German Finance Minister Wolfgang Schäuble said on Tuesday (20 August) for the first time that Greece will need another bailout, triggering a storm of protest from opposition parties five weeks before an election in Europe's biggest economy.
While analysts have long predicted Greece will require more aid, albeit on a smaller scale than previous bailouts totalling about €240 billion, Chancellor Angela Merkel has tried to keep Greece out of her campaign for re-election to avoid angering German voters who fear they will foot the bill.
Just hours before Schäuble spoke, Merkel was quoted in a regional newspaper as saying there was no point in discussing additional aid to Greece before the end of next year, when its second rescue package will expire.
But at a campaign event in northern Germany, her outspoken minister departed from that line, breaking what had been seen as an election campaign taboo.
"There will have to be another programme in Greece," Schäuble admitted.
Schäuble has said in the past that international lenders may have to consider a new aid programme for Greece after the existing one runs out at the end of 2014. But he has never described this as inevitable, as he appeared to do on Tuesday.
‘Tell the truth’
The finance minister’s comments played into the hands of opposition leaders, who have accused Merkel of failing to tell voters the truth about Greece throughout the election campaign.
"I have made clear that saving Europe and keeping the continent together comes at a cost, also for us Germans," Merkel's Social Democrat (SPD) challenger Peer Steinbrück said after Schäuble spoke. "Now it's time that Frau Merkel tells people the truth."
Greens leader Jürgen Trittin said Schäuble had exposed Merkel's "deceit" and criticised the chancellor for advocating austerity policies in Greece that had failed to reduce its debt load.
Progress on reform in recession-stricken Greece has been patchy and there have been several reports that it may need another aid package or more debt relief.
As Europe's biggest economy, Germany takes the biggest share of the bailouts, which are unpopular with taxpayers.
Merkel looks on track to win a third term next month, in part because voters applaud the hard line she has taken with bailed-out countries like Greece.
But any indication she is covering up the risks of another rescue could hurt her at a time when she is battling to win the votes needed to keep her centre-right coalition together.
"Greece is a dangerous subject. It is not clever to bring it up again just as there was a general feeling of calm," said Emnid pollster Klaus-Peter Schöppner.
In the interview with the Ruhr Nachrichten newspaper, Merkel was asked about additional aid for Athens and responded: "In the euro zone, we always said that we would evaluate the Greek situation again at the end of 2014 or in early 2015. It makes sense to stick to this timeline."
€11 billion funding gap
A Greek finance ministry official said a new bailout would involve sums far smaller than previous rescues and would focus on plugging an expected funding shortfall over 2014-2016.
The new Greek package will be at least partly financed via the EU’s regional aid budget, according to German newspaper Süddeutsche Zeitung. The paper cited government sources in Berlin as saying that it would be much smaller than the first two and the conditions would also be less strict as Greece has already set a lot of the necessary changes in motion.
The International Monetary Fund last month estimated Greece's funding gap for 2014-2015 at €10.9 billion.
Athens hopes to cover part of that gap by returning to bond markets, which it could do as early as 2014 with a "small-size" bond issue, Finance Minister Yannis Stournaras told Reuters last month. But market observers increasingly doubt the situation has improved enough to allow a bond market return next year.
Schäuble’s comments came shortly after the European Central Bank said Executive Board member Jörg Asmussen would be heading to Athens on Wednesday to discuss progress on reforms needed to ensure the country receives more bailout money.
Greece received an aid tranche of €5.8 billion from its international lenders in July. It stands to receive another €1 billion in October, subject to implementation of further reforms.
Inspectors from the "troika" – the European Commission, European Central Bank and IMF – will return to Athens in the autumn to find out whether the government needs to find further savings to meet its 2015-2016 budget targets.
As a prelude, Asmussen will meet Central Bank Governor George Provopoulos, Finance Minister Yannis Stournaras and George Zanias, chairman of Greece's biggest lender, National Bank, on his trip this week, Greek sources told Reuters.
On 22 September 2013, Germans will decide in a federal election whether power remains within its current ruling conservative coalition, made up principally of Angela Merkel’s Christian Democratic Union, or whether to entrust it to the Social Democrats or a new coalition.
In the run up to the elections, Europe is largely staying off the agenda.
>> Read our LinksDossier: German elections 2013: Don't mention Europe
- 22 Sept.: German elections
- BBC: Greece will need new bailout, says Germany's Schaeuble
- Telegraph: Greece needs third bail-out, admits German finance minister
- Deutsche Welle: German Finance Ministry: Third Greek aid deal unavoidable
- The Guardian: If Greece needs a third bailout, Europe had better find a formula that sticks
- Zeit Online: Neues Griechenland-Hilfspaket soll kleiner ausfallen
- Süddeutsche.de: Athen soll Geld aus dem EU-Haushalt erhalten
- EURACTIV Germany: Griechenland: Einnahmen steigern und öffentliche Beschäftigung schaffen
- EURACTIV Germany: Standpunkt: Griechenland und die angeblich neoliberale Politik der Troika
EURACTIV Czech Republic: Schäuble ne?ekan? p?ipustil možnost t?etího záchranného balí?ku pro ?ecko
EURACTIV Slovakia: Schäuble pripustil ?alšiu pomoc Grécku
EURACTIV Germany: Kommt das dritte Hilfspaket?