Kyiv said Thursday (5 November) it would halt payment of state funds in areas controlled by pro-Moscow rebels, as both sides hardened positions in what is rapidly becoming a “frozen conflict”: a long-term stalemate that the West believes is Russia’s goal.
A day after the rebels held inauguration ceremonies for their leaders, the separatists and the central government each accused each other of violating a September peace deal and signalled they would withdraw support for some of its terms.
The past four days have seen the rebels stage elections for leadership which the government called illegal, and the government respond by saying it would revoke a law that would have granted eastern regions autonomy and sent them cash.
Despite a ceasefire declared two months ago, two teenagers were killed by shelling in Donetsk, one of the two separatist strongholds, on Wednesday as they played football on a school sports field, the city’s administration said.
The rebels say their newly elected leaders must be allowed to negotiate with Kyiv directly; Kyiv says this is impossible. Both sides’ positions reverse parts of the 12-point peace plan, the Minsk protocol, agreed on in Belarus, in September.
With Kyiv lacking the military might to break the rebels by force, Western allies now fear that a large chunk of Ukrainian territory will become a Russian protectorate with a parlous economic future, beyond the writ of the central government.
“We have now realistically entered the phase of a ‘frozen conflict’,” said Yury Yakimenko, a political analyst at Ukraine’s Razumkov political research centre, using a term often applied to other ex-Soviet republics where separatist enclaves have been protected by Russian troops since the early 1990s.
The American general who serves as the highest ranking NATO officer also said this week that the conditions for a frozen conflict were being created in Ukraine.
Russia seized and annexed Ukraine’s Crimea region in March, but has been more ambiguous about its intentions in eastern Ukraine, where it has supported separatist rebels but has not recognised their declarations of independence.
So far this week Moscow has stopped short of recognising the rogue elections held in Ukraine’s east on Sunday which elected leaders of two rebel “people’s republics” that jointly call themselves “New Russia”.
Western governments see the votes as part of a scenario, worked out in the Kremlin, to perpetuate instability in Ukraine after the ex-Soviet republic of 46 million shifted policy westwards following the overthrow of a Moscow-backed president.
Kyiv and the West fear Russian President Vladimir Putin’s grand design, following the annexation of Crimea in March, is to render Ukraine ineligible to become part of mainstream Europe, with a conflict left unresolved within its borders.Welcome sign, Novrussia. September 2014. [Karl Poggeman/Flickr]
Welcome to Novorussia. September 2014. [Karl Poggeman/Flickr]
“Russia will direct its efforts at supporting instability, at hindering the creation of Ukrainian law-based institutions and at increasing permanent instability,” Yakimenko said.
Russia has dismissed such suggestions and accuses the West of stoking the crisis by staging an “anti-constitutional coup” in Kyiv in February after months of street protests against a president who spurned a trade pact with the European Union.
Moscow denies sending in troops and weapons to support the rebels, although many of its soldiers died there, especially in August when Western governments say Russia dispatched armoured columns to protect the rebels from the defeat.
Ukrainian President Petro Poroshenko said on Tuesday the rebels had violated the Minsk agreement by holding elections outside Ukrainian rules, and that he would ask parliament to suspend a law that would give their regions a “special status”.
The rebels said this “seriously damaged” the Minsk protocol and signalled they would no longer abide by it.
The “special status” law would have given the two rebel regions Donetsk and Luhansk rights to elect local officials under Ukrainian law, offered separatist fighters freedom from prosecution for acts on the battlefield and guaranteed the flow of state funds to rebel-held areas until peace was restored.
Poroshenko said he wanted the law scrapped because he did not want to keep funding terrorists. The rebels had violated the Minsk agreement by breaking the ceasefire and failing to carry out prisoner exchanges, he said on Tuesday.
Prime Minister Arseny Yatsenyuk told a government meeting that Kyiv would continue to supply gas and electricity to the separatist regions but “so long as the territories of Donetsk and Luhansk regions are controlled by imposters, the central budget will not send funding there.”
The cut-off of funding would deprive the war-shattered rebel-held regions of money for schools, hospitals and infrastructure.
Pensions are still being paid into accounts of retired workers in rebel held areas, but banks there have been cut off, so recipients must move to other parts of Ukraine to collect them.
Both sides say they are still committed to continuing the Minsk peace process. Poroshenko has said he will propose a new law to provide a “special economic zone” for the east and set a new date for hoped-for Ukrainian-run local elections, originally planned for early December.
But Kyiv looks unlikely to agree to talks with separatist leaders as this would imply Kyiv’s formal recognition of them, and staging Ukrainian-approved elections in their territory seems impossible.
Isolating the separatists
Kyiv appears to be aiming now to isolate the separatist leadership rather than break it. The message on Wednesday was that the rebel leaders may have to turn to Moscow now for cash handouts and subsidies to finance their breakaway aspirations.
This is a risky strategy, as it could be seen as Kyiv abandoning Ukrainians living in rebel-held areas. But Poroshenko is not expected to order a new military offensive, despite issuing a decree on Wednesday that would raise defence spending to 3% of gross domestic product from 1%.
Ukrainian troops suffered big losses in August, when they were cut off by separatists Kyiv said were backed by Russian troops. Despite the ceasefire, more than 100 Ukrainian soldiers have been killed since the truce came into force.
“A ‘hot phase’ is still going on. There is no ‘frozen conflict’ here,” said Taras Berezovets of the Berta political research centre.
Kyiv’s military effort now puts less emphasis on taking back the Donetsk and Luhansk rebel strongholds than on protecting other cities from any further Russian-backed assault.
Poroshenko said on Tuesday he was sending newly formed units to cities including Mariupol on the Sea of Azov, a possible strategic target since it lies on a coastal route from the Russian border to Crimea.
In a decree made public on Wednesday aimed at strengthening the state’s defences, Poroshenko also ordered the government to work on a new model for guaranteeing national security, and re-introduced an old Soviet-era practice of providing basic military training in schools.
The West hailed the election in Ukraine held on 26 October which was won by pro-European parties representing the Prime Minister Arseny Yatsenyuk and the President Petro Poroshenko.
>> Read: West hails Ukraine’s election
But voting did not take place in areas held by the rebels or in Crimea and in eastern regions controlled by the pro-Russian rebels.
Poroshenko and his allies are trying to restore normalcy to the sprawling country of 46 million and draw a line under a year of upheaval that began with street demonstrations against Poroshenko's pro-Russian predecessor, Viktor Yanukovich.
Yanukovich was overthrown in February in what Russia called a "fascist coup" after he spurned a deal that would have deepened ties with the EU. Moscow responded by swiftly seizing and annexing the Crimea peninsula and backing the separatist rebellions. More than 4,000 people have been killed in the conflict, which has led to U.S. and European Union sanctions against Russia.