EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

Tories rebuke Cameron on EU power 'repatriation'

Published 02 November 2010 - Updated 08 November 2010
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

Three quarters (74%) of Conservative Party members think UK Prime Minister David Cameron missed an opportunity last week to repatriate powers from Brussels to London and slash the EU budget, a poll reveals.  

The results of the poll – carried out by leading Tory blog ConservativeHome – suggest that most Tories do not agree with leader Cameron’s claim to have secured a good deal for Britain at a summit of EU heads of state and government in Brussels last week (28-29 October).

The summit saw wrangling over the European Union's long-term spending plan for 2014-2020 kick off months earlier than anticipated, with the UK securing considerable support for a lean budget (EurActiv 29/10/10).

Fighting among the EU's 27 governments over the next long-term budget, which could be worth nearly one trillion euros, had been expected to start next June after the publication of proposals by the executive European Commission.

But Cameron insisted on discussing the issue at last week’s meeting of national leaders and managed to secure a declaration that the budget will be moderate.

"Heads of state or government stressed that, at the same time as fiscal discipline is reinforced in the European Union, it is essential that the EU budget and the forthcoming [long-term budget] reflect the consolidation efforts being made by member states," the summit's conclusions state.

After the meeting, Cameron told the press he had "succeeded spectacularly" by making sure that the EU budget would only increase by 2.9% next year instead of a 5.9% hike demanded by the Commission and the European Parliament.

But 62% of party members disagree with his assessment and 85% think the EU budget should have been cut.

Meanwhile, the summit saw Britain and other countries back Franco-German calls for tougher eurozone rules by agreeing to accept "limited" changes to the EU's main treaty in return for a cap on the EU budget (EurActiv 29/10/10).

Call for repatriation of powers

74% of Tory Party members think Cameron should have used German Chancellor Angela Merkel's request for a treaty amendment as an opportunity to get some powers repatriated to Britain. 26% agreed that accepting the treaty amendment was in the UK's interest.

The party was split on the issue of whether the UK should remain a member of the European Union. 49% would like to see Britain leave the bloc but a slender majority (51%) supports its continued membership.

Of those who want the UK to remain a member, a massive 42% said it "should stay in the EU but aim to get powers back," while just 5% said it "should stay in the EU but leave the relationship as it is".

Only 4% of Tory members believe Britain "should be more enthusiastic EU members".

Despite their disappointment with his performance at last week’s EU summit, a majority (89%) of party members declared themselves "satisfied or very satisfied" with Cameron’s overall performance as prime minister.

Just 3% were "dissatisfied" and 8% were "very dissatisfied".

Meanwhile, a massive 75% believe the coalition between their party and the Liberal Democrats is good for Britain.  

Positions: 

"As a result of Britain's intervention, the spotlight has now shifted to reining in the excesses of the EU budget," UK Prime Minister David Cameron claimed after last week’s summit.

"Am I sceptical about granting more powers to the EU? Yes. Do I think that Europe should be member states working together - and they can work together very effectively as I have seen at this European Council - rather than a superstate? Yes," Cameron added.

Conservative MP Bill Cash, who chairs the House of Commons’ European Scrutiny Committee, said prime ministers always claimed success when they returned from EU summits but the 2.9% increase was what the Council of Ministers had originally agreed - and British MPs had already voted to reject a higher increase.

"It has to be said that that, therefore, cannot be seen as a success at all," he told BBC News.

Conservative MEP Roger Helmer told BBC Radio 4's Today programme: "I think we could have done better, I think we should have done better. Only two days ago we were talking about a freeze or even a cut and yet here we are rolling over - 2.9% is no great achievement, it's the position that the council held beforehand."

"Cameron must not wobble on the EU treaty or budget. A new treaty is our chance to repatriate powers and to start reforming the EU," Helmer tweeted.

UKIP MEP Paul Nuttall said: "David Cameron has spun himself into a corner. He said that he would cut the budget, or at least freeze the budget. Now he's talking about a 2.9% increase at best. It's crazy."

Conservative peer Lord Tebbit attacked Cameron by telling the BBC: "He would do better to go down fighting than to surrender in some Vichy-style arrangement, pretending to hold on to sovereignty by agreeing to what Europe demands."

Labour politicians have also questioned Cameron’s performance at last week’s summit.

Shadow Foreign Secretary Yvette Cooper said: "David Cameron's grandstanding has been a complete failure. European governments decided on 2.9% in August so he has achieved absolutely nothing."

"He's tried to swing his handbag but simply ended up clobbering himself in the face," Cooper added.

Glenis Willmott, the Labour leader in the European Parliament, told the Guardian newspaper: "Cameron is trying his hardest to appear Thatcheresque. While I don't have much positive to say about Britain's first female prime minister, I doubt she'd have allowed herself to be caught out in the way Cameron has been this week."

Labour MP Austin Mitchell accused Cameron of "coming out with his tail between his legs" after making "big boasts".

"This is a very bad beginning for someone who was going to take on Europe and win," said Mitchell.  "The fact is, he lost."

"David Cameron campaigned in the general election as a Eurosceptic who would repatriate powers from Brussels at the first available opportunity. But the prime minister, following a well-trodden route, has gone into his first European Union summit this week as a classic Europragmatist," concluded an editorial published in The Independent newspaper.

Background: 

The size, structure and priorities of the EU's annual spending, which amounted to roughly €130 billion in 2010, is governed by the 'Financial Perspectives', which cover the period 2007-2013 (see EurActiv LinksDossier).

Negotiations on the next multi-annual budget planning are due to start in earnest in 2011, and will cover the period 2014-2020.

The most controversial issue of the review is the current 44% (€55 billion) share of the budget that is set aside for agricultural subsidies.

On 19 October, the European Commission listed a number of options to fuel the EU's future budget, proposing that Europe decreases the share of spending coming directly from the member states.

To compensate for the shortfall, it proposed introducing an EU tax which could take several forms: a tax on air transport or a share of new financial, corporate or energy taxes, as well as an EU VAT.

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising