Cosy arrangements between individual EU countries and energy suppliers such as Russia will create "a mess for investors and a mess legally," warned a top European Commission official.
Philip Lowe, the head of the Commission's directorate-general for energy, said the EU's 27 member states have opposed proposals to grant Brussels more powers to supervise energy deals with foreign countries.
The Commission proposed new rules earlier this month that would force EU states to share the details of planned energy accords in advance with Brussels and give the EU executive the power to negotiate some energy deals on behalf of governments.
Analysts have interpreted the plan as an attempt to prevent cosy bilateral ties between big gas consumers, such as Germany and Italy, and the EU's main supplier Russia.
"Without exception, all smaller member states strongly backed the direction of the paper," Lowe said after the 27 member states had set out their positions on the proposals earlier this week at an informal meeting of energy ministers in Poland.
"Without exception, all the major member states said 'well, we might be prepared to look at it on a case-by-case basis if there is some justification, but in other cases bilateral agreements are a national issue'," Lowe told an EU energy policy seminar held by the Brussels-based think-tank Bruegel.
Lowe said bigger EU governments had agreed on the need to ensure energy deals are in line with the bloc's internal energy market rules – but they were against revealing the details of such deals in advance, as proposed by the Commission.
"You don't need to be Einstein to work out what that all leads to: a mess. A mess for investors and a mess legally," Lowe said.
EURACTIV with Reuters
Günter Oettinger, the EU's energy commissioner, unveiled proposals on 7 September aimed at strengthening the EU's voice on energy matters vis-à-vis foreign countries such as Russia.
The proposals, laid down in a Communication on security of energy supply and international cooperation, would force EU states to share the details of planned energy accords in advance with Brussels, and giving the EU executive the power to negotiate some energy deals on behalf of governments.
It remains unclear if the policy proposals, which are non-binding, will ever become law, but Oettinger said he hoped EU countries would back it.
- European Commission:Communication on security of energy supply and international cooperation(7 Sept. 2011)
- European Commission:Press release on external dimension of the EU energy policy(7 Sept. 2011) [FR] [FR] [DE]
- European Commission:Energy: External dimension
- EURACTIV Czech Republic:Komise chce státy odradit od uzavírání „špinavých“ energetických dohod
- EURACTIV Slovakia:Brusel varuje pred neporiadkom v bilaterálnych energetických dohodách