The Brief, powered by Eurogas – The tide may be turning in Catalonia

 

Republishing an updated, complete version of the Brief.

Over the last decades, Spaniards have been obsessed with numbers. During the Great Recession, public debt´s risk premiums were debated on TV as frequently as celebrities’ love affairs.

Now that the economic crisis is over, we are all becoming experts on legal affairs as the country faces its biggest political crisis since the end of the dictatorship. Catalonia’s bid for independence has made 155 the most popular number in Spain.

The central government invoked this article of the constitution as the showdown between Madrid and Barcelona finally came this morning. Spanish Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy can now adopt “the necessary measures” to force the Catalan government to return to the legal order, as the region “seriously” threatened Spain’s general interest.

The reason is Catalan President Carles Puigdemont’s half-baked declaration of independence on Tuesday.

In an Orwellian use of words, Puigdemont suspended an independence that he barely declared.  He said that the illegal referendum held on 1 October represented a “yes” for Catalexit even if only around 40% of the registered voters had backed this option. And he offered dialogue “with responsibility and generosity” to Madrid, when what he really wants is the central government to sit down and talk with a gun at its head.

We all know how well it worked out when you threatened your parents with leaving home if they didn’t accept your demands…

This time Rajoy has learnt the lesson, compared to the ill-conceived initial response to the referendum.

Article 155 that he has activated can be reversed with no consequences if only Puigdemont comes back from his wonderland. Rajoy forged a unified position with the Socialists and Ciudadanos, a liberal party. And he offered a dignified escape route from this quagmire to the Govern by promising a reform of the Spanish constitution in six months.

A new arrangement to accommodate the region’s demands (mostly identity and money) as part of a parliamentary discussion would satisfy a majority of Catalans, and would make an international mediator superfluous, as it has always been.

In an ideal scenario, Puigdemont would return to the constitutional order. He would be forced to call a snap election as he would lose the support of the CUP, a radical backbenchers’ party. He would probably lose support but his region would win competences. At the end of the day, what is more independent, a stronger autonomy or a pariah state?

But it remains unclear what the Catalan president really wants to achieve. And when you don’t know what you want, it is hard to satisfy your needs.

If Puigdemont remains defiant, Rajoy will be forced to bring the Govern down, most likely prosecute its members, and call snap elections.

Rajoy could retain the upper hand if he remains cool-headed because the events seem to be unfolding in his favour now.

The exodus of companies from Catalonia will continue hurting its effort and the international pressure to restore the order will increase. And the majority of Catalans (52%) who supported the Constitutional order in the last regional elections will remain, if not grow.

But the situation could easily get out of control as protesters would take to the streets in far greater numbers than when a dozen of mid-level Catalonian officials were arrested. And as long as the pro-independence forces remain in the streets, their victory will be still a possibility.

While Rajoy trusts that reason will prevail among his opponents, Puigdemont is praying for an impulsive reaction from the other side to bring the 52% to his camp and win the desired legitimacy.

Another mistake like the one on 1 October and Rajoy would sadly verify that you don’t need to conquer land to win a revolution, but just maintain your army alive and kicking.


Renewable gas – biogas, synthetic gas or hydrogen – is instrumental in enrolling the new generation of energy provision and adopting the circular economy approach. It is a key player at the nexus of waste utilisation, renewable energy deployment, and industrial and agricultural efficiency. Watch this for more. #newgas4EU

The Roundup

“When bulls fight, the grass suffers”, goes an old saying. The grass is the EU in the crisis between Catalonia and Spain. Standing on the sideline would have “devastating repercussions” for everyone involved, writes Simon Toubeau.

In the latest corrida episode, Spain could suspend Catalonia autonomy following its quizzical declaration of independence – immediately suspended by independent leader Puigdemont.

For those who hoped for a British food renaissance, it is time to wake up. British farmers face “a cuts agenda” as Brexit unravels EU farm subsidies.

On e-health, the Estonian presidency is ready to go ahead with a “coalition of the willing”. Is this another instance of Europe à la carte or the way to move ahead?

Read our interview with the head of EU chemicals agency on pioneering health and environmental protection rules,  chemical heavy lobbying and his retirement plans.

Commission tells off member states for their  “patchy” implementation of the pesticide directive.

Leading glyphosate expert, and consultant in a US court case against Monsanto will speak at the European Parliament’s hearing on the controversial weedkiller.

No more Grenfell Towers – how fire safety is being streamlined into EU regulation on energy efficiency of buildings.

Lighting the way: intelligent bulbs can save energy, enhance our well-being and our health. How? Read our special report on lighting.

Member states are playing dodge ball with their climate commitments: the effort sharing regulation, to be voted this Friday, attracted criticism for lowering emissions by 23% instead of 30%.

Flying on biofuels? Aan environmental plane-crash, argues Almuth Ernsting, director of Biofuelwatch. Here is why.

Three Fs for fixing the EU’s carbon market mechanism: funds, flexibility, and free allocation. Rachel Williams gives her recipe for keeping up with the Paris Agreement on climate change.

Following the Nobel ceremony, who will MEPs give their freedom of thought prize to? The Venezuelan opposition, a Guatemalan indigenous leader, and an imprisoned Eritrean writer are the unlucky contestants.

Almost no progress on safe migration in the EU: Oxfam’s damning report comes ahead of tomorrow’s vote on an EU framework for refugee resettlement.

“Freedom” on the internet has a largely misunderstood and unclear meaning. We should take this word seriously, and start thinking of how to regulate it, writes MEP Helga Trüpel.

Look out for….

Justice and home affairs ministers meet tomorrow in Brussels to beef up the EU’s prosecutor on EU fraud, and to discuss Schengen’s internal borders and migration.

Views are the author’s

Subscribe to The Brief