EurActiv.com

EU news and policy debates across languages

24/08/2016

Member states face legal action over energy efficiency

Energy

Member states face legal action over energy efficiency

The European Commission is planning legal action against EU countries for their poor implementation of the Energy Efficiency Directive.

[TPCOM/Flickr]

EXCLUSIVE/ More than two thirds of EU countries face European Commission legal action and possible fines, after failing to translate the EU’s Energy Efficiency Directive into national law.

19 member states have missed the deadline by more than nine months, despite EU leaders at their summit last week calling for full implementation and rigorous enforcement of existing efficiency laws as part of the flagship Energy Union project.

EU officials told EurActiv that only nine nations had declared they had transposed the directive onto their national lawbooks. 16 have not fully transposed it, and three have made absolutely no progress, the source said.

The source would not reveal the names of the countries, citing possible future legal action by the European Commission. 

Italy, Malta, Cyprus and Sweden declared they had fully transposed the rules at the time of the 5 June 2014 deadline.

The European Commission is today (26 March) adopting its monthly infringements package, legal actions against countries not observing EU law.

It was thought to be too early for today’s procedures, which can ultimately end in fines imposed by the European Court of Justice, to include the 19 nations. But since publication the Commission has hit 27 member states, with the sole exception of Malta, with legal action.

>>Read: 27 member states hit with EU legal action over energy efficiency

Proceedings against Greece, Portugal and Slovenia for failure to fully implement the Energy Efficiency Directive began last month.

In November, Bulgaria and Hungary were asked by the executive to fully transpose the rules, one of the steps before stronger legal action.

Toughen up

The Commission has a policy of not communicating about its infringement procedures before they are announced. But the executive has signalled its intent to toughen up on countries unwilling to fully implement EU efficiency laws.

>>Read: Brussels toughens up on policing EU energy efficiency laws.

Its blueprint for Energy Union, backed by leaders at their meeting in Brussels, demands “fully implementing and rigorously enforcing” efficiency laws.

>>Read: Leaders broadly endorse ‘Energy Union’ plans, leave details to later

Energy and Climate Action Commissioner Miguel Arias Cañete told EurActiv earlier this month that the Commission would take action.

The Commission is on track at the moment to launch all infringement procedures against all the member states who have not applied the regulation in many areas – but mainly in energy efficiency,” Cañete said.

http://www.euractiv.com/video/commission-regulate-and-incentivise-building-energy-efficiency-312843

Research

Analysis by the Coalition of Energy Savings found that most member states had not presented credible plans to deliver the directive’s requirement to save at least 1.5% end-use energy annually.

Denmark and Ireland were the only countries to present credible plans, the Coalition said after it assessed the implementation of article seven of the directive.

French NGO CLER has also reported France to the Commission for not implementing the law properly.

Member states have only half-heartedly embraced, or are simply non-compliant, with the EU’s Energy Efficiency Directive, which came into force in late 2012, according to analysis by the Buildings Performance Institute Europe last year.

Under article four of the directive, countries are obliged to publish national renovation strategies. Six EU nations, Greece, Hungary, Luxembourg, Poland, Portugal and Slovenia, missed the April publication deadline by six months. 

Other member states, such as Austria, Denmark and the Netherlands were not compliant, according to BPIE. France, Germany and the Brussels Capital Region were just partially compliant. The research showed that the United Kingdom, Czech Republic, Romania and Spain’s strategies were acceptable, but there was still room for improvement.

>> Read: Governments ignoring EU building renovation rules

Background

The European Union's Energy Efficiency Directive in late 2012 was expected to trigger the largest revamp of Europe's existing building stock to date and set new standards for public procurement and energy audits. But implementation of the rules at national level has been poor. The EED is as close as the EU comes to an EU-wide energy efficiency strategy anchored by legislation.

The Energy Union will cut across a number of policy sectors including energy, transport, research and innovation, foreign policy, regional and neighbourhood policy, trade and agriculture, according to the EU executive's plans. 

Plans for the Union have developed beyond questions of security of supply to encompass issues such as fighting climate change.

>>Read: Special Report: An Efficient Energy Union