provide assistance for Greece if necessary.

"It should be clear that the creation of such a mechanism would not imply its automatic activation. Creating such a mechanism is also a question of responsibility and solidarity. Solidarity is a two-way street. Greece is making an economic effort at this point and by supporting these efforts we do not only help Greece but the stability of the euro zone as a whole.”

"The framework for coordinated action should be understood as a safety net to be used only in case that all other means to avoid a crisis have been exhausted, including first and foremost exhausting the scope for policy action at the domestic level."

"Beyond technical aspects, any possible solution must reinforce and strengthen the unity and the coherence of the euro zone and its governance. The world economy needs stability. The euro zone is a pole of stability, and it is important that its capacity to provide stability is further enhanced. We may need to resort to inter-governmental instruments for some issues, but they need to be embedded into a joint European framework," Barroso stated.

The European Central Bank will extend its easier rules on accepting assets as security in liquidity operations into 2011 as well as introduce a new sliding scale of risk margins, ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet said on 25 March, Reuters reported.

Trichet said the extension would be coupled with new risk margins, or haircuts, on assets.

"It is the intention of the ECB Governing Council to keep the minimum threshold in the collateral framework at investment grade level, BBB- , beyond the end of 2010," Trichet told the European Parliament.

"In parallel we will introduce, as of January 2011, a graded haircut schedule, which will continue to adequately protect the Eurosystem," he said.

Guy Verhofstadt, leader of the Alliance of Liberals and Democrats in Europe, told journalists on 24 March that at their summit, EU leaders should "put an end to this discussion" on how to address the Greek economic crisis, a discussion which he said was "destroying everything".

"It has been months since we had discussions and different solutions have been put forward," he said, speaking in French, adding that "their result has been bad for Europe, bad for the euro".

"I think some people should stop saying that sentence, which has been spreading through Europe, that 'No aid for Greece'. This is indeed a huge threat, because it created an anti-European state of mind amid many Europeans, in several member states, within a just a few days. We never had such a devastating effect on feelings of people toward Europe than we have now".

"Moreover, it's not about money, because Greece needs no money," he continued. "Greece needs an instrument, which would allow it, in parallel with the austerity measures they are putting in place, to pay less interest rates on state liabilities. It's not about us giving money, nobody will open their coffers, take euros from there and give them to Greece. It's not about that."

"We are witnessing a pollution of the climate that prevailed in Europe since the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty, by making people believe that Greece is asking for money […] A European solution for Greece costs no money. If the Commission, the ECB or the EIB [European Investment Bank] issues a loan to Greece, Greece will pay the interest rates, therefore this will cost the European citizen not a cent. But the interest rate - if the loan is granted by a European institution - will be lower, for the simple reason that European institutions have more credibility and that they have more liquidity," Verhofstadt argued.

Asked by EurActiv why he was stopping short of naming German Chancellor Merkel and of spelling out the word 'populism' as Germany is faced with public opposition to a bailout and regional elections due shortly, Verhofstadt said:

"Would it help if I give a definition? This is of interest for commentators, for sociologists and for political scientists. I'm trying to make things change, together with the [European] Parliament […] We have to decide. Even the worst system we would be able to put in place is better than to continue in the incapacity to decide."

Socialists & Democrats group leader Martin Schulz said in Parliament on 24 March that EU leaders, and especially German Chancellor Angela Merkel, should show solidarity with Greece.

By presenting its austerity plan, Greece has done its part of the work, said Schulz, speaking in French.

"Those who didn't do their job are the members of the euro zone and in the first place the German Chancellor, who doesn't keep her promises," he declared.

"It is not about taking the money of French, Italian or German taxpayers for refilling Greece's coffers, but to help the country borrow on the international markets at interest rates similar to those for the other countries," he continued.

"In the absence of European solidarity, the money goes into the pockets of speculators," he added.

"If we don't want the fire to be extended to other countries as well, we need to show solidarity with Greece," Schulz said.

Lena Ek (Centre Party, Sweden), ALDE spokesperson on the 2020 economic recovery strategy, expressed her disappointment with the draft Council conclusions, which she said appear to repeat the mistakes of the past.

"Europe is afflicted by a perfect storm of financial, economic and environmental crises which call for strong and united leadership this week," she stated.

German MEP from the Confederal Group of the European United Left - Nordic Green Left GUE?NGL Jürgen Klute said the current problems were a function of EU finance and competition policy and a failed Stability and Growth Pact.

"Chancellor Merkel is poised to make Germany the European champion at selfish idiocy. Why is Greece not entitled to the same assistance received by reckless bankers?" he said, reiterating a call for a ban on credit default swaps.

Greek GUE/NGL MEP Charalampos Angourakis spoke of the decline in Greek living and working conditions saying that "people are suffering as belt-tightening policies drive wages down. Capitalists are profiting from this squeeze on labour and workers are being forced to pay for their crisis."

"Mr Trichet, you seem to think the crisis is not yet over" said MEP Nikolaos Chountis (GUE/NGL), also from Greece "but there are varying shades of Greece within the EU with many countries facing similar problems" he said, criticising the implementation of the stability and growth pact in times of recession as a "disastrous policy".

French MEP (GUE/NGL) Marie-Christine Vergiat called for action to be taken against speculators and attacked the notion that "it should always be the same people who have to pay up when their country is a victim of such financial speculation".

Next steps: 
  • EU summit to decide by noon on 26 March on how to help Greece.
Background: 

Greece is sitting on debts that are expected to hit 290 billion euro this year and has a budget deficit of 12.7% of gross domestic product, more than four times the EU limit. 

The cost of servicing that debt has risen, hitting the euro currency and prompting speculation over a bailout plan (EurActiv 04/02/10).

European leaders sought to prop up Greece with words of support at a summit on 11 February but failed to offer concrete proposals to help the country, citing "strategic" reasons (EurActiv 11/02/10).

On 3 March, Greece unveiled a draconian 4.8 billion euro austerity programme targeted at civil servants, the rich and the church in a move designed to secure European help in tackling its crippling debt burden (EurActiv 04/03/10).

Finance ministers from the 16-country euro zone agreed on 15 March to mobilise financial aid for Greece rapidly if needed, but revealed little of how their standby plan for the debt-stricken nation would work (EurActiv 16/03/10).

German Chancellor Angela Merkel, who faces a key state election in May, is keenly aware that the German electorate overwhelmingly opposes a bailout for Greece and had hardened her line against the EU making a concrete pledge of financial support (EurActiv 22/03/10).

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising