EU news and policy debates across languages


‘Mass murder’ reported off Malta, 500 drowned

Justice & Home Affairs

‘Mass murder’ reported off Malta, 500 drowned

Dead refugees on an Italian beach. [Reuters]

BREAKING: If the reports of two survivors prove to be true, 500 migrants from North Africa have been deliberately killed by human traffickers, who sank their boat following a dispute. If confirmed, this is the worst incident of its kind, amounting to mass murder, an official of the International Organization for Migration told EurActiv.

Leonard Doyle, IOM spokesperson in Italy, confirmed news broken by Maltese media that 500 migrants who were attempting to travel by boat from North Africa to Europe are feared to have drowned in the Mediterranean after their boat was sunk on purpose by traffickers.

The migrants, including many families and unaccompanied children, had left the Egyptian port city of Damiette on 6 September. According to Doyle, two of the migrants aboard the ship, who survived at sea for nearly two days, told the story that at some point the traffickers got into a dispute with the migrants, and sank the boat.

The dispute erupted after the traffickers asked the immigrants to board a smaller ship, which they saw as too dangerous. Smaller ships are abandoned by traffickers, while bigger ships are reused and lure prospective migrants on the Northern African shore, who imagine that they would be safe on board until they reach Europe.

“Some of [the migrants] were picked up by a Maltese and some by a Greek vessel. We’ve interviewed these two survivors, people who said they are survivors, and this is what they said”, Doyle said.

Asked about the magnitude of the incident as reported, Doyle said “of course this is mass murder”, provided that it is confirmed. “We don’t know what it is, [for the time being] we have allegations,” he said.

Asked if he could compare this incident with other violence reported in the past, Doyle explained that there have been cases when immigrants have been thrown overboard, or stabbed.

“This is obviously of a different order, but it’s in line with what we have heard before,” he said.

Asked if the two survivors could be considered as independent sources, Doyle responded that they seem to be independent.

“They seem to have been rescued separately […] We have one survivor validated by the other, for the moment,” he said.

Reportedly, one of the survivors was clinging on a life raft with seven people, of which five had disappeared in the sea, and was rescued by the Greek merchant ship Pegasus.

Asked how he could compare this incident with previous experience, Doyle said, “It looks like this is the worse incident that we’ve seen. It looks like certainly the worst this year, if it’s validated. Obviously, if it’s true, it’s very, very serious,” he said.

Asked if the EU response to the immigration challenge across the Mediterranean has been adequate, Doyle said that he could only confirm that the number of deaths was growing.

“It’s already more this year than last year, while it is declining in other parts of the world.”


IOM Greece staff in Crete today (16 September) interviewed more survivors of the deliberate shipwreck of migrants heading to Europe from Egypt, the IOM spokesperson in Italy Leonard Doyle announced.

The survivors provided corroboration that the traffickers turned violent when the 500 migrants they were escorting to Europe refused to switch to an unseaworthy boat.

The survivors told IOM Tuesday that they already had been forced to change boats three times.  When they refused a fourth switch - because they felt the smaller vessel was unsafe – an violent argument ensued. The smugglers threatened that if the passengers did not board the smaller boat they would be returned to Egypt, the survivors told IOM. The migrants persisted saying they would rather return than board the smaller boat.  

At this stage, according to testimony from four of six survivors, the ten smugglers, said to be Palestinian and Egyptian, began yelling and throwing sticks at the migrants.

The smuggler’s vessel approached the boat with migrants some of whom managed to jump into the smaller boat.  Witnesses say the smugglers forced them in the water and then rammed the bigger boat.  It began to sink immediately while the smugglers stayed in the area until they were certain that the migrant’s vessel had sunk, witnesses said.

“After they hit our boat they waited to make sure that it had sunk completely before leaving. They were laughing” one of the survivors told IOM.

“When the boat was first struck, one of the passengers killed himself in despair by hanging,” he added.

The survivors, women among them, included two Palestinian nationals, an Egyptian national and one Syrian.  All the witnesses stated that the smugglers were Palestinian and Egyptian nationals. 

The two Palestinian survivors in Crete said their voyage began hopefully at what they called a “travel” office in Gaza, which made arrangements to get them to Italy.  The cost of travel for each migrant was US$2000, paid in advance.  The survivors said they had received grants to rebuild their homes and used that to pay the smugglers. The migrants were advised by the “travel” office to be in a particular spot in Egypt so that they could travel onwards by boat.

According to their statements, they arrived separately at the rendezvous in Egypt where four buses waited to take them to the Port of Damietta near Alexandria.  The survivors estimated that each bus contained up to 100 persons. At the port they boarded a ship, which they estimated was 15-18 metres long with migrants already aboard.

“When we got to the port to board it looked like the ship was already half full,” the witness said.

The Captain did a headcount, and without including minors under 10 years old, counted 400-450 migrants.  Based on this testimony IOM believes that up to 100 children may have been aboard and are lost at sea.

According to witnesses testimony the ship had two decks with 300 people below and 200 on the upper deck. They were at sea for four days and had to change to smaller vessels three times.  Witnesses stated that the 300 people who were in the lower deck were trapped and drowned immediately.  The survivors say they watched as those thrown in the water clung to each other trying to stay alive.

“The rest of us linked arms in a circle so that no one else would be lost,” a survivor told IOM in Crete.

 Several managed to stay above the water for up to three days.  But on the third day the weather changed: strong winds and waves swept the area and people began to disappear under the water. 

Sometime later a freighter picked up nine survivors.  Seven of these, including a 2 year-old girl were flown by a Greek military helicopter to hospital in Crete.  One of the survivors perished and a girl remains in critical condition.

Survivors in Crete have provided the authorities’ information on the criminal gangs to the Greek Coastguard. 


Further Reading