Pressure is mounting on the European Union to ‘fly the flag’ in Haiti, with the country seemingly becoming a test case for showcasing the bloc’s revamped institutions under the Lisbon Treaty.
EU foreign ministers are gathering in Brussels today for a two-day meeting during which Europe’s response to the situation in Haiti will be high on the agenda.
Herman Van Rompuy, the EU’s new permanent president, has asked heads of state and government to discuss the situation at their informal summit on 11 February.
An extraordinary ministerial meeting last Monday had already committed 92 million euros in humanitarian assistance to the disaster-hit Caribbean country, which came on top of a European Commission commitment of 30 million euros. For early non-humanitarian assistance, notably to restore the government’s capabilities, the EU earmarked another 100 million euros.
This time, ministers will discuss putting in place a ‘gendarmerie’-style force under the UN’s command. It was not clear before the meeting whether the EU would make use of the European Gendarmerie Force (EGF), based in Italy, or whether individual countries would send gendarmerie troops outside this framework, diplomats said.
The EFG consists of six member countries – France, Italy, the Netherlands, Portugal, Spain and Romania. Some countries, like the UK, do not have gendarmerie forces and will not participate in these efforts.
Television reports have conveyed the impression that American aid is massive and that US forces are replacing Haiti’s government in dealing with the disaster. French reporters said that the US army, which has control of the capital’s airport, is giving American planes landing priority.
TV reports quoted citizens of Haiti bitterly complaining that foreign powers, such as the USA, France and Canada, are taking advantage of the disaster to compete for influence and international prestige.
France apparently nurtures ambitions of a greater presence in Haiti, “a country which suffers in the French language,” Jean-Pierre Raffarin, France’s special envoy for francophony, recently told journalists in Brussels, noting that the parent language of Creole, the local tongue, is French.
EU institutional controversy
In recent days, EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs Catherine Ashton has been criticised for not having travelled to Haiti.
Although her diplomatic service is still being put in place, the merits of having for the first time an EU foreign affairs chief at the same level as a US Secretary of State is already being questioned.
Speaking to Brussels-based journalists, an ambassador from one of the large EU member states said the urgency lay in providing assistance to the victims, not in discussing institutional matters.
“Helping the victims, this is what matters. One should not get lost in theoretical discussions. We are in an emergency,” he pleaded.
Conceding that he understood potential perception problems amongst the public at large about the EU’s response to the crisis, the diplomat said time was needed before the new European institutions are fully in place.
For one, he pointed out that Ashton would not be formally invested with her new functions until a vote of approval on the Barroso II line-up had taken place in the European Parliament on 9 February.
“This new European Union needs time to put itself into place,” he said, adding: “The European External Action Service? It doesn’t exist. The draft decision should be adopted, inch’ allah, at the end of April. This is an extremely close deadline.”
The diplomat further insisted that the EU’s response to crises such as Haiti was a team effort, implying the involvement of ministers from the 27 EU member states as well as that of EU foreign policy chief Ashton.
“If you want to see the same face everywhere, then clearly the idea behind the Lisbon Treaty is that, in terms of external relations, there is a High Representative who chairs a foreign affairs council and coordinates a team,” he said.
“I fully understand the political viewpoint that the European Union should manifest itself, etc. But, seriously, we are not going [to Haiti] simply for the pleasure of making ourselves seen when the emergency is to land humanitarian aid planes. Let’s keep a little decency,” the ambassador pleaded.
“The priority is still not that Mister X or Missus Y goes making themselves seen at Port-au-Prince, damn it,” the diplomat concluded colourfully.
A representative of Ashton’s cabinet told journalists on Friday that a visit by Ashton to Haiti was envisaged, but no date had been set yet.
Haiti is the poorest country in the Western hemisphere, and has experienced a lot of political violence throughout its history. In February 2004, an armed rebellion forced the resignation and exile of President Jean-Bertrand Aristide. A provisional government was put in place, with security provided by MINUSTAH, the United Nations Stabilisation Mission in Haiti. Réné Préval, the current president, was elected in 2006.
Scientists said the earthquake which hit Haiti on 12 January was the strongest on Earth since 1770. The damage was high, as the catastrophic 7.0 magnitude epicentre was just 10 miles west of Port-au-Prince and its two million inhabitants.
The number of deaths is yet to be determined, with estimations of 300,000 frequently cited. On 24 January the Haitian government announced that 150,000 bodies had already been buried in mass graves in Port-au-Prince alone.
The widespread devastation included vital infrastructure, including every hospital in the capital, air, sea and land communications, and telecommunications.
The initial foreign military presence comprised MINUSTAH and several US Coast Guard vessels, followed by larger ships, helicopter carriers and a floating hospital. French military vessels also docked in Port-au-Prince. In total, the US Navy lists its resources in the area as "17 ships, 48 helicopters and 12 fixed-wing aircraft" in addition to 10,000 sailors and Marines.
US President Barack Obama appointed former Presidents Bill Clinton and George W. Bush to help raise funds for Haiti's recovery. US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton visited Haiti on 16 January. French President Nicolas Sarkozy said that his country, together with the US, Brazil, Canada and others, would hold a conference on the reconstruction of Haiti.
EU Commissioner for Humanitarian Aid Karel de Gucht was in Port-au-Prince on 21 January. EU High Representative for Foreign Affairs Catherine Ashton met on the same day in Washington with Hillary Clinton. Both discussed the situation in Haiti, where in Clinton's words "one of the greatest rescue-and-relief efforts in the history of the world is underway".
- European Council:Solidarity with Haiti
- European Council:Council conclusions on the earthquake in Haiti
- European Council, The President:Statement by Herman Van Rompuy, President of the European Council, on Haiti:
- European Gendarmerie Force website:
- US Department of State:Remarks with EU High Representative for Foreign Policy Catherine Ashton
- US Navy:U.S. Fleet Forces Commander Provides Update on Navy Contributions to Haiti Relief Efforts
- The Telegraph:Haiti earthquake: Lady Ashton under fire over EU 'visibility'
- Reuters:French EU nominee downplays rift with UK on Haiti
- VOA:Death toll rises in Haiti quake to 150.000
- Le Monde:En Europe, premières critiques contre Catherine Ashton à l'occasion du séisme en Haïti
- Le Point, France:Haïti : la diplomate en chef de l'UE critiquée pour sa gestion de la crise
- France 24:Très critiquée, Catherine Ashton pourrait finalement se rendre en Haïti
- EurActiv Czech Republic:EU by m?la na Haiti ukázat, co dokáže
- EurActiv Hungary:Menni, vagy nem menni Haitira
- EurActiv Germany:Geld und Gendarmen für Haiti
- EurActiv Slovakia:EÚ chce, aby na Haiti „viala jej vlajka“
- EurActiv Slovakia:Ashtonovú kritizujú, že neodišla na Haiti
- Tony Barber, Brussels blog (FT):Strains are showing in the EU’s new foreign policy structures
- Nile Gardiner (The Telegraph):The EU's foreign policy chief is no Kissinger: Baroness Ashton proves a flop in Washington
- Jean Quatremer, Coulisses de Bruxelles (Libération):Haïti: Barnier critique Ashton
- Stanley Crossick (Blogactiv):Lisbon Treaty : managing expectations
- Stanley Crossick (Blogactiv):Haiti: action before photo-ops