EurActiv Logo
EU news & policy debates
- across languages -
Click here for EU news »
EurActiv.com Network

BROWSE ALL SECTIONS

UK coalition govt tones down Eurosceptic rhetoric

Published 14 May 2010 - Updated 25 May 2010
Printer-friendly versionSend by email

The new UK government will be "a positive participant in the European Union, playing a strong and positive role with our partners," reads the text of a coalition agreement struck between the Conservatives and their Liberal Democrat partners, indicating that the coalition may pursue a more conciliatory approach to its relations with the bloc than the Tories had suggested in their campaign.

The new government, which is today enjoying its third full day in power, looks set to engage more constructively with its EU partners on issues like climate change, poverty reduction and tackling the economic and financial crises than many had predicted before this month's election.

Pre-vote poll leaders the Conservatives had pledged in their manifesto to secure a "full opt-out" from key areas of EU legislation like the Charter of Fundamental Rights, but the coalition agreement, published on Wednesday (12 May), makes no reference to the charter at all.  

Similarly, the Tories promised to return key powers over legal rights, criminal justice and employment legislation from Brussels to London and vowed never to allow a future EU public prosecutor any jurisdiction over the UK.

Their manifesto pledged to "restore national control over those parts of social and employment legislation which have proved most damaging to our businesses and public services," citing as an example the application of the EU's Working Time Directive to employees of the National Health Service (NHS).

The coalition government, however, will pursue a more nuanced path by approaching forthcoming legislation in the area of criminal justice "on a case-by-case basis, with a view to maximising our country’s security, protecting Britain’s civil liberties and preserving the integrity of our criminal justice system".

Both parties agreed that Britain will not participate in the establishment of any European Public Prosecutor, but the coalition deal makes no reference to exempting NHS employees from Working Time.  

Instead, the new government "will work to limit the application of the Working Time Directive in the United Kingdom".

It will also campaign for Brussels to become the sole home of the European Parliament.

The breadth of the coalition agreement – which both Prime Minister David Cameron and his deputy Nick Clegg insist will allow their government to endure for a full five-year term – comes as a surprise after their parties' manifestos offered starkly different visions of the UK's future relationship with the EU (EurActiv 14/04/10).

The Conservatives promised to "constructively engage" with the EU but introduce a 'referendum lock' on all future transfers of power from London to Brussels, while the Liberal Democrats pledged to put Britain "at the heart of Europe" to ensure that the country uses its influence to achieve prosperity, security and opportunity for its people.

'Referendum lock' retained

The coalition government retained the Tories' manifesto pledge to "amend the 1972 European Communities Act" so that any future treaties that transfer powers to Brussels "would be subject to a referendum – a 'referendum lock'".

The two parties have agreed that the UK will not adopt the EU's single currency for at least five years. "We agree that Britain will not join or prepare to join the euro in this parliament," the agreement states.

The Tories had pledged before the election "never" to lead Britain into the euro.

The Liberal Democrats, the most Europhile of the UK's main political parties, had openly campaigned on a pro-European ticket.

"Britain must work together with its partners abroad if we are to have the best hope of meeting the challenges the world faces," read the Lib Dem manifesto, which included a pledge "to work through the European Union to deliver a global deal on climate change".

"Liberal Democrats believe that European co-operation is the best way for Britain to be strong, safe and influential in the future. We will ensure that Britain maximises its influence through a strong and positive commitment," the manifesto stated.

Uneasy truce?

It remains to be seen how effectively the two parties will be able to paper over long-standing differences between their attitudes to the EU.

Indeed, a live TV debate between the prime ministerial hopefuls just three weeks ago saw Tory leader David Cameron and Lib Dem chief Nick Clegg clash openly on the issue (EurActiv 23/04/10).

Claiming that his opponents "just give in to everything that comes out of Brussels and do not stand up for the country," Cameron pledged that his government would be "in the EU, not run by it".

Clegg, meanwhile, accused Cameron of wanting to isolate the UK on the global stage. He drew attention to the Tories' decision to withdraw from the biggest group in the European Parliament, the European People's Party, to form an alliance with the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR), who he described as"a bunch of nutters and homophobes who deny climate change".

"We want to lead in Europe, not sit on the sidelines," said Clegg, insisting that "we punch above our weight when we stand together in Europe".

New Prime Minister David Cameron is expected to finalise his government team today.

Positions: 

Speaking after David Cameron's appointment as prime minister, Tory MP and prominent Eurosceptic Bill Cash was quoted by the Independent as saying that "the proof of the pudding will be in the eating. The proposals will not come from Downing Street or the Foreign Office, but from the European Commission".

"The question is how you react to them - do you say 'yes' or 'no' when they can be approved under qualified majority voting? [when Britain would not have a veto]" he asked.

"It is very simple. Implementing the Lisbon Treaty is a further transfer of power, and so the answer is 'no' because we [the Tories] voted against it. Full stop," Cash said.   

Open Europe, a British think-tank, congratulated the coalition on committing themselves to holding a referendum on future treaty changes and for opposing any shift towards more decisions being taken further away from "individuals, communities and parliament". 

Calling on the UK government "to push for genuine EU reform, including repatriating powers from Brussels," the organisation said "the coalition must break with the Labour government's record, and be fully honest with voters about when powers are being transferred from Westminster to Brussels - and take the voters' side in opposing such moves". 

Open Europe Director Mats Persson said: "The Con-Lib coalition could be a powerful force for EU reform, and should be congratulated for its pledge to keep the EU's ever-growing powers in check. It must now have the courage to promote long overdue changes in Europe, both at home and abroad. Failure to do so will be bad for Europe, bad for Britain and would undermine the legitimacy of the coalition."

"What cannot happen is for the new government to adopt the calculating, spinning, referendum-dodging approach of its predecessor in order to avoid facing up to the electorate and honouring its pledges, particularly on the transfer of powers to Brussels. If that becomes the case, you could forgive backbenchers and voters for opting for a rejection of the coalition. "

Background: 

David Cameron's Conservatives and the smaller Liberal Democrat party led by Nick Clegg struck an agreement on Wednesday (12 May) to form the UK's first coalition government since 1945 after a general election had failed to produce an outright winner (EurActiv 12/05/10).

The Conservatives became the largest party in parliament after winning the closest election in three decades on 6 May. But the poll delivered a hung parliament after voters failed to deliver the Tories a clear majority (EurActiv 07/05/10).

The Tories secured 306 of the 649 constituencies. Labour finished with 258 MPs, down 91, the Lib Dems won 57 seats, down five, and other parties secured 28.

Clegg held coalition talks with both Labour and the Conservatives before opting to form a government with the Tories. 

More on this topic

More in this section

Advertising

Advertising

Advertising