The economic recovery is proving fragile for jobseekers in Spain, and has become a hot issue for voters, who are preparing to go to the polls for the second time, on 26 June, since an indecisive election was held in December last year.
“They hire you, they ditch you, they hire you and they ditch you again.”
Young and unemployed, Elena Martin sums up how difficult it has become to find a stable job in Spain, an issue that has made its way to the centre of sometimes acrimonious debate ahead of 26 June elections — the second in six months.
After seven years of economic crisis, the country returned to growth in 2014 and has seen its jobless queue shorten, with unemployment now standing at 20.1% from a peak of 26.9% in early 2013.
But that is still the second highest level in the 28-nation European Union after Greece.
And when acting Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy vaunts his government’s creation of 500,000 jobs a year as part of his re-election bid, his opponents retort that Spain is marred by “widespread precarity”, “junk contracts” and “poor workers”.
‘Strong’ but jobless recovery
Economist Raymond Torres, special advisor to the head of the International Labour Organisation (ILO), points to a “strong recovery” but adds that “Spain is still creating mainly precarious, temporary, unwanted part-time jobs.”
According to the country’s labour ministry, 90% of contracts that have been signed since the beginning of the year have been temporary.
And even acting Economy Minister Luis de Guindos has spoken of the “scourge” of temporary contracts.
“This makes sense at the beginning of a period of recovery as companies don’t really know what to expect,” says Torres, but he adds that the general instability of jobs is causing a structural problem in Spain.
Marcel Jansen, economics professor at the Autonomous University of Madrid, says Spain’s economy relies increasingly on low-value, low-skilled jobs in sectors such as tourism or telemarketing, which don’t pay well.
And crucially, Spanish entrepreneurs are now in the habit of considering that “their workers can be used and discarded like papers napkins,” he says.
“There are a lot of contracts that last less than a week and recently there has been talk of a boom in contracts that last just one day.”
The average length of contracts has gone from 79 days in 2006 to 53.4 last year, according to official figures.
Standing outside a job seekers’ office in Madrid, Martin says she has highlighted on her CV that she is “completely available”, which she hopes will compensate for her lack of university degree.
But since 2008, the 26-year-old has only managed to get a few fleeting jobs — phone operator, manager of a clothes shop where she was “completely exploited”, waitress and cashier.
And work instability is not only the preserve of those with no degree or few qualifications.
It also affects areas such as public health, with doctors and nurses often recruited part time, sometimes for just one weekend, says Manuel Lago, an economist at Spain’s largest trade union, the CCOO.
“Over the past ten years, 161 million work contracts have been signed in a country that counts an average of 14.5 million people in its workforce,” he says.
“That means that people keep entering and leaving companies and changing posts, activity and sectors at a frenetic pace.”
A 2012 labour reform brought in by the conservatives has done little to alleviate the problem, and critics say it has actually worsened it.
The reform has for instance brought in permanent contracts with one-year trial periods for companies with less than 50 employees, at the end of which a worker can be fired without explanation or compensation.
Dwindling salaries are also at the heart of the pre-electoral debate.
“There has been a marked increase in poor workers earning less than €690 a month,” says Torres.
To remedy this, Spain could increase its minimum wage — which stood at €757 a month over 12 months in 2015 — by 10% over three years without harming competitiveness or job creation, the ILO said in January.
On 18 May, the European Commission decided to delay potential fines against Madrid and Portugal for failing to meet their budget deficit targets, partly because of the upcoming Spanish elections on 26 June.
The Commission has pushed back triggering the sanction procedures until early July.
“We have concluded that this is not the right moment economically or politically to take this step,” European Economic Affairs Commissioner Pierre Moscovici told reporters after the college meeting.
However, there is a “broad acknowledgement” between the Commissioners on the lack of effective action taken by Madrid and Lisbon to meet their deficit targets, EU officials told EurActiv.com.
The Commission had prepared recommendations for stepping up infringement procedures against both countries, which ultimately would lead to imposing fines costing up to 2% of their GDP, the sources added.
But European Commission President Jean Claude Juncker was wary of the “political consequences” that such a decision could have caused days before the Spaniards go to the ballot box and the in-or-out referendum in the United Kingdom to be held on 23 June.
- 26 June: General election in Spain
- 28-29 June: EU summit in Brussels